My wife and I were on a walk and spontaneously decided to pop in for some appetizers here. We ended…read moreup ordering entrées and a couple of nonalcoholic beers. Both of our dishes were really good... The veggies were fresh, the guacamole was tasty, the chicken was tender and much better than expected. And, both dishes had lovely sauce and flavors. The Mole was particularly good. Alejandro, our server, was so nice and professional. Anyway, we were pleasantly surprised all around and will certainly be back before we leave the island. Muchas Gracias.

Taking a break from seafood and sandwiches we decided to go for Mexican. The service was friendly…read moreand really fast in a good way. The food was excellent and flavorful. The place is clean and everything looks good.

Just to clarify, this restaurant is close to the ocean but you won't have a view of the ocean when…read moredining here. It's surprisingly spacious inside with plenty of seating/tables for large parties. Food: generous portions. My husband ordered the shrimp and I had the fish tacos. The tacos require assembly. I wouldn't recommend them on a first date, as they are a little messy to assemble at the table. All of our food was fresh and prepared well. We also had the grouper bites as an appetizer. Service: excellent. We had Paige and she was great, checking in and keeping our drinks topped up and making sure we had everything we needed.

Service was definitely fun, although not what I expected when booking to eat here online! I would…read moresay that the oysters were not as good as I expected compared to where I am from despite the pricing. It had a little grittiness and were a bit small despite the price. The cocktail and lemon matched them well complimenting their flavour overall. The shrimp and grits was a good choice, reminding me of Jambalaya from a local dinner back at home. Ambiance was very laid back!

My husband and I stopped in for lunch and had a great experience. He ordered the fried oyster…read morebasket and I had the fried shrimp, and both were excellent. The seafood was very fresh and cooked perfectly, and the portions were generous. Our food came out quickly, which was a nice surprise. What really stood out was how friendly and helpful the staff were--they made us feel very welcome from the moment we walked in. Great service, great food, and a really enjoyable lunch. We'll definitely be back!

Taylor was our waitress and she was awesome! Food was wonderful. Only reason I'm not giving it 5…read morestars is because we ate over a dusty parking lot but would do it again! The food is good! Staff is kind.

Best lunch on Hatteras Island! The corn and shrimp chowder, fish tacos, and crab cakes are a must…read morehave!

We always stop at Buxton Munch when we are down there. My wife had the tuna and I had Grilled…read morecheese. We both had the Shrimp corn chowder and it was great. Great atmosphere. If you're down that way stop in and enjoy.

Amazing food, but they need to up their cocktail game. Add a whiskey cocktail to the menu, please…read more Super nice staff, good music (although, I think you may want to check to make sure both your L and R speakers are working) and for a spot in gas station lot, they did a good job with the feel of the place.

We came in just before closing and the service and food were both great. We always research where…read morewe eat but we were coming back late and just saw this and decided to try it. So glad we did! We will definitely tell others what a great experience we had!

Server was top notch!!!! Good great. Burger looked amazing…read more Cocktail sauce was homemade and delicious. Fried shrimp yummy. Perfect French fries!!! Lively photos on the wall. Pub atmosphere. Gingerbread crème brûlée yummy.

Our food was amazing! Our waitress was very attentive and made sure we had everything we needed!…read moreWill definitely return! Highly recommend!

Amazing food, great atmosphere! Love the cheesy garlic breadsticks! The fig and prosciutto Sonoma…read morepizza is delicious!!!

Salad, cannoli and sub par pizza x2 for $65. I'm looking at the good reviews and the pictures do…read morenot look like the same pizza we got. It looks almost like premade rounds of pizza dough - and tastes like microwaved pizza. The top was dry sauce broken apart. Good reviews show fresh buttered on top pizza. WTH? 1st meal in OBX on our anniversary- not happy. I could go to mellow mushroom and pay a 1/3 of the price and get more for my buck and waaaayyy better quality.

Our dinner was delicious!! The service was friendly and prompt... Rusty came out to see if we were…read morepleased with our dinners. ... We had a pleasant evening with Belinda, our waitress and the ambience was lovely. Definitely will recommend family and friends to visit Rusty's while on vacation!! thank you!!! Christina and Paul

We come here often, usually twice during our twice-yearly visits to OBX. We always enjoy it but…read morewere especially pleased with our visit last Friday night. The calamari appetizer was I think the best fried calamari I've ever had--especially tender, breaded with the lightest coating and fried to perfection. The shrimp and grits, which we have ordered each trip since Rusty put it on the menu, was the best ever and also the best version I can remember. All in all, an excellent meal! Adding to our pleasurable experience was our server, Belinda, who was funny and delightful as well as attentive. And to top things off, Rusty visited our table to check on our satisfaction. A good evening. My husband always enjoys the craft beers available on tap. If I had one quibble, it would be to up their game a bit in the wines available by the glass. The white wines, at least are pretty lackluster. But a small price to pay for an overall excellent experience.

Go for the sunset views, cocktails, and desert. Main course not worth it…read more Get a reservation early for the stunning views. Worth it but not for the food. For fine dining, every dish was slightly off. Thai curry mussels, too salty. Yes it's mussels but it over seasoned. Shrimp pasta, shrimp was overcooked and too many capers make it too acidic. Tuna with the coconut rice, overcooked mushy rice. Cocktails were amazing. Desert was amazing. Go for sunset, cocktails and desert. Not main meal.

Just WOW! I've not had crab cake Benedict quite like cafe Pamlico. The service was wonderful and…read morethe food... so yummy! Very, very good. I'm so happy I ate local. To me, it's a win win