Man, what do I gotta say actual New York pizza?! In Puerto…read moreRico?! This is a must come down and enjoy a good slice. Everybody here was so cool. Plus, that guy has some real punk history in his bar! The vibe is there through and through if you want that New York experience in Puerto Rico

Was seated by the staff, given a menu and no one came back to take our order. We were seated on…read morethe back patio and no one returned. We saw other people get seated and had their orders taken.. not us. After 22+ minutes of waiting, we left. First time in my life I've ever had to leave a restaurant because of this.

Top tier New York style pizza. Very friendly staff and a nice cozy atmosphere that wasn't very…read morehectic. It has a good selection of drinks for a pizza place including wines and beers.

Taking a stroll out. Decided to check this place out. Ordered a small pie but they were out of…read moreavocado. I still opted to try it without the avocado. My eyes started burning as soon as I sat down. Not sure if it was from the brick oven smoke or what. Customer service was 10/10 as they helped me find a bar in walking distance.

No picture sadly, but we ordered the following:…read more Borincana Carbonara These pizzas are probably the best non New York pizzas I've ever had. My only complaint is that I wish the pernil (borincana) had a little more seasoning, regardless, how can you say no to pork, sweet plantains, mozzarella, and onions on a pizza? Carbonara: White sauce, mozzarella, bacon, chicken, onion. EXCELLENT! - just wish the sauce was a little more x present. We picked up the food, but the place seemed like a great place to hang out. World Cup game (2026) was on the TV and they sold beer. I would definitely return if I'm I return to Luquillo or Fajardo again. Patronize this place!! It took 15-20 to get our pie out together.

Great ingredients! Great people! Grabbed a couple of pies before going to the hotel.read more

Made reservations for dinner and were seated on our promised time. The place was packed - not…read moresurprised given it was right in the middle of the resort with easy access. Frankie was our waiter - very friendly and attentive. We got straight to ordering which included a couple of things including Truffled Mushroom Pizza ($24), Truffle Fries ($14), Shrimp + Grits ($32), and a few others. These were the most notable. The pizza was great, but could've used slightly more mushrooms at that price point. Service was excellent all throughout, and they have a very attentive team.

Had dinner in the patio after a long day in the rainforest and then beach. Ordered the wedge salad,…read moresalt and pepper calamari, smash-burger, and a couple of desserts. The wedge salad was fresh, but could have used more bacon and blue-cheese crumbles. The salt and pepper calamari was also tasty and cooked perfectly; it was served with a lemon aioli. The smash-burger had two patties, and standard fixings - lettuce, tomato, and a sauce. The plate came with season fries. We also ordered dessert. We ordered the pineapple upside down cake, which was amazing. The cake was super moist and buttery. We also ordered pistachio ice-cream, which was delicious. The service was friendly and attentive. They also split everything and brought extra plates. Reservations are encouraged because this place can get busy. There is a take-away window so you can still enjoy the food! Enjoy!

Fantastic pizza and a great location. We are there twice and with our group ordered 3 different…read moretypes of pizzas and some appetizers. All of it exceeded our expectations. Definitely worth a visit for great food.

My husband and I tried this pizza place for the first time last night and it was very good. The…read morecrust seems homemade and is medium thickness with a good flavor. We were able to get a half meat lovers and half veggie lovers pizza which was nice to be able to get a variety to try. The meat lovers side was loaded with pepperoni, Italian sausage and bacon. The meats tasted fresh and of good quality. The veggie side was good as well with a nice selection of olives, onions, tomatoes and green peppers. The only thing missing was tomato sauce - there was either none or a small amount. But we think that is the way they do pizza here in Puerto Rico so this is not a failing of the restaurant. The interior of the restaurant was nicely decorated and clean. The owner was friendly and helpful and spoke perfect English which was great for us being from the states. My only suggestion would be to light up the menu somehow as it was on black background and being a somewhat sight-challenged middle-aged person it was hard for me to read it. But the owner helped with suggestions and questions to find out what would be good for us. Overall a very good experience and definitely recommended.

Definitely a carry out place. Drove there, place was absolutely empty. Ordered 1 large pizza, got…read moretold wait time was 20-25 minutes and I waited over an hour in the car for the pizza. Got told there were delivery orders ahead but I was physically there and waited an hour for a pizza (which is completely unjustified). I wanted to cancel it towards the end but they were already preparing it. Had to wait until it came out watching them. If they would've told me it was an hour wait I wouldn't have placed an order.

Fantastic pizza! The pizza is one of the best I've ever had, and the large size is considerably…read morebigger than most 'larges'. I've gone twice on my week vacation!

So for dinner, we came to Rustica, because the kids were craving some real pizza, and this place…read morecame highly recommended. Let me tell you... it did not disappoint! The restaurant is spacious, family-friendly, clean, and the staff is incredibly friendly and quick. They're open Thursday-Sunday from 4:00 PM to 9:30 PM. Now let's get down to the food! We started with the meatballs, and OMG--they were huge and absolutely delicious! Then came the wings, and if you know my daughter, you know she's a picky eater... but she had no problem going to town on those wings! For pizza, we ordered two: Sausage & peppers Half pepperoni and half chicken When I tell you there were 10 of us, and everyone left full and happy, I mean it! We also ordered a salad, and everything we had was fresh and full of flavor. Of course, we couldn't skip the drinks! Our waiter recommended the Dress Italiana, which was such a refreshing way to start the meal. We also tried a Rum Punch, Piña Colada, and a Moscow Mule, and they were all great. I have to say, it's really hard to find a truly great pizza place these days, so when I find one, I'm going to give them their flowers. This place definitely earned them. The restaurant started filling up fast around 6:30 PM, and it's easy to see why. Whenever I'm back in Puerto Rico and craving pizza, Rustica will be my go-to. Highly recommend!

As a foreigner, this was the best Puerto Rican Pizza experience ever. The meat balls are best on…read morethe menu, but be weary they sell out fast, we came later in the night and they only had 1 serving left. The quality they put into the customer service is amazing, best overall. The ambiance is similar to an old Puerto Rican house, warm inviting and needing company. I've never been more satisfied leaving a restaurant before in the way that Rustica made me feel.

¡Claro! Para una reseña de Google, la haría un poco más cálida y entusiasta:…read more What a beautiful place! The food was absolutely delicious, and the atmosphere was comfortable, spacious, and welcoming. Amanda provided us with excellent service and made our experience even more enjoyable. I highly recommend this place! We will definitely be back!

Cute little spot on a side street. The server was great. They have a nice selection of coffee…read moredrinks. Each drink we had was made well and were very delicious. The quesadilla was made fresh and was yummy. It was the special this day. I would go back to try other items. They are also known for their wood fired pizza.

Cheese pizza is pretty amazing, was not expecting that at all. However after going there many…read moretimes, had to order supreme, with all meats and so on. Didn't like it and would definitely suggest to improve on some ingredients for the pizza place. So if you looking to grab a cheese slice or the whole pie, that's the place. Will definitely go there again

February 2026 we stopped here for a medium mushroom and it was very basic and underwhelming…read more Crystal took our order and seemed annoyed we were interrupting her FaceTime call which she was on the entire 30 minutes we were there. We are mushroom snobs and the mushrooms were canned. Cheese on the pizza was good and gooey and the dough was very cardboard like in texture. Sauce was decent. We are very surprised at seeing the great comments for this place. I feel like kids would enjoy this pizza. Favorite pizza I've ever had was at Tomato pie (the grandma) in Silverlake (LA, CA) for reference. Please don't read this as rude. This is our opinion and I don't care that Crystal was on her phone the entire time. Didn't even care that there were pigeons in there and on the counter (see photo). Had a great vacation with the love of my life by the ocean and wonderful weather.

Bistro Del Mar has what I can only describe as the greatest empanadas known to humanity. I'm not…read moreexaggerating. I came here expecting good food and left wondering how I'm supposed to return to my normal life knowing these exist. The flavor?! The crust?! THE EMPANADAS?! Honestly, if there are only two things you do in Puerto Rico: enjoy the island and eat these empanadas. I would happily cancel plans, rearrange my schedule, and possibly betray a loved one for the last empanada. Bistro Del Mar, you have officially ruined all other empanadas for me. 10/10. No notes. Seriously... GO. GET. THE. EMPANADAS.

Go to Bistro Del Mar for the fish tacos. They're the reason to come…read more You get fresh, flavorful fish with just the right seasoning. The textures work. The toppings don't overpower anything. Every bite feels balanced and worth it. Be ready to wait. The food takes a while to come out. Plan for it and don't come starving. That said, the tacos make up for it. You'll forget the wait once you start eating. Also plan for the setup. There isn't much shade during the day, so think ahead if you're coming earlier. Bring what you need or come at a better time. We went at night, and it was perfect. The atmosphere felt calm and easy, with a great breeze and a relaxed vibe. Sit back, take your time, and enjoy it.