Line went quickly even though it was busy…read more Our server was generous with the samples as we wanted to try a couple different flavors - portions were large and we were super excited with our choices. Ice cream is delicious. We live in San Diego and a Handel's just opened close to us recently - we were surprised to see pops and sandwiches at this Indiana location as we don't have those at ours.

Handel's NEVER disappoints!! Their ice cream is some of the best in town and I seriously love them…read more My fave flavor is the Graham Central Station and get it every time I go. The service at this location has also been amazing and I've never had any complaints. They usually move pretty swiftly so even when the line is super loooong!! If you're on the search for good ice cream, do yourself a favor and stop at a Handel's location !!

DELICIOUS ICE CREAM IN CARMEL, INDIANA…read more==================================== My husband and I visited on Sunday, June 21, 2026 after having lunch nearby. I sampled the bourbon ball flavor which was absolutely amazing. I almost ordered a single scoop of that until I saw toffee chip on the menu and had to order that. My husband most likely ordered something vanilla. I was too engrossed in my own selection to even notice. It's nice sitting out by the fountain outside if it isn't too warm. I have been watching the forecast today, July 1, 2026, and your ice cream would melt in two seconds. Just stay inside to eat it this week. I am really glad there isn't a Graeter's Ice Cream in Los Angeles or I would be in big trouble. It was so good.

I think handles is more affordable and you get more. It taste better also. I paid 7 for a 1 scoop…read morecone when I can buy a pint from handles for that price. Only 2 stars.

5 stars. I would…read morenever think to combine Italian ice and custard, but I'm glad someone did! I enjoy the sour Italian ices, but they didn't have any on my last visit He told me to call the day before and he would make sure someone made it the next morning! How sweet is that?!? Definitely a lil pricey, but isn't everything nowadays? They have a couple of tables where you can sit or walk down to the Nickel Plate and grab a seat or swing. Solid weekend afternoon outing for the fam.

Rita's is a pretty good deal for the price. I got my nieces some treats -- a small strawberry…read morecustard with gummy bears for one; a cherry Italian ice for the other. (About $5 each) The custard portion was more than my 4 yo could finish in one sitting but she loved it and it looked great! The cherry Italian ice cup was packed full and made for a good treat for my older charge on a hot day. The staff were super friendly and made sure to offer helpful suggestions-- like making the cone into a cup/cone hybrid to help her eat without big spills. They're a walk up shop, so they have order windows where you ring the little doorbell for service, they take your order, then you get it at the pick up window. They were pretty quick to fulfill orders too! Outdoor seating lines the sidewalks. When we were there, we snagged the last shaded table! I imagine when it's busy over the summer, you'd have to truly take it to go. Was definitely worth a stop for us today!

Lick Ice Cream is such an easy stop inside The Garage on Mass Ave, whether you're out for the day…read moreor need something sweet after dinner. I tried the sweet corn ice cream because obviously I'm not going there to make boring decisions and it was fun, creamy, and soooo good. I'm all for some out of the box flavors and hellllloooo we're in Indiana! One scoop was the perfect size, and the staff was super friendly and helpful while I picked a flavor. They also sell cookies, although sadly there's no way to warm them up, which feels like a missed opportunity for an elite ice cream sandwich situation. Cute, convenient, and right in the middle of all the Garage bustle. Definitely worth a visit.

I like Lick, but always have to get the vegan chocolate marshmallow flavor when I go. It's really…read morerich and creamy! But sometimes a gluten free and dairy free girl wants a different flavor, you know? Anyway, I'm always served quickly here and with a smile. It's one of the more expensive ice cream scoops I've had, though, so it's a rarer treat for me. I prefer some of the other vegan ice cream spots in town, but still enjoy visiting Lick when I'm over here.

Such a fun experience! When you go here you not only receive ice cream, but you also are…read moreentertained as you watch them create a magical masterpiece before your eyes. Service was helpful and quick.Pretty busy inside and a little loud so if you plan on having an intimate conversation maybe take it to go... Many tables to choose from. Something I didn't realize until after I'd ordered is that there is a coffee cafe that sells from within their shop... I will return to try the coffee and report back. It is called 1832 Brew Expresso Bar. Ice cream choices are many and so tasty! I tried the pistachio this time and enjoyed it!

Always stop in for this treat when in Carmel! Very cool experience for the kids. Expect a little…read morewait while the make your treat!

I got a peanut butter cookie dough glacier with brownie bits here and it was an amazing combo! They…read moreloaded it with brownie and had fast service. A great after dinner treat! Large seating area out front for those warm summer evenings

I ordered a chocolate glacier with marshmallows fluff and when I got home I was eating it and it…read morehad something in it, I am not sure what it was but it was stringy, I thought it might be some kind of plastic, I didn't finish it, and I live to far to take it back, I was very disappointed, I will not go back.

This location of Cold Stone Creamy is kind of hidden on a side street within a strip mall. What I…read morelike about Cold Stone is that you can design your treat from a selection of ice creams, toppings and cones. A clerk hand mixes your chosen ingredients. I stopped by after craving some ice cream early afternoon. The clerk was friendly and patient as I pondered the perfect combination. I was excited to see coffee ice cream, which is how I prefer my coffee. I settled on Heath Bars to mix with my coffee ice cream. What a delicious combination! The service was quick, but I was the only one in the shop. I ate inside listening to the motors on the freezers, which were very loud and annoying. Overall, great ice cream, good service and mediocre dining space.

I lost a game so I treated my friend to ice cream. Im glad they chose ColdStone because I haven't…read morehad it in years & honestly forgot how good it was lol. It's your typical ice cream shop but always cozy and has a welcoming atmosphere. There were two young ladies working who were so nice! I had the surrender to strawberry & added fresh bananas & graham cracker crust... yummmm! I thought I would need a to-go top but no, I finished it all smh lol. He had the cake batter w/ yellow cake, butterfinger, graham pie crust & a sprinkle of cinnamon, sounds like a lot but he devoured it too.

Good ice cream. You can tell it is a quality product with a low water content and a rich flavor. I…read moream not a fan of Ben & Jerry's values as a company but they serve a good product. We like to walk to this Carmel location from the Monon Trail. That also means they compete with Graters Ice Cream (also off the Monon) with our family. I think I enjoy both establishments, but Graters is our favorite. Plan to grab n' go because the seating is limited.

TLDR: fantastic ice cream, terrible seating options for groups larger than 2…read more I was excited for Ben and Jerry's to open their new Carmel location. We went a few days after it opened. The ice cream is, of course, delicious. If you've never tried Ben and Jerry's fresh from their store, you must try it. It's so much better than the store bought pints. You can taste the freshness. I'll be back for that reason alone. My main issues with this storefront is THE SEATING. There are a handful of tiny tables with 3 chairs smashed around them. The tables should realistically sit just 2. That's the largest option they have. They also have bench seating with the smallest little cloud shaped tables I've ever seen. Where are you supposed to sit if your party is bigger than 2-3?! We also asked an employee for water cups, and she looked at us like we were crazy. She had to ask a manager. We didn't receive water cups. Odd experience. Overall, great ice cream but the seating is terrible.