Like you, I was very much intrigued by the overwhelming swarm of positive reviews. With this many positive reviews, how could anything go wrong? But ratings for any repair shop can be misleading, especially when the majority are either oil changes/typical auto repairs/ or minor paint repair.
The Project:
In my experience, they were eager to take my vehicle which needed a LOT of repair work which consisted of Mechanical work and lots of body work, the entire side of the car. The initial quote was a fair price, which would have kept the majority of customers. This particular project was estimated to take 3 weeks which did not include waiting for parts to arrive from suppliers. After 2 weeks all the parts had arrived, and we were all eager to see the results of their work. Half the project was completed and Steve calls to ask for money up front to keep his shop open, claiming that he is a small business and has to pay his people. I refused to pay for any work that was incomplete.
Fast forward to week 6 and the repair work has still not been completed. Leading up to this 6 week mark, we had inquired for weekly updates (we almost always had to call as any time they said they would call with an update, they never did), and there would always be an excuse for why they were behind. To name a few: It was too humid outside to paint(valid, but this doesn't delay for 2 weeks), it was a busy day at work(likely trying to squeeze in other people where they could turn the customer around the same day), we found another issue which slowed us down by several days(reasonable, but this gets old after the second time), it's my anniversary/birthday(fine, but I don't care), I am short on people(no excuse, stop taking jobs when you committed to this one), I forgot(this was my favorite one of course). With all the excuse making and delays, this is how a large project with a predicted 3 week turn around turned into an overall incomplete project after a painful 9 weeks. After week 10 we moved the car to another shop that had the capability to complete everything in 2.5 week.
Work Done Wrong:
After seeing the car completed after paint there were several major issues. First, the paint was nowhere near matching the original color. I remember how emphatic Steve was in his ability to match paint, this confidence would turn up with a paint texture nowhere close in matching, and areas that were not properly coated at all. All the panels they painted has to be stripped and repainted. The shop claims they would redo anything if I wasn't happy with it, but quite frankly, I didn't want to wait another 7 weeks.
The damaged rocker panel had to have the dent pushed out and repaired. Instead of taking the panels off to get the buckling/dents out, he filled the rocker panel completely with bondo. Next, he used bondo to "glue" a brand new factory part side skirt to the car. It almost matched up, but broke off in several pieces when it came time to actually fix the car properly which required the removal of the side skirt. This is supposed to be a removable body panel!
Generally speaking:
Without a doubt, this is a great place to go for routine maintenance work. Brake Jobs, Suspension. Bumper repair, Oil Changes, etc. But this place made the mistake of accepting a project clearly out of their league, where they have to outsource nearly all of the body work (to probably the cheapest shop they can find) without the capability to perform work within a reasonable amount of time. Their coordinator Cindy is very pleasant and understanding, and is only relaying what her team is telling her. There is no question that Steve's poor communication between him and his employees leave frustrated customers. Cindy has to constantly work around this severe communication gap by doing her best to determine scheduling between the business owner that wants to have more control of when he does what projects in his shop. It is entirely possible that this place would be completely destitute without a coordinator like Cindy to salvage what little there is left of customer respect.
Concluding thoughts:
If you look again at all of the ratings for this shop, you will see that the vast majority are for small projects and repair work. Don't hesitate to use this place for your small jobs and routine work. But seriously scrutinize all of the reviews and specifically the large jobs reviews before considering this place for a big project. This place is very much run like a mom and pop shop that will do an average job for an average price over a very long period of time. Sadly I will not be returning, there are hundreds of shops out there in the valley. read more