The beef pepperoni pizza was extremely tasty, and it has become my preferred choice. I will definitely come back for it.

It's very close to a New York slice I would get it for a regular pizza night. Great job. And great customer service very friendly.

Amazingly large and tasty slices. Hit the spot. Clean spot, friendly and helpful service, chill family atmosphere. You can't go wrong. read more

Why Not Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Charlotte, North Carolina

You can't beat $4 by the slice pizza! Our slices were hot and the flavor is solid. There was a steady stream of to go pickups while we were sitting there. I'll be back to order a pie in the future. read more

Why Not Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Charlotte, North Carolina

Great pizza every time. If you want the best, try this pizza restaurant. I definitely recommend stopping by for some delicious pizza.

The crust? Absolute perfection--crispy, chewy, kissed by the fire just enough to give it soul. The ingredients taste fresh, not just in the sense of quality, but like they were chosen with love and purpose. read more

See all

We have been customers for years . We have had a lot of issues over the years with getting home and having no sauce, no dressing for our salads more times than I can remember. Now they have took their pizza prices to the stratosphere. $2.99 and up for each topping on the least expensive overhead item they make . $3-$5 for an entire pizza . They are charging almost $10 for one yes I said 1 slice of specialty pizza . Someone has bumped their head . You can search all over charlotte with all the high end pizza places $6.50 is the max for one slice . You most definitely are not in Noda or downtown. You are in a low income area . You're going to lose a lot of business including my family because that's just a poor business decision. Normally when businesses do this they will out of business soon , good luck to you, read more

Stopped by during work for lunch and this place definitely didn't disappoint. Authentic New York style and New York size too! All ingredients were fresh and tasty. Not only the food but the staff was super friendly and restaurant was very clean. Will come back when in the area read more

Why Not Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Charlotte, North Carolina

See all

I got the Philly and it was sooooo salty. I couldn't finish it. I'd go back but I'd prob stick with pizza or one of the oven baked dishes. They have a connected ice cream shop, I didn't try any this visit but made a mental note to go back and check em out since the flavors looked to be tasty. read more

See all

I definitely liked my slice and honestly probably one of the most underrated places since you don't hear a lot of people talk about it in Charlotte read more

I just tried their stromboli and couldn't be more dissatisfied. This had to be the toughest and flavorless stromboli in existence. I'm sure they provide marinara dipping sauce to soften the crust enough to be edible. Never will I attempt to eat this again. It is my hope that first time stromboli eaters will not judge all stromboli by this one. read more

Gigantic slices of true NY style Pizza! Not to be missed! Perfect combination of cheese sauce and a foldable crust!

Large slices of classic New York-style pizza, but I always come for the cannolis -- they're awesome!

Best pizza I've had in Charlotte. I've been meaning to stop by this place for a while and finally got around to it for lunch. I placed my order online and it was ready to pick up in 15 minutes. I walked in and right back out. The pizza was fresh and hot plus it was actually thin and you had to fold it. read more

Great pizza. Crust was terrific. Flavor was on point. Employees were courteous and fast. Clean with an ice cream shop adjoining for dessert. read more

Just starting to Hubby's B-day celebration! We wanted to get a bite to eat. Why Not Pizza was the number one choice. This place is still our favorite pizzeria. True NY style pizza! read more

it really makes you feel "why not pizza" The pizza is decent, but there was nothing really outstanding about it to be honest. They do have a few things right: There's a good amount of toppings on the pizza and the ingredients are high quality. There are a lot of nice combination choices and plenty of variety on the menu. They do have amazingly fudge-y chocolate ice cream. I've been here a few times and it doesn't leave much of an impression each time. The crust is always a touch too chewy and I'm not a fan of the chewy, doughy consistency. Good pizza is really all about the sauce and the crust. Everything else is secondary in importance, and they try to cover up the lack of remarkable pizza taste under layers and layers of toppings Overall, not bad. I'm sure some people love it for the variety. Pizza is one of my absolute favorite indulgences. read more

Sweet lady in the register with nice attitude all the time, and the pizza is spot NY. My favorite place and my husband is from the Bronx and he feels like home after eating this pizza read more

Places like this remind me why I miss Charlotte! This small business is serving up big New York flavors. We never drive to east Charlotte but I will make it my business to do so on my next visits. I ordered very simply: 2 slices of pepperoni pizza and fried mushrooms. Would have ordered more but had just left the restaurant next door and BW's Sweets Bakery - check out my next reviews. Don't judge. I told you we never visit this area anymore so I took advantage of my time in what used to be my old stomping ground. Now back to the review. The pizza was that perfect combination of foldable crust, tangy with a bit of sweetness tomato sauce, stretchy cheese, generous spicy pepperoni and - wait for it - grease! Love at first bite. The mushrooms were crunchy and unctuous and still hot after my 30 minute drive back to Matthews - Union County side. The young lady at the register was friendly and helpful. She was what customer service should always be. I can't wait to go back! read more

Best pizza in East Charlotte. Slices are huge. The subs are great too. Get the steak and cheese with everything on it. read more

Really enjoyed this! Just got it on DoorDash for lunch and the turkey sub was definitely top-5 I've had down here. Toasted nice and they don't scrimp on the toppings. Also got a pepperoni slice and it's SUPER thin but if you're okay with that (I personally am) it's very good as well. Looking forward to ordering a pie and some different subs this weekend! read more

I ordered the lasagna which comes with 3 garlic knots and a side salad with dressing and it was very good. Prepared fast and everything was neatly put together. Will definitely be back more often for it. read more

Why Not Pizza - Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Charlotte, North Carolina

I have ordered from this restaurant in the past & really enjoyed the food. I just repeated my order & the size of the pizza I received was way smaller than I received in the past. Not worth the price & will definitely not order again. read more

Why Not Pizza is a perfect name for a pizza place that will actually make you ask "Why, Why Not Pizza?" Been here twice. First time I ordered a slice of the works. They took precooked pepperoni pizza slice, tossed a bunch of toppings on, and put it in the oven for all ove 5 mins. Needless to say, the new ingredients weren't cooked, and it was a mess. 2nd time, I ordered a full size pepperoni, mushroom, and sausage pizza and it was an undercooked, floppy mush and a waste of $30. This food is a poorly executed and very over-priced pizza pie. You couldn't get 99 cents a slice for this floppy slop in NYC. read more

Great place for pies with large NY slices. Lots of topping choices. Love having it around the corner from my house!

Since moving to Charlotte from N.Y this is my go to spot. The cheese , the crust, the sauce . It's all pretty good. I get mine well done cuz it's my preference and it's solid pizza . All in all I'd say a 4.4 read more

The pizza was cold and terrible. The delivery person got here as quickly as possible so I have to think the pizza sat there for a while for some reason. That would be ok, we can heat it up, but the flavor of the sauce was just salty. no other taste was discernable over the salty taste. it just ruins the whole pizza. The dough was ok. A little thin, soggy and flavorless, but I've had worse. I'm from New England, so when a pizza shop claims to make NY style pizza, there are expectations. This met none of them. Then there were the zeppole desserts. They had the taste and consistency of baked pizza dough. Not fried dough like traditional zeppoles. We had ordered 2 servings as we love zeppoles we've had before in other cities, and wound up eating one each of the hard, dry, flavorless little pizza dough balls sprinkled with powdered sugar and threw the rest of them out. $9 of zeppoles trashed. If you've never had a zeppole and don't mind fried dough that has no resemblance with the taste or texture of fried dough, maybe you won't care. I think WNP can do better. We won't be back unless they completely overhaul their pizza sauce. We're willing to just not attempt to eat their zeppoles again. read more

Gist: Go elsewhere. Pro: You can buy by the slice. Cons: I think my pizza crust was made from quesadilla. It tasted like cardboard. It was thinner than thin crust but tough. The crust was inedible. Gave it to the dog. read more

Not much to rate, they had some good pizza. I had a spinach and mushroom pizza. Still haven't found a pizza joint in Charlotte that does beef pepperoni yet. But this place is good I rode by it all the time and finally stopped in to give them a try. Thumbs up. This is an update review about the Chick-O-Philly. This sandwich is the damn bomb. I always get this when I get a sandwich here cause it's one of the best sandwiches in Charlotte. Now I didn't say, The Best but it's one of them. I got the 12 inch today with fries and it was good. I get it with Everything on it. They never disappoint me any time I come here to eat. read more

See all

THE best NY style pizza on the east side. We always get a larger pizza thinking we will save some for throughout the week but it never lasts more than 2 meals because we devour it. Great food, great prices. read more

In luv with the vegan pizza and fries. I have gotten it a few times, always good. They offer gluten free crust as well!

I love why not Pizza Saint privat eat there at least three times out of the month and I know that's a lot for me but I love this Play Say Something About Me therapy Pizza their jobs their wings their chicken salad everything is delicious I give it a AAA plus they do a great job and customer service is so nice they are so friendly I think they almost know me when I come in I'll call cuz they usually kind of tell me if the lady I can't think of her name she is so sweet she knows exactly what Pam wants keep up the good work why not pizza you get at a plus from me read more

Why Not Pizza - A ride in the park - Pizza Near Me - Charlotte, North Carolina

My boyfriend and I were hungover and searching for any easy pizza. This place has great reviews. And we were honestly seeking anything to sustain us. We ordered thru DoorDash and this pizza BLEW away our expectations. I got a sausage and pepperoni for my friend and I. My boyfriend got the specialty pizza minus olives. But he ended up eating more of our. The sausage was BOMB. Dude, this pizza is legit and delicious! We all sat there quietly eating for a moment and then all said this is fucking delicious. The crust was the right balance between crispy and giving their the ingredients. So happy to know that we have this available to us in less than a 10 min drive! We will become regulars!!! Thank you to all the workers that are there making pizza and delivering a delicious product to us thirsty ass pizza seekers!!!! read more

Awesome pizza and garlic knots. Bit pricey. But worth it. Nice to have a decent place to go on the east side without having to give local money elsewhere. Wish there were more places like this on this side. And maybe serve beer. read more

Really good pizza, maybe the best NY style I've had in Charlotte. WHY DO THEY CLOSE AT 8:30??? Only complaint

the only reason this restaurant does not have a line out of the door every single day is because it's not in a trendy area of town. Fantastic service, INCREDIBLE PIZZA. read more

I am spoiled to this place. Everything is fabulous! The chef salad is wonderful. The pizza is outstanding. The cannoli is the best I have had. read more

I have ate here for years but recently found the customer service is way pass terrible. I ordered through door dash for the 2rd time. My order was over 60 bucks. The price wasn't the issue. The issue is twice they have given my order to the wrong person twice. On the door dash app it showed it was picked up but when I called why not pizza the person was so rude. I only asked where my order was. The lady was like it's not our problem call door dash. I told her I will but why offer door dash if your having so many problems with thim. And she just hung up. Then canceled my order. Didn't even try and fix the problem. read more

Why Not Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Charlotte, North Carolina

Great Philly cheesesteak ! Definitely in my top 3 in Charlotte ! The pizza and wings are great too !

I always get the Stromboli, which is huge! Extra marinara, please- it is the best in town. Love having this little neighborhood place nearby. read more