Dear Greg, I wanted to thank you for the tremendous support and legal guidance provided by your firm through our Son's dis-enrollment board and subsequent appeal. From the very first phone call with you, and after several interviews with other military law firms, it was clear that you and your team were truly our best course to arrive at a positive outcome. We had the great pleasure to work with Wayne Roberts who immediately created a strong rapport with my Son and our family. His legal expertise and calming demeanor brought great confidence and reassurance as we navigated through the initial board hearing. Even though we received a favorable recommendation from board, it was not accepted by the PMS nor the Brigade. We were left with one final appeal if we chose to continue the fight to allow our son his dream of obtaining an Army Commission. Our second consultation, you presented the opportunities and hope we could successfully overturn the initial denial and arrive with a recommendation to commission. I am happy to say, I am glad we stayed with it and worked with your team. I am confident your preparation and presentation of all the facts, allowed the careful consideration and ultimate commission by the Department of Army Headquarters. Thank you again for your fairness throughout and great legal representation to arrive at this outcome. read more

** Tully Rinckey's response to my reviews is disingenuous. We already addressed this matter directly with Mr Hogan. The only options presented were to continue paying TR to correct their mistakes in their work--despite them already having the necessary information and documentation--or to close the matter and receive only the unused portion of the retainer. Mr Hogan had the opportunity to resolve this privately and chose not to. ** Our experience with Partner Derrick T. Hogan was extremely disheartening. After I raised legitimate concerns regarding defective, factually inaccurate, and a legally weak demand letter produced by the firm, Mr. Hogan treated the issue as though we were simply dissatisfied with a draft. The firm already possessed the necessary information and documentation to prepare the demand letter , yet we were effectively expected to pay additional fees to correct mistakes that should have never occurred. During our phone call, Mr. Hogan repeatedly emphasized that he was a "Partner" while minimizing the substance of my concerns. He did not meaningfully address the factual errors, omissions, weak legal posture, or the firm's failure to properly handle a serious matter involving retaliation and safety issues.  This matter severely affects my 88-year-old mother and our household. We had already been dealing with a destabilizing situation for approximately a year and a half, and I expected someone serving on the Client Assurance Committee to listen carefully, investigate what had gone wrong, and help resolve the problem. Instead, the conversation felt focused on defending the firm's inaccurate work product and billing rather than understanding the deficiencies I had identified.  Mr Hogan did not provide a meaningful remedy, the options presented were essentially to continue paying for revisions or close the matter and receive only the unused portion of the retainer. This left us with an unusable draft after a substantial portion of our retainer had already been billed.  Mr. Hogan's approach was dismissive, condescending, and unhelpful. I would caution anyone seeking capable, considerate, and zealous advocacy to look elsewhere. I cannot recommend Mr Hogan or Tully Rinckey. read more

This was the worst law office I have ever dealt with. Beside pushing me to the back burner for a simple military upgrade 7 yrs later and 5 lawyers later, I get a lawyer who doesn't like my kind, but hey what ever, but when we agree on things and he waits (4 months) for me to call so he can charge me 400.00 for issues he should have been dealing with but he forgot until I send him the email we stated it. Sorry so much hate and anger against this company for taking advantage 1st a veteran who was blind to a promise and then nicely removed 6000.00 from me and nothing except if you pay more we can go further. 20yrs is a long time to fight the military for a simple upgrade from administration to honorable. I can say thank you tully for being like our government and no helping the veterans from 1992 just take our money like the government does. If people would like more info email me at polarbeard_s@yahoo.com we can exchange # and talk read more

My husband is a combat Veteran 82nd airborne with two tours in Somalia. We purchased our NNY property with a VA loan. We experienced immediate issues with a property easement where we are the servient estate. The dominant estate was/is creating an undue burden with an out-of-code hazardous utility panel. Not only is there a burden to the property owners (the Veteran family), there is also an infringement on the property title. We hired the Latham NY office of Tully Rinckey and they gave our case to Carol Crossett (Partner, Manhattan) who is perhaps the most obnoxiously arrogant, rude, unethical, shrew on the face of this planet. In addition to her terrible demeanor, she was lazy and her grasp of property law is apparently so piss poor that she tried to convince us, her client, the Veteran family, to pay for all of the costs to resolve the overburdened easement and infringement. Opposing counsel admitted in court documents that she told him that we didn't have a case. Further, she drained the $15k retainer by pretending that she couldn't understand the difference between a utility panel, a utility meter, and a utility pole. She feined ignorance to elicit explanation emails so she then bill us for responses to her nonsensical questions. It was one big grift. Luckily, another firm stepped in at no cost to us to resolve the civil dispute, and at no expense to us. Tully Rinckey doesn't support Veterans, they exploit them. read more

Contact this law firm back in October 2024, signed contract November 3rd and paid $2600 for an eviction of a tenant. Mid November I called and talked to my assigned lawyer since he didn't contact me. I was informed things were on track and the tenant would be out by January 1st. Beginning of December called my lawyer, called again nothing, nothing, nothing over and over again. In late January, I received a notice of my bill. Over a $1000 of my $2600 was used. Hold on, used I what? My lawyer hasn't talked to me, January 1st came and went (lost potential new tenants) and your trying to tell me I used have of my money. I wrote to the managing lawyer. I asked for my money back. I then received a letter saying my lawyer is on extended leave due to personal reasons. You are now assigned to another lawyer. I talk to new lawyer in February. He informs us that he was assigned our case and this other really great case that he can't wait to work on. Our case will be over soon and our tenant will be removed. We are starting over, cool. Filled new lawyer in he is ready to go. Then crickets. March, can I please get an update. Nothing. And this went on until June. Finally June 17 is our court date. June 16 I received a call from our lawyer. Everything is all set for tomorrow but I won't be there I have a conference call. He is sending another lawyer who is up to date on our case. June 17, 3rd lawyer shows up for court (I'm still not convinced she is a lawyer). The only thing that she said during court was her name. I spoke the whole time. Judge informs us tenant has 30 days to get out, he asks the tenant if he need more time than that and he says sure, my new 3rd lawyer, nothing. Not a word, objection, excuse me nothing. Tenant get until July 31st to get out. So a simple eviction took Tully and Rinckey 9 MONTHS to get my tenant removed. 9 months of no rent being paid, but we are paying this half assed lawyer group to basically drag their asses. Then, icing on the cake then send me a final bill in august asking for additional $250 and it needs to be paid immediately. So simple eviction took cost $2900, I lost 9 additional months rent coming in on top of what the tenant already owed. Talk about get screwed by your own lawyers. STAY AWAY FROM THEM. UNLESS ITS A BIG CASE THAT THEY ARE EXCITED ABOUT. read more

After having written an earlier review and then agreeing to remove it for a payment from Tully Rinckey I have found even more disturbing information about my Father's estate that was handled by Carrol Crosset, a partner at Tully Rinckey. First I would like to express that I have a right to my opinion and there is no amount of money that will make me remove this review so they should not bother sicking their HR department on me again! To start off, Miss Crossett is probably the most nasty and arrogant person that I have encountered in my entire life. In the beginning of my case she told me that she was not sure what they had even given her my TEN MILLION DOLLAR case because she felt it was beneath her...rather arrogant, yes! Then after several months of pleading with her to bring the case back to a realm of civil discussion over and over when she repeatedly became irate with me for wanting to know the whys and hows of what was going on with my case, she enticed me to sign off on the final releases without ever telling me that I had other options to settle the most bizarre and ridiculous happenings in this estate that was wrought with perjury, embezzlement and accounting trickery . She never even told me that I could appeal afterward. The only thing that she was interested in was taking my seventy five grand and then getting rid of me as soon as possible, leaving me with a total mess and being totally screwed out of my father's estate. Be wary of these people, they are very nasty and underhanded wanting nothing but your money and a quick resolution regardless of what happens to you. Now my entire retirement is gone thanks to her! If I could leave a minus ten stars I would! read more

Retained the firm for a simple uncontested divorce that was written for them. Attorney Daniel Gvertz had drawn out communications over months, couldn't handle dates and signatures, and admitted to filing incorrectly. Meanwhile fees are being racked up, also by a partner supervising the case. Daniel refused to draw documents to finalize the divorce as written, with the opposing party also begging for fair and ethical conclusion, while that is clearly stated in the retainer. Along with being updated, to which I was not. Once the court returned documents of judgement, Daniel split leaving me and the other lawyer to question everything. Daniel then refused to represent stating they have completed whatever they felt they had done, while also creating bogus documents for me and my ex wife to sign behind her attorneys back. All evidence of begging for months and then failing had been reason for refund that they refused. They then made up a "client assurance committee" that wasn't concerned in the first four months of my begging to tell me they performed their job. Then filed with the BBB to which no one read the emails of Daniel refusing service, and refusing to create documents their retainer clearly states they are responsible for. Partner responds that any details break client attorney privilege and the firm completed their job. Two partners couldn't explain to me what the firm had done, I had given clear evidence of them performing like it was their first day. Avoid at all costs, even the partners can't read emails of clear negligence. read more

Poor response time- not great knowledge. Needed prompting to respond. Not efficient. Consult that you pay for is a sales pitch. Wouldn't recommend. read more

Rob M. I highly recommend Allen Shoikhetbrod as Counsel. He is focused , respondsive , very easy to talk to , highy effective and knowledgeable . He immediatly took a deep dive into My case, navegated and thoroughly evaluated the issues and kept Me updated throughout each day. I will retain him moving forward and I have no doubt He will Help You. I Highy recommend Him! read more

I had a great experience with Tully Rinckey with counsel Mr. Sean Timmons. This firm was able to represent me for a case, and we achieved a favorable outcome. It's never good when you have to get lawyers involved, but it helps when you have Mr. Timmons in your corner. read more

Avoid, avoid, avoid. They lie to cover up lies. They will pull a bait and switch on you in court. They do not care about you, your family, or the results that they facilitate. Do NOT put your trust, faith, or money into this firm. Be warned. They will only add insult to injury. read more

Highly recommend this law firm. Very helpful. Timely responses back to messages, very knowledgeable and courteous. Richard Brister was amazing and a pleasure to work with. He made a difficult experience go alot easier for me. Highly recommend him as well as the firm. Kudos to the firm. I wish there was a rating higher than 5 stars because they are worthy of it. read more

I contacted Tully Rinckey for legal advice for a moving scam situation. The attorney was excellent. He guided me to the next step to take, and it was not hiring his firm. He was empathetic and even offered some personal insight, not your typical attorney! I am pleased with the low payment for high quality consultation. I highly recommend this firm to handle whatever your legal need is. They are friendly, know the law and trustworthy. read more

Having had a very difficult divorce 17 years ago and having to now close out that chapter of my life, as child support comes to a close, I felt totally at ease speaking with Mr Michael Liptrot, for my initial consultation, to represent my case. As Attorneys go, I felt the high level of integrity in his voice, and empathy, while planning on representing my case. I feel confident now, that I have found a way to fairly hold accountable, the uneven outcome of 17 years ago, with honesty! read more

Won my case with MSPB ..! OPM disabilty benefits..so glad they handled my case. Thank you.. read more

I worked with Attorney Allen Shoikhetbrod. I was really pleased with my representation. When there was a need he contacted me right away. There were times in the waiting process of my case where he did not always reply, but in retrospect this was because there was nothing new he could tell me and he ended up saving me money, he was able to help me using just over half of my $5000 retainer. I was shocked when I heard there was a remainder to my retainer. read more

I am impressed by the courtesy of all the contacts I was in touch with at the firm and the personal attention and client service provided by the attorney who I was referred to my a family member. I recommend the firm. read more

The attorneys at Tully Rinckey provide depth of knowledge and the requisite level of professionalism expected from a top-notch law firm. Having interacted with Mr. Shoikhetbrod and Mr. Cometti on a pressing legal matter, I was left duly impressed. I would recommend Tully Rinckey to others and use them again when the need arises. read more

After receiving the worst possible representation ever, I tried reaching out to the firm via phone calls, email, and I even wrote a letter , however, nobody would reply to me. It wasn't until I wrote a review in the YELP site, that someone got back to me. I was told to call or email them ASAP to resolve the problem. Well I did that, and 2 weeks later, I still haven't heard from anyone! What a joke of a firm!, read more

I reached out to Tully Rincky when I realized I could not handle what I was about to deal with on my own. Fighting to have visitation of my Son that passed daughter I could not afford to lose I had to get it right, when I called my calls were answered or returned when I felt panicked I was assured they had best interest at heart. I would like to Thank You Peter Charnetsky for taking my case and also Theresa Levine for keeping me updated in everything that was going to happen and did happen and Thank You so much for winning my case you gave me the Faith that I wasn't alone and you reunited me with my granddaughter I am forever Grateful Thank You Joyce read more

Mr. Shoikhetbrod and his staff at Tully Rinckey were absolutely fantastic from start to finish. The level of communication throughout the process along with there commitment to making sure I received the every last penny went above and beyond the call of duty. I would highly recommended them!!! read more

I should have done this before !!! Several years ago firm was hired to represent Granddaughter in a school matter . Went to Albany sat down with attorney and discussed what we wanted gave deposit and on way back to Binghamton thought how happy with attorney and what was discussed. Over next few months we had several discussions and reviewed items that we FOILED from school district . It was at this time all communications ceased .I finally called law firm and asked for i believe Gus ! Oh he is no longer with firm . I blew a bit and asked when i was going to be notified ? New lawyer called next day and said " My name is Doug and i will be handling your case and i will be making you ,daughter and grandaughter $$.I said ur missing the point it is Right or Wrong !! After months of him doing whatever we were told some kind of legal BS to this day not sure what it was !! But low and behold Doug thought we could win on appeal but needs $$$$$ . Worst representation one could ever have . Believe he is no longer with firm !! I wrote to the firm a lengthy foul worded letter on exactly what i thought of FIRM . Not really happy with myself on wording but to this day this upsets me !! Even with a signed statment with admission of guilt from accused !!!! Terrible firm I recieved email firm has new attorney handling Title 9 etc all i can say is good luck !! Only person in this firm that has control of business is a very nice Irish lady named Patti !! knows firm inside and out ! Excellent person to deal with ! Good luck people read more

I would never, in good faith, recommend this law firm to anyone. Their tenacity and communication was limited to hooking you as a client. Pretty much all communication was limited to that which I initiated. Their "aggressive" representation was limited to an offer to write a tersely worded letter after I complained that the US Army had completely ignored the FOIA request. If you need legal representation PLEASE do yourself a favor and find another firm. This firm is a complete waste of time, effort, and money. read more

Great law firm, they were more than reliable and understanding of my situation. My lawyer with the firm was Tyler Patterson who went above and beyond to assist me and my family with my legal issues. I would recommend both him and this law firm for any issues someone would have. They were worth every penny spent, and more than reasonable with their rates, especially for the level of service they were willing to provide. Thank you again for all of your help. ~ Apeksha read more

As the first reviewer said these guys are horrible. The attorney I'm most focused on is Gavin Routt. In anticipation of this company weaseling out responding like they did with the review by reagan I will say nothing in this message violating attorney-client privilege so everything here could be responded to in the open. My issue pertained to getting discharged from active duty so it was pretty straight forward compared to other situations I've heard of. During the initial consult I was told by Greg Rinckey that he himself would be my attorney. This was great given his claimed experience level. But once I later paid the retainer ($3500) I found out my attorney would be a kid named Gavin Routt. I looked him up on Linkedin and he looked like he just graduated high school. Gavin Routt would not respond to most of the phone calls I made to him to include my emails. Worse was he charged $26 per six minute increment of work. From looking at the itemized billing (that's how it is with retainers instead of flat fees) every time he called me and had to leave a message I was charged $26. The reason I missed many of his calls was because the building I worked in had lousy reception. I told Gavin this repeatedly in advance and that he would need to send me a text or something just before calling so I could find a good spot to receive a call. He never followed my advice leading me to think he was not listening to me and also not reading my emails. He never outlined any strategy for how to handle the situation until I insisted to know what it was just before firing him. The biggest issue was not refunding the retainer. I initially had to pay $3500 to start things off. After Gavin Routt drained it he said I had to refill the retainer. But shortly after refilling it I decided to fire him and that meant I should get all of it back minus about $100 to 200 for recent charges. Gavin Routt refunded NONE of it. In emails and in phone calls he acknowledged I would get the refund and now we are two months later and they refuse to refund it. But they always said nice things when I corresponded with them. I even contacted Gavin Routt's boss Robert Rock and his entire response was "I am sorry for the hold up. I am checking with finance to see what has happened and make sure this gets out today." I think "today" is relative as days are measured on Jupiter because it has been several days since I have heard from anybody. A few tips I picked up from this ordeal: 1. only hire attorneys that charge a flat rate. Any that use a retainer do this with the intent of hooking you and nickel and dimming you. 2. find out in advance who will be your attorney before paying anything. 3. if they insult you during the initial consult (I was called an "idiot" by Greg Rinckey) then go elsewhere. If this is how much they respect you before starting a formal relationship just think what it will be like later on. 4. whoever is assigned to you as an attorney look them up on Linkedin for further information. Profiles are exaggerated this could still be useful. read more

Great law firm. Mr. Shoikhetbrod was professional and made me feel at ease during my litigation. Displayed quick and open communication. He was always available to answer my questions. Would highly recommend Mr. Shoikhetbrod. read more

Our experience with Tully Rinckey was wonderful. My husband and I worked with Peter and Theresa. They fully explained the process to us and kept us updated. Our outcome was even better than expected. Could not have done it without them thank you so much. read more

Hands down worst representation I have ever seen. Had to obtain an attorney Derick Hogan. Young guy not very knowledgeable with criminal law. Didn't seem to know much about the issue I was dealing with. He pretty much should be on the other side of the court room, not a defense attorney. Treated me as if I was guilty and not innocent like I am. In the end I spent well over 10K on this guy, I even referred him to a friend in the very beginning. Both I & my friend ended up firing Derick and going with another attorney who was able to settle our cases for a fraction of the cost we spent on this "graduate" attorney. Completely dissatisfied with his overall performance. Just wish I wouldn't of given him so much money. Knickeled & dimed every last thing he could. I WOULD NOT RECOMMEND Derick to anyone for any reason. read more

Mr. Shoikhetbrod and his staff at Tully Rinckey did an excellent job in helping me file for FERS Disability Retirement. The FERS Disability Retirement process is complex and would have been very difficult to do on my own. I am so glad I hired Mr. Shoikhetbrod. He and his team did a great job of gathering my extensive medical record and preparing a very detailed incredibly written letter to OPM. He helped me throughout the whole process, I could reach him or his staff at all times. With such a complex and lengthy process, it was great to have his leadership at my side at all times and I got a favorable outcome the first time. 100% pleased. read more

Very dissatisfied!! Was told my divorce could be done in about 6 weeks for less than 1000 dollars. It was an uncontested divorce with no property. The child support and custody agreement had already been done by myself. My lawyer billed for phone calls she initiated, she billed for emails, and billed me 3 times to review the same document!!! I would barely hear from her I would just get an invoice and absolutely no progress in the case. It took over a year and cost 2000 dollars. I finally got fed up when she called and asked for 500 more dollars. I went to Legal Aid they did it in 2 months for free. I really disapprove of this law firm read more

Worst. Experience. Ever. Took my money and did nothing. Did not return phone calls. Unethical, misleading.

I could not have been happier with my experience with Tully Rinckey! I worked with Kelly and Karin. Not only did I have great representation, but they both went out of their way to explain the process and ensure me that I was in good hands. Situations like this can be stressful, but I am so thankful to have people representing me who were kind, knowledgeable, and supportive of me through this process. Kelly went out of her way to assure me that no matter how many steps we have to take there would be a positive outcome, and she was right!!! Both women communicated in a timely manner, most of the time almost instantly, which put my racing mind at ease. I truly could not have asked for a more professional team! read more

Fresh out of my second deployment to Afghanistan, I was fired from my government job for being in the Army reserve. They even said so in a letter. They said they could help but first they needed money, and the so I paid. And then they needed more, and more, and more. Eventually they had ALL my deployment money. If I said no they would drop the case and all would be lost. Eventually they won but only a few grand and nothing that covered nearly my bill. They claim to support vets. That is a lie. They support themselves. read more

Our family was very pleased with the service we received from the Tully Rinckey Firm. The attorneys we dealt with, Darren Swetz and Sandra Pieczynski were professional, competent and approachable. They were always available to answer any questions by email or telephone. We highly recommend them. read more

I went to Tulley Rinckey PLLC in Albany, NY for help with a tax issue. I talked to a case manager about my situation; she told me that her firm could help. I had to pay a $150 fee for my first consultation and it was over the phone. When I got my call for the consultation, the person introduced himself as Mike when I was explicitly told that I'd be talking to a Greg Rinckey. The guy already knew about my situation when he called and had no help to offer. The phone call took a total of 20 minutes. The only advice I was offered was to use a certified accountant. This is funny because I had talked to several law firms over the phone already and was given the same advice without having to pay $150. I was stupid enough to think that an attorney would be able to understand my case better due to the complexity of it; thus, I kept pursuing the legal route. If you are going to use this firm, DO NOT pay a consultation fee up front. It is a rip-off and will just cause you to feel like you threw the money away as I did. read more

I was very disappointing with this law firm. I met with them, they promised to take care of my legal matter and then never did anything. I took of work to meet with them and then followed up but in the end they did not do what they promised. Calls to their office require extended waits, several transfers and in the end, for all for naught. I wasted a day off work and a month's time and in the end, they did not have the decency of ever following up to my inquiries. This is my second attempt at this post as Tully Rinckey asked Yelp to flag this as not relevant. If that happens again, I will contact the bar association next as people need to know that this firm wasted my time and damaged legal matter by their inaction. read more

I felt that this law firm didn't offer me the candid legal consultation from day one on whether to pursue a legal case or not. Their main concern was that I simply pre-pay. Not mention that my case kept being re-assigned from one of their legal experts to another for at least 4 times. The original one even quit the firm, which caused me lots of uncertainties. The other reason why I won't recommend this legal firm is that because they nickel and dime everything and charge the client. Even when they pause during a phone call to sneeze (figuratively speaking), there goes a charge on the client. I would prefer to deal with legal firms that simply does it the good 'ole honest fashion way: one flat rate for the entire case. This new nickel-n-dime method is dishonest and opens the door for lots of unnecessary charges against the client's balance. I paid this firm close to $10 grand for an ill-advice and transactions that look like a credit card monthly balance. I wish they were more candid and have told me from the beginning that my case wouldn't yield anything, but they didn't. read more

Derrick Hogan at Tully Rinckey handled my case and I feel fortunate that he was my lawyer. I called to talk with someone about my case and by chance was connected with Mr. Hogan. He listened, asked good questions, and gave me all the information I could have asked for. He explained every step, what would or could happen in very clear and easy to understand terms. I was sent a retainer and explained the case would be covered by a flat fee, and that anything that came up in the future relating to the case would be fully covered by that fee. Although my case was probably one of the simpler, easier cases they handle, Mr. Hogan always made me feel that my case was important to him. He always urged me to call him if I had questions or wanted him to go over anything again. He even called me to follow up before I had to call him - something I find is rare with almost any professionals these days. He treated me with utmost courtesy and respect, was knowledgeable, and reassuring. I believe he is one of the firm's younger atty's, but I would not hesitate to recommend him. I feel I should explain the reason for the 4 star rating: An appointment conflict came up for the initial hearing, and Mr. Hogan had to have someone else cover for him. It was very simple and would not have been a problem at all as Mr. Hogan had clearly and explicitly explained what would take place. The atty. who handled it however, was over half an hour late to meet me, and I became very nervous as to whether she would show up at all. When she did, she didn't apologize or say anything about why she was so late, but she did handle it the hearing ok. When I next spoke with Mr. Hogan, he apologized for her - but that is my reason for the 4 star rating for the firm. read more

I utilized Tully Rinckey's services for my marital separation, will, healthcare proxy and power of attorney. My experience with Tully Rinckey started by reviewing their website and found the information Barbara King shared along with her video regarding separation and divorce was extremely helpful before hiring this firm for my needs. Upon hiring Barbara, she discussed several options for me including a mediator along with her as my advisor and this proved to be the best option for me with the least about of costs. Her experience, advice and review of my case was exceptional and I would recommend her any time. My services for the will, proxy etc., was average and I did not receive the level of service I did with Barbara. read more

I would rate my recent representation by the Tully Rinckey Law Firm as one of the worst experiences encountered. The lawyers that I dealt with were predominately unavailable throughout the duration of my case and they offered no suggestions or advice that was beneficial or supportive to the issues that I was dealing with. There were errors made by Tully Rinckey professionals relating to standard child support calculations at the onset of my case and no professional from the Firm offered any type of beneficial advise, suggestions or guidance when settlement negotiations occurred. I could not have been more disappointed in the professionalism and services provided by Tully Rinckey and I would not recommend their services to anyone. read more