Pizza is great and the staff is friendly and quick! It is good pizza for people who don't like a lot of sauce and fresh toppings.

The pizza was delish. The service not so great. I was the only customer and there to pick up a pizza. They totally ignored me Until I. Spoke up. And then they weren't the friendliest. I could tell they were restocking boxes, etc. and i tried to give them the benefit of the doubt, but they could have said" be right there". Its decorated nicely and there is plenty of room for even big groups. Keep your fingers crossed for good service! read more

if you like soggy pizza, this is for you. even after multiple attempts to get them to cook it well done or crispy, it's just a soggy greasy mess. My husbands was just as bad. Cheese odd, no sauce and what little it had was bland. It will be a long time before we try again. sad. even tried to cook it more at home, but was just bad. read more

We did a carry out order and didn't have to wait long at all. Loved the pizza! Didn't care for the breadsticks but would totally go back. read more

Abe's Pizza - Large thick crust pizza with pepperoni, onion, and bell pepper - Pizza Near Me - Monticello, Indiana

1st time there ...(and last)...enjoyed a halfway decent Italian sun on a nice roll. The dressing was ok..could have been better...roll could have been toasted..Oh, I forgot, started with breadsticks and the owner must think a small spoonful of marinara is adequate to keep 5 breadsticks dipping. (Barely enough for 1)....the sandwich comes with chips. I hope you don't mind a tiny handful of the smashed bottom of the bag because that is what was served....(typo ; Sub sandwich). Don't go thirsty unless you enjoy a large glass of crushed ice with a couple swallows of lemonade, and don't mind sitting for a whe to get a refill... read more

Grabbed a pizza while in town for a track meet. Reasonable price. Pizza was delicious! Wish that wasn't an hour away from home!

The mini pizzas are very filling, small but piled high with toppings. I had the mini veggie pizza today and it was topped with so many veggies you couldn't see the crust. The breadsticks were very tasty! Service was a little slow at lunch, they seemed to have quite a few carry out orders. Our server was very friendly, the little dining room was homelike and the atmosphere made us feel like we were eating in the home of a friend. read more

We have ordered twice from here and been disappointed. The sauce and crust have little to no flavor and the cheese is very strange. The prices aren't bad, it's just not worth it. We tried the deep dish to see if we just ordered the wrong crust but it wasn't any deeper than the original crust we had previously ordered. I wanted to love it but sadly wasn't able to. read more

GOOD FOOD, FRIENDLY SERVICE Tired of chain restaurants? Give Abe's Pizza a try. Go for their salads, pizza and bread sticks. Come back for their friendly service and clean restaurant.... Abe's is a locally owned and family operated business with great food and good first jobs for area students. What more could you want? read more

See all

The pizza is very good. Great quality food, fast delivery to my home, friendly staff and a clean facility!!

Great little pizza spot. Breadsticks were great and pizza was filling. No frills dining but nice little spot for a local pizza.

Nice little place in downtown monticello. Super cheap and good food. To manage expectations, food is on paper/plastic plates but the place is clean. They deliver as well. read more

Great service. We loved the pizza and potatoes wedges! Happy to find pizza out here we actually like!

I LOVE Abe's! It is one of the first places I stop when I get in town to visit. Couldn't be more happy with the service every time I come in and in all the time I've eaten their taco salad they are still just as good as they were almost 20 years ago!!!!! If you've never eaten here before you MUST start with breadsticks with cheese AND sour cream!!! Delicious read more

Tried to order dinner from a hometown restaurant. Pleasant on the phone, hadn't been in the area for years. . . Depressing decor, still, Abe's right? Get to the counter to pay for my order, they won't accept my debit card for the total of $9.90, only for ten or more. No, how about a cookie, just No. the girl rolled her eyes when I pointed out it was 10 cents, told her my choice was to leave it, manager came over and picked up the food and said "ok" took it to the back. I suspect he was the owner, I know he likes more than $.10 on that order. And I know now that I've moved back to the area he's washed my business forever. Over $.10 read more

A great local mom and pop pizza joint. No frills and no thrills but solid pizza. It had a quiet atmosphere and wasn't super busy. Service and employees were excellent. Prices listed are for cash, so if you use CC it is 4% more. If you are in Monticello, give them a shot. read more

One of the best pizza places in Monticello. We aren't huge fans of thin crust pizza so it's nice to have another delivery option. We always get the thick and chewy crust and an order of breadsticks with cheese! read more

Pizza was OK not great!! Service was terrible we had to continue to go up to the counter every time we needed some thing. The waitress never came back. Not worth stopping. read more

This pizza place made me feel like I was at home & my Mother was making pizza. Their breadsticks are to die for, so I'd high recommend them to anyone. The taste of the pizza made my mouth water for more- but it's very filling, so 1-2 slices may fill you up. The staff is very friendly and so courteous, they'll make you feel at easy in this Pizzeria. I would definitely recommend you to come try this Pizzeria. read more

I went to sit down when I found gum on my butt. I had gum on my butt. And poop was smeared on my table. Yummy very appetizing. The food tasted like srirachi sauce. I would have rather went to the movie theater and eaten Popcorn off the floor. Why do places in town love poop?! read more

Love the food, but this place is getting pricey! Too much for pizza. Breadsticks are awesome!

Abe's serves the best breadsticks I've ever eaten, but the pizza is nothing extraordinary. I've been going to Abe's for 7 years and will keep going as long as they have those delicious, doughy breadsticks. read more

Found them on the web and choose them from their Yelp reviews. We were not disappointed! We ordered 8 large pizzas of all varieties and they took care of it without a hitch! They even delivered to the campground and were very timely and communicated when they were leaving! You made 21 fans of this place! read more

Everytime I go into town, I specifically make time to stop at Abe's. Not only is the food great, the staff is friendly and attentive. One of the best pizza restaurants I've ever been to. The breadsticks are mind blowing !!! read more

We waited 45 minutes for a small pizza and breadsticks. The people in line after us got their food before we did.

Found this place during a recent trip to France Park and had an awesome lunch at a great price. The staff was so pleasant! Definitely will come back when in the area. The breadsticks were great. We had a supreme pizza which was loaded with toppings and very tasteful. My daughter had the taco salad which also was excellent. Great restaurant, staff and food!! read more

this place is crap but i guess to reach your own....... i didnt even have a little fun but u can buy pizza here so i guess if u wanty it u can get it. the guy was mean at the door read more

Tired of chain restaurants? Give Abe's a try. Go for their salads, pizza and bread sticks. Come back for their friendly service and clean restaurant.... It's a locally owned and family operated business with great food and good first jobs for area students. What more could you want? read more

My one and only time here.. My "date" had sworn on Abe's pizza and breadsticks.. Pizza ended up looking and tasting like a bad freezer pizza and the sticks were microwaved, pre cooked supermarket breadsticks out of a plastic bag.. Service was bad too because some of help had called off.. We didn't even finish and both swore off the place.. It was too bad, had hoped it would live up to the hype.. read more

Pizza as bad as the so called pizza king.. YUK Want a real pizza go to Double D's on Six street. Best pizza in town. Tell Bee Phil sent ya!! read more