Top notch dentists'. I've been going to Island Dentistry for 25 years. Aira, one of the dental…read morehygienists, is an absolute gem. Helene Schaeffer, dentist, has a great bedside manner with children. It's always a joy to see Martha, too, at the front desk. Lovely place, lovely people!

I have conscientiously been going to dentists all my life and not since I was a boy have I found…read moreanyone as good as Helene Schaeffer at Island Dentistry. She is an expert at what she does -- taking care of her patients and making them look good. She does not try to sell you anything and her office is full of life and happy people, which says a lot. The office location is in West Tisbury by the Airport.

The worst dental experience I have ever had. He was very condescending, arrogant, and unsympathetic…read moreof the pain I was in when he was drilling on my tooth. During a cavity/filling procedure, I could feel a lot of pain as he drilled on my tooth. I kept telling him how bad it hurt and he basically said you need a higher pain tolerance or I can't work on your tooth. The Novocain he gave me didn't cause the numbness it is supposed to. He ended up sending me home without fixing the problem, telling me I need to see a specialist. He charged me $180 for this visit. I have dental insurance that covers cavities and filling but he said since he didn't fill the tooth I have to pay. This made no sense to me. He didn't do his job by fixing the cavity and I have to pay. I have been to 5 different dentists and have never, I mean never had an experience like this. He made me feel so uncomfortable while I was in the chair.

Dr. Herman and his office staff saved me. In terrible pain while on vacation I called the office at…read more4:50 pm and they got me in at 8:30am the next morning. They were friendly, fast and got me out of pain quickly. Dr. Herman made a diagnosis and prescribed an antibiotic. The receptionist helped me find a pharmacy. They emailed my X-ray and diagnosis to my own dentist at home. I'm very grateful!

Wife broke a portion of her tooth at breakfast Called Amnity…read moreDental and was told to come in on an emergency basis at 2pm Dr McNulty took my wife in and gave her a complete exam detailing the condition of her tooth and her options He was extremely professional as was his staff He had a very nice way about him We can not say enough of the services offered Thank you Dr McNulty and your staff

I'm so happy with the whole experience so far. Thank you for making it comfortable…read more S.F. Mom of S.M

Great looking brand new office. Always a friendly smile (cause they all have great teeth!) and so…read morekind to the patients. The staff is as good as it gets. This new place is state of the art. It's clean, refreshing and I wish them success on this lovely island.

Dr. Shea saved the day for me 3 days before my wedding. I don't live on the island and walked in…read morewith an allergic reaction and he was more than willing to help me. He and the front desk staff were so nice. I highly recommend them!

Excellent work. Care quality! Office Experience! I am quite grateful to Dr. Samuels for the…read moreexcellent gum surgery in May, 2013.

I gave $800 deposit. I made an appointment for an extraction. I cancelled well in advance and Dr…read moreSamuels refused to return my deposit. I had to get another dentist to call him. He ended up only returning 1/2 of the deposit.

My son had a dental accident/ tooth trauma while on vacation on Martha's Vineyard. Dr. Gear was…read moreamazing and so efficient and thorough, both in his care and in communicating with his providers at home. Would 1000% take my family to see Dr. Gear again!

Dr. Gear is a caring, professional individual. Her and her stuff were nothing but pleasant and…read morehelpful to me in my time of need. Dr. Gear and her team literally saved my vacation! On Friday July 28th, my first day of vacation, I chipped an already broken, decaying wisdom tooth. This was followed by excruciating pain and a sharp piece of my tooth digging into my cheek. I called every other office on the entire island, none of which were able or willing to help me. Finally I was able to reach Dr. Gear's office, who made time in their busy schedule to see me IMMEDIATELY. As soon as I arrived, I was greeted by her lovely receptionist to fill out necessary paperwork and was soon taken back to get X-rays taken by another lovely lady. Dr. Gear gave me a temporary filling, which consisted of clove oil. It relieved my pain, covered my exposed, sensitive dentin, and she also smoothed out the jagged piece of tooth so it was no longer cutting my cheek. Her office was exceptionally clean and had advanced technology. I highly recommend Dr. Gear and appreciate her help so much. Thank you Dr. Gear!

best dentist ever. he does amazing work and is the kindest soul I tell everyone how much I love my…read moredentist all the time. he goes above and beyond for our family and I'm super grateful for him and Almarie! I don't think anyone loves there dentist as much as I do lol

Windmill Family Dental has the latest technology... I got the most comfortable teeth cleaning ever…read morefrom their very experienced and knowledgable hygienist Irene, using an ultrasonic scaler. Irene and Dr. Mulcahy gave me a very thorough and patient explanation of all my issues and were very helpful about a treatment plan.