I went and they had a great selection. I didn't face any snooty shop keepers there. Not sure if…read morethey have different people working at different times. The prices are great and they have good inventory on blazers, slacks and suits, especially. Definitely recommend.

Consignors beware. I…read moreconsigned two blazers with Gentlemen's Resale on May 26, 2026. Their written receipt states that sale information is updated on the 15th of each month for the prior month. Since then: No June update. No July update. No August update. Multiple emails have gone unanswered. Each time I have called, I have been told there is a growing "backlog." I visited the store and neither item was on the sales floor. I still have not been told whether my items were sold, what they sold for, or when I will be paid. On my latest call, this past Monday, I was again told that there was a significant backlog, that nothing further could be done at that point, and that my complaint would be passed along to accounts payable. When I asked whether the business was going under and at risk of defaulting on consignors, there was some hesitation followed by what I would characterize as a half-hearted denial. I obviously do not know Gentlemen's Resale's actual financial condition. But after more than three months without an accounting, payment, or meaningful response--and repeated references to a growing backlog--I am seriously concerned about what is happening with consignors' property and money. I am posting this publicly in the hope that Gentlemen's Resale will finally provide an immediate accounting of my two items and pay any proceeds that are due. I will update this review promptly if they resolve the matter. Update: they finally answered my emails. The jackets had been sold. I eventually received payment for them.

Service good. Friends and helpful staff. Just v. Poor quality …read more For the price you pay. Not great. Would recommend Levi's

Today AG Jeans lost a very loyal customer. I bought 3 pairs about 8 months ago which I rotated on…read morea regular basis and wore moderately frequently. One pair developed a linear relatively clean tear in the right back pocket with the surrounding fabric pristine. The fabric underneath was also pristine. I went in expecting to get a new replacement pair for what most likely was a defect in the fabric making it prone to a tear. Instead I got an offer to purchase a new pair at 30% off. To me that is very poor customer service and very shortsighted. They lost a very good customer. In the future I will buy as good if not better jeans at stores like Nordstrom where you pay for what you get.

Illustrator at your September 18 event was incredibly racist and rude. Made snide comments about…read moremy appearance. Did a half-assed job on the illustration and was snarky about my dog throughout. NOT RECOMMENDED.

I check in once in a while because I like to buy certain things that are stand outs like my…read moreburgundy suede bag this season.

A must for fashion hunting! The selection was vast and must have patience to look through…read moreeverything so nothing is missed. Found enough items that I needed an extra suitcase to store all the amazing finds. A must for NYC consignment shoppers.

After reading the reviews, I was honestly hesitant to write this--but I feel it's important to…read moreshare my experience. I'm appalled by the way Jonathan, the owner, responds to many of the 1-star reviews here on Yelp. Not only does he appear to respond mostly to negative feedback, but his tone often comes across as rude and overly defensive. Jonathan, having a business for 30 years doesn't give you a free pass to be dismissive toward people who are simply sharing their experiences. There's always room for growth and improvement. Instead of being combative, take the time to really listen to your customers and consider their concerns--this could lead to positive changes and an even better shopping experience. That said, I visited this consignment store a few days ago, and Jonathan himself was actually very helpful and knowledgeable. He took the time to explain the consignment process and was very pleasant throughout. The store itself is a bit overcrowded with clothing and shoes, which can feel overwhelming, but the selection is solid and the pricing is reasonable considering the focus on high-end pieces. While the clothing leans more mature, there are definitely options for all ages. This shop is exclusively for women--I didn't see any men's items, but that's not a dealbreaker for me. The clearance section is located upstairs, and while I did find a lot of regular designer names, I didn't spot many high-end pieces there aside from a few pairs of shoes. Also, the upstairs area definitely needs better ventilation--AC or at least a few fans would make a big difference, as it was uncomfortably warm. As for handbags, I might have missed them since I was more focused on clothes and shoes, but I didn't see any notable high-end options in that category during my visit. I plan to return soon with more time to explore. Despite my concerns about how the owner responds to feedback online, I didn't experience any issues personally during my visit. I actually had a positive shopping experience, and I would recommend this store. I just hope that in the future, there's some improvement in how customer feedback is handled publicly--it really does make a difference.

They have some super cute things but are a bit pricey for the quality. T-shirts were around $70 and…read morelittle skirts the same. A lot to choose from but it's similar to forever 21 but a small step up. There was a staff shortage as the other reviews stated, I couldn't find anyone to help me so I left.

Cute trendy clothes. Very pricey and geared toward the young. I did buy some beautiful sweaters…read morelast year. Will check it out again

A lovely little boutique with lots of charm. I came across this place while I walking on Amsterdam…read moreand took a peek in. While the clothes were reasonably priced, I found the jewelry to be a bit pricey but the quality is good. I bought a beautiful and sparkly bracelet for my mom which she loved by the way. Hope they get more cute stuff and maybe reduce the price a bit. Last point, the lady at the counter was friendly and not pushy, helpful and honest.

While walking around on a a Saturday afternoon, I saw this place had some sale items and decided to…read morecheck it out. It turned out to be a very positive shopping experience. The young girl working there was very helpful, (maybe a slight bit pushy, but she was also really nice, so I can overlook it.) I found an awesome pair of skinny jeans. I have NEVER been able to find skinny jeans that fit right, and don't make me feel like a fat ass, but I was in luck at this store. They even offered to call another store if I wanted another color that they didn't have in my size there. They were a little expensive, but it's a Manhattan boutique, so it's to be expected. The jeans I bought here were cheaper than some, but more expensive than others....If I lived in the neighborhood, I'd probably shop here for certain items.

Such beautiful clothing hand made in nyc. Highly recommend if looking for quality and craftsmanship…read more(or craftswomanship) that transcends passing trends.

I stopped in a few days ago and what a beautiful store!! The girls in the store were very helpful…read morebut gave me my space as I wandered around. They ended up keeping the store open past closing because I couldn't make up my mind about which dress to buy. After all of the back and forth I realized that i had forgotten my wallet and they held my dress till the following day with no attitude. This brand is truly special - I wish i could buy the whole store!!

Best children clothing store around. I shop for all five of my children there ages 2-12!read more

Great experience buying my granddaughter's first pair of shoes today. Very helpful and…read moreknowledgeable staff person who has been there for 15+ years. It was my first time there and I will definitely be back! So many cute clothes and things and great shoe selection. Thank you!