Great selection and staff. Been going there for years…read more Many clothes and shoes to chose from.

Great selection, great staff and if you really look you'll find a deal or two…read more And if you can't find a deal, check out the basement store. Totally separate entrance around the side and down the shabby stairs. They do nothing to enhance the ambiance down there, but if you take the time to sort through what they have you could find that surprise item that you can't find anywhere else for half the price or even less. But back upstairs, they have everything from vacation wear to formal wear. From every season, to outdoor sports, to accessories. If you like that New England look the MA Islands are so famous for, this is where you can find it. Most often when we come here we shop in both stores. Sometimes we climb back and forth trying to decide if we like the deal downstairs more than the full priced item upstairs. You should try it when in Vineyard Haven. Great way to waste time waiting for the Ferry!

My son bought his first pack of Pokémon cards here. Very…read morecool shop with all types of toys and collectibles. I even got a "ribbit" on the way out. Highly recommend stopping in - will be back.

Fantastic shop! Jake, the owner, is always incredibly helpful. We have never been disappointed…read morewith a recommendation. Once we brought a group of kids in to pick out discs form Disc Golf. Jake helped the kids picked discs, gave some instructions and tips to get them started, and provided directions to the course and recommendations on what holes to play. Had a huge smile on his face the entire time. You won't find a shop owner who loves what he does more than this guy and it absolutely shows.

A super cute bookstore with a great selection of books, cards and novel gifts. Staff were so…read morehelpful and welcoming especially the sweet kitty!

Super-cute bookstore with lots of lovely gift selections, too. I even got a small toy book from the…read morevending machine.

So many unique things here! One of my favorite stores in Edgartown and I visited multiple times…read moreduring my trip. Excellent selection of books, art work, interesting souvenirs, cards, journals, photographs, and more. Friendly service and ambiance.

This is not a store...this is an adventure, a destination, an escape, pure paradise. I loved the…read moreuse of quotes, objects, art, statues, the diversity in book selections. Overall my new happy place!

PROS: this is a huge souvenir store that has loads of items with many varieties of items. One lady…read morewas nice and wrapped my item well CONS: the young lady wearing a gray sweat jacket was in a terrible mood OVERALL: as long as you don't get the young lady helping you, you'll have a great time shopping here

This is your one stop shop for wrapping paper, gift cards, trolls, and claddagh rings!…read more Also available: watches, glass animals, candy. Has this place changed in decades? No? Awesome!

Yes the place still has deals, but "Fred" is never there ( 2 years in a row ) now. Not sure if the…read moreplace was sold or Fred retired and he let a new crew run the place. 2 years in a row, unfriendly sales staff. Not the old town feel from before, but if you want good deals, go. Part of returning to a business is to talk to the owners or regular staff. Not the case here any longer.

Thankfully Trader Fred's donated clothing and underwear to our 50 brave souls from Venezuela. Thank…read moreyou . .

Lady that owns the store is very nice, inventory is plentiful, prices are good, located near center…read moreof the shopping district

This is an amazing souvenir and convenience store! Staff is nice, prices are great, wide selection,…read moreand it's located in center of shopping district

Edgartown Paper Store is one of my favorite places to shop! They have an amazing selection of…read moregifts, souvenirs, toys, snacks, books, and everything you might need while visiting the island. The staff is always welcoming, friendly, and happy to help, and the store is clean, well organized, and easy to browse. Every visit is a great experience, and I always find something unique. Highly recommend stopping by if you're in Edgartown!

As noted by others, the older woman behind the counter was rude, offensive and aggressive toward my…read morefamily. She missed out on a large ticket purchase from us and I would never, ever recommend anyone go near this store. There are other tourist oriented shops just down the street but stay far away from Off Main.

My adult daughter and I were shopping there and would have purchased some items, but the older…read morewoman who was working was extremely rude and muttered about "throwing" an item down, when it was a fabric hat that was placed down. My daughter also saw her roll her eyes at us. We did not feel welcome and were quite taken aback by the rude manner of the older woman working there. I would not recommend shopping there at all.