I found this place because it's literally on the bank of nature trails I was using! Small, quaint and bartender was very hospitable! I ordered a 10" deep dish pizza because I'm in Chicago and because I did 4 miles on the nature trail so I deserved it!!! Pizza came out hot and delicious as ordered and I would highly recommend it! I'm boxing up 1/2 and eating the rest later! read more

York Tavern - 10" Deep dish York's Special with pepperoni and bacon. - Bars Near Me - Oak Brook, Illinois

The York Tavern is a Gem of a place & a MUST visit for the Best pizza & burgers ! It is a quaint, cozy place that makes you feel like you want to belly up inside at the bar & stay awhile or grab a table on their patio like we did ( dog friendly outside). Warning, the place is small so do not be surprised if you have to wait. Service is great too! What more could one want?!? Stop there today & be ready for a 10/10 experience! read more

York Tavern - World's Greatest Pizza! Seriously, drooling rn - Bars Near Me - Oak Brook, Illinois

See all

Servers were cold and aloof. Place is very loud--in the middle of a weekday. Food is barely fair.

Favorite for lunch or dinner or beers! Easy to park, old school inside, great service and delicious food! Winner, winner! Burger is my "go to" but also love the pizza. Great spot to have a meal and conversation w friends. read more

York Tavern - Lunch bill for 2 - Bars Near Me - Oak Brook, Illinois

I had heard that the York Tavern was serving Roberto's pizza, and that was a correct bit of information. I am a huge fan of Robertos, but do not like ordering it at their Elmhurst location as they seem to look down on you for asking for the "pizza menu" and then treat you as lower class. But this is the PERFECT ANSWER for me. A humble bar that has table seating available and has Roberto's delicious pizza. My wife and I have went multiple times and each time is better than the last. Pizza is top notch, the appetizers we have gotten have all been great. My only complaint has been the chili, which was not either my wifes or my cup of tea. I want to try some of the sandwiches or burgers they offer, but cannot stop myself from ordering the pizza! highly recommended. read more

I grew up in Hinsdale - not a great experience. I only go there when I need to. There are only two places in area I frequent. This is one of them. Warm, cozy, and inviting. I have my favorite place to sit and everything on the menu is good. The staff is friendly and the patrons are polite. Being a distinguished older gentleman , this place is good for a date, a drink, a meal or a nitecap. Save your "Oh No's". If there is an issue; it's You not Them. Have a Good Day read more

Business lunch. Service was good. Went about 12:45 so lunch crowd was thinning. Overall nice little spot .

I do not usually give negative reviews but this time I think my lunch deserved it. The tortellini with tomato sauce was truly lacking in anything that warranted the price. Speaking of price you would think it deserved real silverware rather than a cheap plastic knife and fork. I won't be returning with all the other better restaurants in the area. read more

Went there on a Saturday afternoon. It was busy but had a few tables and lots of space free at the bar. We sat at the bar and just waited... the staff didn't seem to really enjoy the work and were almost unhappy that more people were arriving. Place looked pretty dirty. We didn't stay. They need to do better to deserve business IMO read more

Always excellent service and food, but why did u take Bells 2 Hearted Ale off if tap? Very disappointing read more

Came here for a bite to eat after an event at the humane society. We were immediately greeted after walking in and ordered a few drinks. We ordered a sausage pizza. The crust was a bit thicker than I'd like but it tasted great. Been to this place on many occasions and it is usually incredibly loud but this time it was not. Much easier to enjoy yourself when you aren't screaming at the people right by you. Overall good experience this time around! read more

York Tavern - a pizza on a silver platter - Bars Near Me - Oak Brook, Illinois

Stopped by Sunday evening. Had a pizza because they looked amazing coming out of the kitchen. Place was extremely crowded but service was excellent. Waitstaff was very attentive. Will be back read more

The place is dirty and not enough hands to help clear, wipe, deliver food etc.... My son got sick from eating a burger there and the burgers are way overpriced. The servers work hard and don't have enough support staff. I was in the industry for years and this isn't a way to run a business. Maybe the owner should hire more help ! read more

Amazing little hole in the wall in the middle of Oak Brook. We only met for drinks, but it was a great experience.

Pretty good but kinda high prices, and not very friendly to strangers. Cramped seating.

York Tavern for the Halloween Pizza win! We order pizza every Halloween, 2 years ago Lou Malnati screwed us over. We ordered York this year for a perfect tasty hot tavern style pizza and crispy calamari. Two weeks ago they were the perfect choice for pick up after we did the Fullersburg Woods Halloween walk. I have to say that the pandemic has actually improved this establishment with the new take out window, the new outdoor patio and attached event tent. It's a popular place, they needed those things. As has always been, this is a super cool location right next to the woods and the mill. But the new adds take it to the next level while still preserving the original space. Keeping it historic without getting dusty. Also, it feels like the food quality has gone way up over the last decade, so they're doing great things there too. Their fried apps hold their crispiness for take out, so many places fail at this. Love the arugula salad, too! Fresh, simple, flavorful. read more

I Just wanted a good hamburger, really disappointed in the possibly frozen packaged unflavored patty that had no soul. The $16 price tag was too much. I expected much more for a local landmark restaurant with a very nice clientele. For the record I am visiting the area after many years in the restaurant business in San Francisco. I would hope that the locals would call out the manager/owner and request a better product. Wolfs Head had a much better burger, fresh ground beef used to make the patty. I wanted to like York Tavern, cool location with a good back story that is banking on the locals to not care, The servers were not very attentive or personable. You have to care more. read more

Waited forever to get served, when the server finally came I put the order in for myself and my friend. Apparently the server did not like the way I said it. When the food came the burger was undercooked and there were no grilled onions as I had ordered. The server kept walking back and forth and not once asked how things were. I motioned for another beer and she looked at me like why are you bothering me?! very unprofessional and basically rude. Sad to say I will never eat or drink there again. read more

I used to eat lunch there about forty years ago!! A group of us from then went back and found it very different but still very good!!!! Our server thought it was great we had regrouped there after a long time. It was very welcoming. Others were eating not burgers which is what we always ate....thats all they served....and said the food was really good. We will meet there again for old times sake!! read more

Straightforward food, friendly service in a bar atmosphere. Nothing fancy. Burgers are a good bet.

Bartender with curly hair and big earrings was extremely rude, did not want to serve us a drink one hour before closing. Will not be back here and will advise family and friends read more

The food was good, the place is small loud and uncomfortable. It's more about the history than anything else else. You have to yell to hear the person across the table read more

I have been coming here for years, the thin crust pizza is outstanding. My favorite is the York Special-cheese, sausage, mushroom, green pepper and onion. Sarah was our server and did an outstanding job! read more

York Tavern - Check out the new tent!! - Bars Near Me - Oak Brook, Illinois

See all

Food was pretty good and the blonde server was great. However while leaving the other one who was working (08/29/24 @6:30pm) was weird and like stepped up in my face as I was trying to leave. And of course it super crowded so it's not like sliding past is really an option unless she wanted me to rub against her? I was only like 1 more steps away from leaving the crowded area so it made no sense that she got all up in my face expecting me and the party is was with to back up a bunch and excuse our selves for her? And I'm a waitress, that's why I have an issue with this... BE BETTER read more

I don't know what kind of crack many of the reviewers are smoking because this place is great! I've probably been to the York Tavern 10-15 times over the years and they never disappoint. Granted I only ever get the burger when I go because why mess with perfection? I got the burger tonight and it was so damn good. It was cooked perfectly, medium rare AF. I noticed a lot of people got pizza tonight and it looked super good. I doubt I'll ever get anything besides the burger though. Probably a top 10 burger in the book of Kevin. Keep up the good work y'all! Service was great by the way! read more

We came here after golf and had lunch at the bar yesterday October 5th. Amazing food and excellent service from Marla. As a restaurant owner I appreciate great guest service. I will be back. read more

Came for late lunch and got a quick seat outside on the (6 table) patio. This is only place a dog can utilize. We had a beer (didn't have our first 3-4 brands) a fish plate (very tasty) and burger (not that good). Pleasant surroundings. We walked our dog along stream after we ate. Overall: Ok but not great. Seems they cater to Locals who already know what they like. read more

Food is okay but the service isn't good at all. Second try, second strike out. Two different servers.

I love the location and the building. The actual restaurant space is pretty small for the amount of people and tables squeezed in, so the noise level was really high and it was at capacity, so very crowded. I was seated elbow to elbow with another table and a crew of 6-8 slightly drunk women at a table immediately behind me. Squished in. Large menu but I just needed a starter and Diet Coke after a hike through nearby Graue Mill. Unfortunately, nearly all starter options are fried. The mushrooms were ok. I regret not ordering a pizza- other tables did that and their pizzas looked really good. There was a photographer at the next table photographing a bunch of dishes so I got to see a lot of options. The burger looked massive and at $14 I suppose that's reasonable considering the size. There were a couple of vegetarian options. Large drink menu, just no hot cocoa or coffee, so if you are looking to warm up after a hike through Fullersburg or Graue Mill, you'll have to settle for cold Cokes and beer. Clean bathrooms, big parking lot, tidy space. Waitress was attentive. The plastic plate, fork and knife were odd to be used in a restaurant. I was surprised and thought perhaps they'd had a power outage and could not wash their real dishes, but I see other Yelpers have mentioned plastic or styrofoam plates and plastic utensils so that is probably the norm. I'd probably stop by again for a beer if I was in the area but on a quieter day, perhaps. read more

Food is GREAT and people working here are nice. Very small and hard to get a table sometimes, but the pizza is well worth the wait as are their burgers. We lucked out and got a table right away. 20 mins later and people were lined up waiting. read more

Nice place, good food. No complaints. Solid burgers and really nice staff. Had the tortellini and delicious burger. read more

York Tavern - Tortellini - Bars Near Me - Oak Brook, Illinois

See all

Food quality has declined over the years. Burgers are average. Than I'm the past. Fries are bland read more

for extra sauce, a little dry. I would also ask them to let cheese get a bit more brown so it would be more melted. Overall enjoyed. Ok I guess O just listened late thought was recent message. Pizza was good, very good sausage, fresh mushrooms which is a plus for my extremely advanced/hyper sensitive and very finely tuned taste buds... Crust was ok hot, not good after cooling. Good sauce but I should have asked for extra sauce, a little dry. I would also ask them to let cheese get a bit more brown so it would be more melted. Overall enjoyed. Ok I guess O just listened late thought was recent message. Pizza was good, very good sausage, fresh mushrooms which is a plus for my extremely advanced/hyper sensitive and very finely tuned taste buds... Crust was ok hot, not good after cooling. Good sauce but I should have asked for extra sauce, a little dry. I would also ask them to let cheese get a bit more brown so it would be more melted. Overall enjoyed. Ok I guess O just listened late thought was recent message. Pizza was good, very good sausage, fresh mushrooms which is a plus for my extremely advanced/hyper sensitive and very finely tuned taste buds... Crust was ok hot, not good after cooling. Good sauce but I should have asked for extra sauce, a little dry. I would also ask them to let cheese get a bit more brown so it would be more melted. Overall enjoyed. Ok I guess O just listened late thought was recent message. Pizza was good, very good sausage, fresh mushrooms which is a plus for my extremely advanced/hyper sensitive and very finely tuned taste buds... Crust was ok hot, not good after cooling. Good sauce but I should have asked for extra sauce, a little dry. I would also ask them to let cheese get a bit more brown so it would be more melted. Overall enjoyed. read more

The food was fair. The staff seemed to be having a bad day. They were all cold and unfriendly. We should've checked Yelp before going in.

We grew up in Hinsdale and have great memories of Salt Creek, the park, and York Tavern, a fixture on York Road. Had a nice time there with classmates at our 50th reunion in 2010. Burgers and a beer. This time was very different and disappointing. The service was wonderful but our food, a meatball and chicken sandwich, was expensive and awful. True Sysco foodservice gruel, not the quality of times before. We won't be returning anytime soon. read more

Great neighborhood tavern, awesome food. Our server was Lia, she was the best. Used to come here 40 years ago. Visited for old times sake. No regrets. Had a cheeseburger 5 stars read more

Best place for beer and pizza. The Hawaiian pizza is amazing. It has this unique cracker crust that is crispy and super flavorful. read more

York Tavern - Hawaiian pizza and beer. - Bars Near Me - Oak Brook, Illinois

It's not the great burger place it used to be, plus it's really expensive. $16 for an average cheeseburger seems out of line. Bartender was average, not very personable. Oh well, things change. read more

Don't get the hype about this place at all. Service was horrible. Food, especially the famed burger, was mediocre at best.

It was the first time there the doctors nurse that I saw recommended this place our waitress was about 16 years old and didn't know how to waitress she gave us two plastic plates with some dirty jars of Parmesan and basil etc. on top of the plates and wanted us to use those plates after she carried those dirty jars on top we were given to napkins how to ask for more she never came to check and see if everything was OK pizza was mediocre it was so noisy in there and there was only 6-8 people inside I couldn't hear my husband who was sitting across the table as I watched people in the tables next to us the other waitresses kept forgetting things there was no way to walk through this place to get to the bar that's so many tables jammed into this building I'm surprised this place was still in business we won't be going back read more