Well, TEN STARS!! Just an incredible experience from beginning to end. The place was jampacked and…read moreI felt like we were the only ones in there. The ice cream was so good. Cody was lovely! He communicated crystal clear that we were only allowed to try two flavors. The two flavors I got I actually enjoyed. Peanut butter and cake batter. I appreciate people who are clear and kind. I would definitely go there again because of him

I got 2 chocolates: 1 dark chocolate mog bar and 1 milk chocolate whisky truffle.Both were super…read moretasty. Came out to $5 which is very affordable for hand made chocolate. The staff here is also so friendly.

Overall great ice cream place. We've visiting both the Vineyard Heaven and Oak Bluff location and…read morethey both were great. The staff at both locations were very friendly and while it gets busy, they are very fast and efficient. They offer a rewards card so you can earn a free ice cream. Ambiance is like your classic ice cream shop and they have a great selection of flavors. The Oak Bluffs location is bigger, which allows for more inside seating.

I visited Mad Martha's in Oak Bluffs around 8PM today (8/18) and asked to sample the black…read moreraspberry flavor before purchasing it since I had never tried it before. The employee refused. Normally, that wouldn't be a big deal--except I had just watched several white customers on either side of me receive samples without any issue. They were treated kindly and allowed to sample flavors, while I was denied the exact same courtesy. As a Black customer, the stark difference in treatment was impossible for me to ignore. Based on what I personally witnessed, I felt singled out and treated differently because of my race. I don't make an accusation of racial bias lightly, but when customers immediately around me are being accommodated and I'm denied the same basic service, it's reasonable to question why. What makes this even more disturbing is that after my experience, I came across another review from a Black customer describing a remarkably similar experience at this same location involving samples and differential treatment. Seeing that after experiencing it myself was extremely concerning. Whatever the reason, customers should receive the same level of courtesy and service regardless of race. Absolutely unacceptable experience.

I am such a fan of Nauti Cow! I stumbled upon this place 4 years ago when I was trying to find…read morevegan ice cream on the vineyard, and I'm so glad I did. Now it's a must stop each time I go to the vineyard. It's a bit hidden around the corner from most other spots on the strip, but it's worth walking a little further to visit. The owner and staff are really kind. My most favorite thing they have is the gf/vegan ice cream sandwich! The cookies are thick but also soft, and I love that they don't crumble Even though there's ice cream in between. The ice cream is great but not too sweet. I highly recommend if you're gf and/or dairy free.There's no where to sit inside, so be prepared to walk around to find somewhere to sit and enjoy your treat.

This place had a really high review on Google Maps and was also boasting about the dairy-free…read moreoptions so it seemed quite accessible to a large audience. I was intrigued by it. I was able to get in with no line but soon after I ordered, I think seven more people showed up so this place can get pretty popular during the summer. The staff is super friendly and was happy to provide various samples. I got two scoops and it didn't really blow me away but it was still good, kind of reminding me of store-bought ice cream, which isn't necessarily bad. When I take a look at the photos that people are posting here, it makes me feel like I made the wrong choices because they look really good. I would definitely be willing to come back here and try some new flavors or options but it's really tough to compete here since there seems to be an ice cream shop on every corner around here. There's certainly a lot of competition but don't let this message discourage you from coming here. I really like the accessibility they have with the vegan options so I think you should go support them!

My favorite ice cream place in Edgartown! The flavors really pop! I had a scoop of pistachio and a…read morescoop of blueberry and they were awesome! I also enjoyed a latte. Friendly service and fun atmosphere. Colorful decor, spacious interior, nice seating, and clean bathroom.

Mad Martha's is a really solid ice cream place with some classic flavors and exciting specialty…read moreflavors. I loved the Shark Attack and especially the Catboat Crunch, a delicious chocolatey toffee ice cream that I will be thinking about for a while! Good size portions but still felt a little overproduced. Overall, if you're looking for a sweet treat this place won't disappoint.

Great ice cream shop right on circuit ave amongst all the other stores. Spacious layout and has a…read morevariety of ice cream flavors and treats to choose from. Service was fine with polite workers serving the ice cream. Opted to try their vanilla soft serve and it was very good. Recommending trying this place if you're looking for a new ice cream place to try since there's quite a few on circuit Ave. Can't go wrong with this place.

After a quick slice of pizza we treated ourselves to some ice cream at the CarouselIce Cream…read moreFactory in Oak Bluffs. My father got a large twist in a cone that was so large it appeared to be ready to topple over. With lots of yummy licks he was able to avoid losing a drop of delicious ice cream. I chose the chocolate chip ice cream in a kiddie cup thank goodness as it was a good size for an adult despite the name "kiddie cup". They had benches out front in the shade to enjoy our afternoon snack. Run, don't walk to this place.

PROS: ice cream was good, prices were nice, menu variety plentiful, place has seating inside and…read moreout, sells food, and tall young guy was nice CONS: one of the girls wasn't the nicest. It was as if she didn't want to be there OVERALL: despite not liking the attitude of one person I do like this place and would come back in the future

My friend and I were on the island and wanted a frappe on a hot summer day. We stopped by the Big…read moreDipper and I got an Oreo frappe, and my friend got a chocolate one. Both were delicious, but just fyi the frappes aren't thick at all, it's more like a milkshake. We were expecting these to be at least a little thicker since they were pretty "watery" but I guess that's a milkshake for ya!

Really amazing! We…read morewalked by in the morning and the smell almost pulled us inside by the nostrils. Instead we came back in the afternoon and enjoyed a glazed chocolate cake donut as a late day snack. It was soft on the inside with just a hint of crisp around the edges. The glaze was perfect. The flavor was deep chocolate with just the right amount of sweetness. 10/10. Stop by when in town and have a donut... or grab a box to go.

They advertise GF donuts but didn't have any available. We drove all all they way there. Maybe a…read morenote saying you babe to Pre Order them Would be nice.

Cash only. They do have an ATM machine but it was broken when we were there. The staff are really…read moresweet and give samples. We had pistachio ice cream in a cone. The Ice cream store was located in an indoor plaza with shops for families. The ice cream itself was hard and was not overly sweet.

Came here as a result of not wanting to deal with the crowds of the more popular places in OB…read more Ice cream itself isn't half bad but it is SO overpriced even by MV standards and the cones that they use are seriously from the stone age. Got our kid an oreo, and one of us got a moosetracks while the other got coffee. Again, the ice cream itself is passable, but more of the Baskin Robbins variety than anything original or artisanal. This is for the tourists who aren't in the know and we are *pissed* at ourselves for having fallen for their conveniently-located trap. Ah well, at least our kid was happy and rode their joy ride car for a hot 30 seconds for a dollar. Go up the street. Literally everything is better. This location has so much turnover and The "Sweet Spot" will be gone soon enough.

Wow! This ice cream is incredible. The service was awesome too. They let me try like 50 flavors,…read moresorry to be that annoying person, but there were so many good choices I HAD to sample them. Again, they were so patient and kind. Awesome service. A little pricey, but worth it. I ultimately bought 3 pints (no regrets!) of the carrot cake (I still think about this one), the salted caramel truffle, and the mocha Joe (I don't even drink coffee and I liked this, it's filled with Oreo chunks but not overly sweet). Notable mentions were the heath bar crunch (yum!) and the brown sugar banana (aka bananas foster), I was outvoted otherwise that Heath bar would've been grabbed as well. The ice cream was rich and creamy, deeply flavorful, just dreamy. I was impressed with the texture too. After being in the freezer for several hours (and then 24 hours later) it was never rock hard, it remained easily scoop-able. I imagine that's a signal of the quality. I have no confirmation, but I'm thinking higher fat content and good quality fat so less ice crystals and hardness? Idk and it doesn't matter. The point is this is flavor town & you should check it out. The carrot cake was my favorite. It took me back to thanksgiving and my grandmas famous sweet potato pie. Hope you love it as much as I did. Pro-tip: Go grab a pie from pie chicks & have it with your ice cream!

Massive line but totally worth the wait. This is not your stereotypical ice shop with regular…read moreflavors so do be mindful of that. However, this is the creamiest and BEST ice cream in Edgartown. Another note - A little tough later in the night (after 9pm) because a lot of the flavors were out by the time we got there so come which multiple flavors in mind. HIGHLY recommend the strawberry (it was the real, not syrupy/fake kind). The maple walnut was great with big chunks of walnuts. And the cookies and cream had the most cookies in cream I have ever seen.

Tasty ice cream, quick service, tons of merch to choose from, and only steps from the ferry so you…read morecan get your first scoop asap and fit in your last scoop without a time crunch. Nice clean bathroom as well.

Mad Martha's Ice Cream sells homemade ice cream and has locations in Edgartown, Oak Bluffs, and…read moreVineyard Haven. I was catching the Steamship Authority's ferry out of Vineyard Haven and stopped by here to get a scoop of ice cream prior to boarding. There were many flavors to choose from. I ordered a small M&M Cream and my husband ordered a small Catboat Crunch. Each were $7.50. There was a queue, but more staff came out to help and the queue moved. There are a few tables inside to enjoy the ice cream. The ice cream was very creamy. The M&M Cream had M&M pieces which I enjoyed.