Last night was first time I ordered take out ( also my last). My order was a large pizza - half…read moreplain half sausage and extra brown on the crust & a half order chicken parm wings. Picked up order got home and the pizza was half pepperoni and not crispy or brown crust and the wings under fried, not crispy skin on the " flat" wings just soft skin . Now I forgive the wrong pizza meat as maybe I just got someone else's order but the only thing that was good with the entire order was that the amount of cheese they use is ample which most places are just short. If you order extra cheese you're chewing on rubber bands. It seems no one ever gets that right .. they're all being cheap and skimpy. The sauce on this pizza was bitter, like eating paste, not thinned a little bit & it was horrible and the crust chewy and soft. Pizza is my life long love. I've had pizza my entire life from living downstate, MD, VA and here. This ranks high on the bad ones. Reading the reviews I was somewhat hopeful but then again, seeing reviews from here is a crap shoot as so many praise places I think are inferior and wouldn't eat there. Some seem to get praised more for length of time in business rather than on food taste, quality etc. So for my family I'm sad to say Pizza on the Plaza is a bust!

Recently reopened under new owners. What a great little…read morelocal gem! The pizza is fantastic. The menu for a start up is small but everything I've had so far is fresh and delicious. The more support and business they get, the better the chance of them asking more options. Our last order they made a mistake. Not only did they fix it but they sent us home. With more than double of what we had originally ordered! You won't get better customer service! Give them a try, give them a referral, give them a review! You won't regret it. Dine in it's small and cozy or get takeout. You can't go wrong.

Have been there several times since they opened, tried something different and enjoyed everything…read morewe have ordered. Baked Ziti Sicilian, Baked Ziti Vodka Sicilian, plain cheese pie, half cheese half pepperoni and garlic knots... don't forget the knots. Being a bit of a pizza snob and waiting anxiously for this place to open I was not disappointed. Happy to have found a little slice of home (metro NY) right here in Vestal. Great food, great staff, great location.

Paid 16 dollars for 3 slices and a drink and they couldn't head up the slices properly. They were…read moreall cold in the center and the overall quality was average.If you cannot get a simple thing as temperature correct, I am not surprised you cannot produce a good pizza.

Understaffed so we sat at the bar. Excellent fresh pasta, perfectly steamed broccoli, warm bread…read moreand attentive service by Gabriel. Nice Manhattan, but you need Luxardo cherries, not maraschino. Bar seating is always fun for engaging other patrons

For starters, I'm not a huge fan per se of Italian food and I'm not the type to typically set time…read moreaside to post reviews. Outside of Pizza, don't care much for spaghetti, or meatballs, or Lasagna or Penne A La Whatever. But, these guys? Just set the standard and made me a fan of Italian food at the ripe age of 54. The Spaghetti Ai Frutti Di Mare, good gosh, unlike anything that I have ever tasted before. Absolutely amazing is all I can say. My wife I believe had haddock, gave me a bite, melts in your mouth. My step daughter has the chicken marsalla, another knock out. The atmosphere was decent, family oriented, nice lighting, I'd say 7 out of 10. Parking lot gets full quick around dinner time (understandable truthfully). But the food??? 15 out of 10. I wanted to order another Spaghetti Ai Frutti Di Mare to go, but my wife protested and said for me to stop being greedy.

$33 for a large veggie pizza? Make this make sense. $25 for a large chicken wing or rib pizza, $33…read morefor a meat lovers of same size. You're telling me a veggie pizza should be more than the meat pizza and as much as a meat lovers? Out of your mind

Great place good food Enjoy !!!!!great people and village…read more...wish them all luck in the future!!!!

Yes, very good. Totally different taste. Sometimes I crave this for something different. A sweeter…read moredough.

I was recently talking about bad pizza with my daughter whose husband is from the Binghamton area…read moreand I mentioned how Terrible the pizza was at Brozzetti's. Her reaction was "OMG my husband swears by the place, they all love it". This actually reminds me of friends from Taylor/ Wilks-Barre PA that swear by the greatness of Old Forge Pizza. Let me be clear, this pizza is glorified ELLIO's frozen pizza. While visiting Johnson City i was told by acquaintances, I must have the pizza at Brozzetti's. "It's Life Changing". This is tasteless generic pizza. I could have chewed on the cardboard box with some sauce and not noticed the difference. I would travel to New Haven, Brooklyn, Chicago, even Phoenix (which i hear has excellent pizza), and I appreciate different styles like Detroit style pizza, But I'm glad I didn't make the trip to Johnson City purposely for Brozzetti's. I can't believe I am saying this, go down the street to Dominos if you need pizza.

I know it was only take-out but what an amazing experience!…read more The online ordering through the restaurant website was really easy and it gave me a coupon for $5 off a purchase of $30. I was shocked at the 45 minute wait time for some chicken wings but, I saw how busy they were when I go there. I loved the atmosphere when I walked in. It was busy at the bar and restaurant but no one was waiting for a seat. That's a great sign. Immediately, I was asked if I had an order. I told the gentleman I could wait but he went back and put a rush on the wings. Within 10 minutes I had the wings, and an apology for how long it took. Although, it was well before my 45 minute pick up time. The parking lot is a bit cramped but there's not much room to expand. Besides, they have been there since I was a kid. The wings were so good. They came with blue cheese, celery, and carrots. Overall, this place is well above 5 stars. I can't wait to dine in and visit the bar side. Great service and I hope they stay open for another 40+ years.

Active and well behaved clientele. Wonderful Italian kitchen fragrances. Attentive wait staff…read more Wonderful flavors.

First off the place was packed but the wait time was pretty quick considering. We did make a…read morereservation. We waited maybe 10 minutes. The place was very clean and the greeting staff were nice. The service at the table was phenomenal. Our waitress was on point and we never had to ask for anything. She didn't write our drink orders down and everything came out perfect (and fast especially for bar drinks). The food was delicious. The French onion soup is in my top 3 all time. My Delmonico was cooked to perfection. It could of used a little more seasoning but I could add it so that wasn't an issue. My wife got the homemade Gnocchi which she said was spectacular. She added on shrimp for 13 dollars which is pretty standard at a nice restaurant. My son got a pizza just to try and we all loved it. The fries were good! The chicken wings were crispy and had a lot of sauce too. Very good combo. Overall it cost us around 250 bucks (tip included), but that was for 6 of us and with bar drinks. Overall a great experience and I would definitely recommend and will be coming back!

Enter and the garlic hits you before the warm smiles and friendly greetings at the host stand…read more Leave and the garlic has fully invaded the soft tissues of your mouth. Wake up the next morning and it matters not what toothpaste or mouthwash you used, garlic! Love the food here trumped only by the service. Gabby was terrific! I haven't had bar service here so no can't comment. Oh, and lead with the garlic cheese bread. We'll be back! Thank you!

Delicious food will see how delivery goes Today and that is…read moreit, taste of food So hungry eggplant parmigiana

Found it through reviews. Best Italian I've ever had. We had Chicken Bruschetta and Fettuccini…read moreAlfredo (both recommend by our server). Upgraded the side of pasta to their homemade, with red sauce. Bread was warm and perfect. Their homemade Italian dressing for the salad was outstanding. Brought home enough for a second meal. Sooooooo good!