Been in St. Pete for over a year now and I had almost given up on finding the right Italian place for us, and then we found Tony and Nelly's! Thank the good heavens. Party of 4 Saturday night with reservations. Our dishes were all delicious, and portions were awesome! Veal saltimboca Meatballs and gnocchi Baked Ravioli and a meatball Pasta ago frutti Di mari fra Diavlo Holy smokes!! Food for days... can't wait to try take out when we hit Fort DeSoto in the RV! Bravo!!! read more

See all

Great Italian restaurant very authentic! Try to make a reservation because it's small and the portions are huge and very yummy. We had a pizza for an appetizer and added ricotta cheese very rich. Our main entrées sword fish, freshly caught, and you could have it anyway you wanted it to mine was with capers and olive oil. We also had broccoli pasta with Parmesan and a wonderful view masala. The mushrooms were so yummy. I know I said Yummy so many times, but everything was!! must try. Bring your appetite. read more

See all

I am overdue to write a 5 star review of our favorite, local Italian restaurant, Tony & Nello's! My wife and I live close by and dine here frequently. More importantly, the quality is such that we frequently bring our house guests here for dinner and they constantly love the experience. The entire wait staff have been with the restaurant for a long time and are all very service oriented and friendly. The portions are HUGE! Warning - we routinely get 3 servings out of a single dish, so order accordingly ;-D Their Pizza is amazing and the Chicken/Veal Parmesan is a consistent winner. We also love the Scampi & Pasta dishes. The Sausage and Peppers appetizers is a particular standout and the bread that accompanies the meals is simply amazing! If you are anywhere near Tierra Verde, do yourself a favor and break bread at Tony & Nello's - you'll become a return customer too! read more

Annual trip to Ft Desoto. Dined in this year. Fabulous pasta. Our table had chicken marsala, cacciatore, shrimp scampi and pasta primavera. All were delectable and portions were large. The stand out was the roasted pepper bruschetta, best appetizer I've had in a very long time. It was massive and would make a great meal for 2, with side salads. Service was sketchy because they were busy and our waitress was new. 20 minutes to get wine... Ambiance was noisy and crowded but the food made up for it. read more

Tony and Nello's - Chicken cacciatore and veggie primavera!! These are platters, not plates. - Pizza Near Me - Tierra Verde, Florida

See all

First off the waiter was good. However I go to restaurants for good food! This was NOT ! It was HORRIBLE! One I didn't get the write dish I asked for breaded chicken I got boiled chicken. Tough chewy uneditable. He did offer to take it back but it would have taken to long. My husbands dinner was disgustingl!!! Absolutely disgusting!!! The bill came to $169. It wasn't worth $6. We used to go here all the time but won't go back again!!! read more

A Sicilian Italian, family style restaurant that consistently pumps out delicious food with a variety of Italian standouts and nightly specials The Sicilian tomato salad is a must have for me Where do they get their tomatoes ??? The best I have had in Florida !! With shareable portions of standards like chicken Parmesan and chicken piccata a variety of pasta and veal dishes with various sauces I had a nice angel hair with aglio & olio and anchovies that of which I was still eating 2 days later the service is friendly and professional a decent wine and beer list in a bustling trattoria setting read more

We were there early and the service was excellent but there were very few other customers. Our server was very friendly, attentive and knowledgeable. The food was served hot and plentiful. Very good ambiance. The muscles were flavorful but tiny . The pasta dishes were very good. Overall we enjoyed our experience. read more

This is definitely authentic Italian food. We had penne a la vodka and it was flavorful and so creamy. The pizza, amazing! We ate the entire pizza between two people because it was just that good. Best tiramisu and cannolis we've ever had. The meatballs melt in your mouth and the marinara sauce was the real MVP in all this, it was homemade and made every dish just that much better. FYI: HUGE portions read more

Tony and Nello's - Penne a la vodka - Pizza Near Me - Tierra Verde, Florida

Excellent dining experience... cozy ....huge portions ....tomatoes actually tasted like tomatoes!!!!.....service was great.... a wonderful night!!!!! read more

Super good!!!! Servings are giant. Would definitely recommend sharing plates. Adam was a good waiter, good vibe inside. Pasta Rustica was AMAZING best meal of the four we got read more

Tony and Nello's - Chicken cacciatore and shrimp scampi - Pizza Near Me - Tierra Verde, Florida

See all

Food is always amazing, the Philly and vodka pasta are our go to's. 10/10 recommend - service was amazing and sitting at the bar is great too read more

Tony and Nello's - Penne alla vodka - Pizza Near Me - Tierra Verde, Florida

Hannah said she was new but she was far from a new server, she may have been just new here. She was excellent! My wife has come here a bunch but this was my first time. My house salad and bread appetizer were excellent. I ordered the Nello's Carbonara and it was great. My family enjoyed the veal piccata and Alfredo. Heard great things about the pizza. This really is a hidden gem. It's Friday night so we enjoyed the atmosphere being a little crowded and exciting. read more

Tony and Nello's - Nello's Carbonara special - Pizza Near Me - Tierra Verde, Florida

I am leaving this place with a smile in my face. Everything was so good, amazing, delicioso, spectacular. The service was kind, friendly, best of the best. Do not leave this place behind for its looks. The facade needs an update, but that is truly not important. The people inside make the difference. The authentic Italian cuisine was the best I ever tried. :) read more

Tony and Nello's - Chicken Marsala - Pizza Near Me - Tierra Verde, Florida

Great service. Food is awesome. Portions are HUGE w reasonable prices!! Will be back !!

We're staying with our Aunt and Uncle for a month here in Tierra Verde and wanted to try this place. My husband and I are foodies and love supporting local businesses. Dinner for four included a large pizza, which was HUGE, Greek salad - also huge, and a nice bottle of Chianti. Everything was delicious and perfectly made. The icing on the cake was our server, Peter. He was attentive and funny and we really enjoyed every minute we spent there. This place is a gem! read more

Tony and Nello's - Having fun drawing on the table - Pizza Near Me - Tierra Verde, Florida

See all

Visiting our daughter in St Petersburg over Easter weekend. She took us to Tony & Nello's in Tierra Verde. Walking in, the smells were so darn fabulous, we knew the flavors were going to be spot on!! Not a huge restaurant but plenty of space to enjoy yourselves. Nicely decorated with plenty of that Italian feel. Not quite busy yet, so we sat at the bar. Johnny was our Bartender .... Very friendly guy. Asked what we wanted to drink, we weren't sure because we had JUST sat down and looking over the menu. Very, very attentive. Plus he was answering the phones & getting to-go orders lined up. He worked like a Swiss watch. By the time we left, the place quite full of guests and orders were flying out the door. We figured out what we wanted. Pizza !! Found out EVERYTHING was in large portions. We ordered a tossed salad, ($14.95) which was plenty enough to feed 4, easily. I ordered a glass of wine...nice pour by the way, Johnny. Thank you. They delivered some hot bread as well. Delicious !! Then the large pizza arrived, for the three of us..... 1/2 meal lovers & 1/2 Tony's Special. OMG..... it was HUGE !! Loaded with sausage, pepperoni, peppers & black olives. It was certainly full of flavor. Guess we got the NY style because it was very, very thin. Tasty but we would have preferred it with a thicker "chew" on the crust. If they offer a thicker crust... we missed it. We each ate one slice, took the rest of it home and had it for breakfast the next day !! Just as tasty ! Yes, highly recommended. We would go back in a heartbeat !!! read more

See all

Really liked this place suggested to me by friends. Why? Because they make a great gluten free pie and other stuff I don't get to eat a lot. There were gf pasta options but with the smells in play this is where I broke my blasted pizza fast. Sure glad I did it was worth it. I even took some home for later after giving it my best shot! This place is very Italian, so they had great wine too. Pricey because its in a tourist area, but their bruschetta bread looked legit too! Would def chill here again. read more

Tony and Nello's - Gf small - Pizza Near Me - Tierra Verde, Florida

We where visiting from out of town a little sceptical at first but we said let's try it so we walked inside and was met by the waiter who was friendly after a few qustions we decided to order a pizza 1/2 sausage roasted peppers and 1/2 fresh mushrooms and it came out pipping hot larger than most lg pizza around we could only eat 2 slices and decided to box the rest . the pie was quite filling lots of cheese and sausage pep[ers and mushrooms the best way to describe it "Delish" the next day heated it up it was fantastic a go to if on Terverdi I can't wait to get back to try other foods they serve. read more

We were recommended to dine here by two different friends that live in the area. Had we known this 30 years ago, we would have been there every time we come down. We were greeted with smiles and it was so cool to be able to see into the kitchen and have a look at that brick oven!! Tara was our delightful server and treated us like we regulars! The fried Calamari was breaded to perfection and the fresh HOT bread was remarkable! We split the Veal Saltimboca which was cooked to perfection and we ordered a Tiramisu to go! And Tara gave us a fresh loaf of bread to go! Tony, himself, stopped by to say hello! What a nice guy!!! I highly recommend this restaurant for anyone who appreciates really good Italian Food!!!! read more

My dish was good and a huge portion. Bread was delicious and everyone in our party enjoyed our meals. I only rated four stars because A) I drove 30 minutes to get here because I craving lasagna. Got there at 6pm and they took my order only to return 15 minutes later to tell me they were out of lasagna. I understand the issues with making lasagna, but it's only 6pm, your open until 9pm and you run out. Makes little sense to me and I never got to try their lasagna. B) The meals state that bread is included, we were a party of 8 and were only given enough bread that we each got a very tiny slice. I later asked for more and the waitress seemed shocked that I was asking. We did get more and it was delicious. read more

Tony and Nello's - Baked Ziti - Pizza Near Me - Tierra Verde, Florida

To much for one trust me. Good food and quantity much for one. Hard to find small family restaurant like this. Please support them!

The food is delicious. Service is even better but the ambience, well it's nice. Let's just say you don't go there to stare at the walls. But they're clean. read more

I gave them a third chance and they failed me again. So sad. I ordered a pizza with mushrooms and meatballs. The crust, cheese, mushrooms, and red sauce were excellent. The meatballs reminded me of scrapple because the meat was crispy and spicy. Not what I expected from a meatball. As they say, three strikes, you are out. read more

Took almost an hour to get two appetizers and a house salad. The waiter was worried we would not tip him so he sent Nello's wife ( she apparently is the manager). She firmly informed me that she decided that our meal should take almost an hour wait for our order because they were busy ( not when we got there) for 2 appetizers and one house salad, even though those around us that arrived after us were getting served food., because she decides the order of the food that goes out. There was drama happening between the server and management and that affected our food service. We tipped the server 25% but unfortunately will not be back. The manager was rude to me 6 years ago when she was Nelly's fiancée. Now she's more rude and ugly today. The food is good, and portion size is fantastic, but she is a turn off. read more

Ordered the eggplant parm which I have had multiple times. Always great. Tender and flavorful. This time eggplant was tough and I kept picking around looking for a tender piece. Finally sent it back. Manager came over to argue why it wasn't tough. Offered to take half off the order. We were a party of 8 with drinks. I told her not to bother. Won't be back. read more

Food is top notch. Service was great, we did not have reservations, which was a mistake, but they sat us and never rushed us. It was our first time, but will be back regularly once we return to st. Pete. Great value! read more

We had an amazing dinner. I can't say enough about the food and service. The quality and size of our meals were very generous and delicious. The staff and owners are wonderful. We look forward to our next visit. Highly recommend this restaurant for the best Italian food. read more

Came here after a day at Ft Desoto and Egmont Key. We were in coverups and sandals. The place is casual but nice. The service was excellent. Our waitress was on top of checking on us and refilling drinks. I ordered the Eggplant parmigiana but with Alfredo sauce instead of a red sauce. It is served with a side of pasta. So good! Didn't reheat well the next day but the day of was incredible! I heated it up in the microwave instead of the oven so that may have made the difference. Would definitely go back! read more

Tony and Nello's - Eggplant parmigiana with Alfredo sauce instead of a red sauce - Pizza Near Me - Tierra Verde, Florida

Italian Italian. Heaping big portions. I can't believe anyone would finish their meal and plenty of take home containers around. Great service as well read more

On my first full night in town, while visiting my mom for the holidays, we ordered takeout from Tony and Nello's. We ordered their chopped salad, which came overflowing with tons of delicious toppings. And we ordered a pizza that was pepperoni and mushroom. I didn't place the order, so I'm not sure what size the pizza was, but whatever size it was, it was ginormous and enough to feed three hungry adults with leftovers. The glorious slices of pizza were gooey with cheese and the size of my head. Given the size, I was surprised how well the pizza crust held up to all of that cheese and toppings. The style of pizza definitely reminded me of New York style pizza and had that wonderful balance of flavor and greasy goodness. I would definitely come back and order pizza from here again the next time I'm in town. read more

Very good, we made a large pickup order, and the food was great. We did the eggplant rollatini. In my opinion, the sauce was a bit sweet, which is typically a con for me, but it worked here. Very good. Now a word of caution food can get a touch charred, but I wouldn't call it burnt. Also had some wings, they were big and fried well before saucing. The pizza looks good too, but I did not try. The atmosphere is pretty good, a family italian restaurant. It was a little small. We are excited to go back. read more

The service was excellent and the food delicious at a reasonable price, especially since the portions were large. We had the spicy shrimp appetizer, veal saltimbocca, and chicken piccata, all scrumptious. read more

This is a local favorite for the neighborhood. They have decent pizza and big portions for their entrees I only come here once a year since I do low carb yet when My group of friends want take out this place is their top pick. We call in our order, describe our car & 35-40 mins later you can drive up, pick up and go. They make it very easy. We ordered one pasta dish that lasted for 3 days. Also an order of mixed vegetables (they were a bit too oily for me) and a large side salad with cucumbers & peppers. Staff is always kind & helpful. They are even my re helpful & patient when you t comes to choosing off the menu since there's is a lot of options to choose from on their menu, available online too. read more

Tony and Nello's - Pizza Near Me - Tierra Verde, Florida

went there last night to meet friends but were to sit at a table next to them since they had a large party which when we made reservations told no problem we got very nice waitress said she was sorry the table that was across from them that was empty would not be available to us and we would have to seat far away from the came to hope to be and that the would not change your mind. I asked to talk to her and she was unresponsive to my request so we took the table available and had dinner the table that we had requested stayed empty for the full duration. We were there and at least a half an hour after my friend had left , when I mentioned this to the person in charge, she was rude and told us there was just too bad. She didn't know how long we were going to be there and it was just too bad if we didn't like it, so sad that a successful has a disregard for a good customer I was told it was the owner's daughter. She should have learned from her parents how to treat a customer read more

We had a great dinner at Tony and Nello's. The food was delicious and portions were generous. But the service we received from Tara stole the show! She was so pleasant, attentive and personable. We will be back. read more

This is our favorite italian restaurant! It's so tasty, tons of food and just a great atmosphere. Last night was so busy! I felt bad for the workers but they all did a great job. I had the fra Diablo shrimp pasta, as king as you don't mind very spicy it's amazing. My husband had a pizza which looked perfect and tasted even better. You definitely need a reservation between January and April. In the past we have had the raviolis and eggplant parmigiana. I have yet to have a bad meal. The plus is, there is always so much food you have dinner and lunch the next day! read more

Tony and Nello's - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tierra Verde, Florida

See all

This is easily the best Italian food in all of greater Tampa Bay. Also this might be the best bread and butter I've ever had... Wow, just wow!!! read more

Always a wow!wow!wow! for us! Great local spot with fantastic food. Give them a try and definitely start with the bruschetta. Tonight we had the gnocchi and chicken Marsala which was incredible. read more

Tony and Nello's - Gnocchi - Pizza Near Me - Tierra Verde, Florida

Offers made-to-order HUGE portions, with friendly service in a clean, nicely decorated room. It was impossible to hold a conversation, since the noise level was like being in an echo chamber, so Take Out and maybe sitting at the bar would be a better dining choice. The veal parm, and the other pasta dishes our table ordered, plus the crusty bread and crispy salad, were delish. My mom was born in Italy, so I have had eggplant many different ways and love it, but their Rollatini Appetizer was strange. The eggplant was bitter, plus so weirdly unchewable that it was not edible. read more

There is no better Italian Restaurant in the St. Pete area. I'm hesitant to give it a great review because it's already tough to get in, but it's worth the wait. You won't be disappointed. read more

Tony and Nello's - Pizza Near Me - Tierra Verde, Florida