After a full day of walking, biking, and convincing myself I definitely wasn't tired, Millie's on…read moreMain hit the spot. My daughter ordered the burger, and it was a winner. The patty was juicy, the bun was soft and fluffy, and somehow she still managed to have room for dessert. Kids are magical like that. My husband and I both ordered the pan-fried whitefish because, come on... you're on Mackinac Island. You have to. The fish was fresh, flaky, and perfectly cooked with a light, crispy crust that let the flavor of the whitefish shine. Exactly what we were hoping for. The restaurant has a fun, laid-back atmosphere that feels like the perfect place to recharge before heading back out to explore the island. The service was friendly, the food came out quickly, and everything tasted fresh. If you're visiting Mackinac, don't overthink it. Order the whitefish, steal a fry from whoever you're eating with (it's vacation, calories are on island time), and enjoy a great meal.

It was surprisingly empty when we went in, perhaps because we were there between major meal times…read more But we were greeted, seated and then promptly ordered. Everyone was friendly, the restaurant and restroom was clean. The atmosphere felt very cozy, we had a seat by the window which was lovely for people watching although apparently people line up for the carriage ride right outside the window. Our food was great, a really good experience.

The place has GREAT pizza. By the slice or a whole pizza. Small place but great for take out…read more One of our yearly go to places

I believe this may be one of the few pizza places on the island. It was a very busy Fourth of July…read morenight. The pizza was mediocre at best and you're going to pay top dollar for it. I would skip it unless you have no other options for food. The staff was pretty friendly at least .

You know whwn you're in a tourist town and you eat at a restaurant right in the main downtown area…read moreamd afterwards you think, "that place must only stay in business because of its location"? Well, that is not the case with this place. We stopped in for a late lunch after a 3-mile kayak tour and we somehow managed to get a table immediately. They were extremely busy, but our server was efficient and attentive. Everything was clean and our drinks and food were excellent. I had the bruschetta checken and i was sorely tempted to lick my plate to get every bit of it. We also bought a souvenir for my brother: a shirt that says, "we support pour decisions".

Needed a place to eat and found the Broken Spoke! The place next door had an hour wait, so we…read morechecked out the Broken Spoke. The wait was about 15-20 minutes - so much better of a wait time! I like the theme and vibe of the place - the play on bikes and name of the restaurant is perfect. Decor is bike themed but not overly done. Rustic and laid back. Our waitress was excellent - very friendly and attentive. All staff were wearing masks. Good drink menu in addition to food. A lot of small plate options but the portion sizes of the small plates could feed at least 2-4 people. I went with sweet potato fries and steak tender bites - delicious! The dipping sauces for the fries had three different options - sweet/savory, loved trying each one. The sweet potato fries were not mushy and had a good crunch. The steak was cooked to perfection - I asked for medium and I got medium! Everyone seemed happy with their food. Restrooms were downstairs. Nice dining option in the city - only con there was no outdoor seating. Picking up on social media - looks like this place used to be Huron St. Pub & Grill not sure if it was a re-branding or new owners. Either way, I hope Broken Spoke is here to stay on the island!

You have to make an effort to get off of the tourist main drag to get over to this place. There was…read morea couple blocks off of the main strip. They had a Detroit style pizza, and it was fabulous. For being in such a tortoise spot, I felt they did a good job and the prices were fair. It is attached to another restaurant, so it's a little confusing at first, but you will figure it out and enjoy it.

After a long day, this pizza was absolutely amazing! It was just Detroit style pizza and it was…read morephenomenal. The service was quick and we got our pizza within 15 minutes of ordering.

We had the most amazing meal and service tonight! Joseph our server seemed to be very busy but…read morecould exceed our expectations in spite of it. Nathan at the bar was great too. The staff was overall off the charts. We ordered whitefish, veal, lobster Mac and cheese and crab cakes which were all outstanding! A fantastic restaurant and wonderful experience!

Went to the 1852 grill to celebrate an engagement that occurred earlier that morning. Was hoping…read morethat they would give a nice romantic experience to cap what was a wonderful day, and they certainly delivered everything and more. William T. was an exceptional waiter and made us feel like we were the only couple in the restaurant with his hospitality and his attentiveness. As for the food, the walleye was delicious and the NY Strip you could cut with a fork. The carrot cake was excellent. If you're looking for a wonderful meal to celebrate an occasion, I could recommend no other.

Best restaurant I have ever eaten at. The owners, staff and food were top notch! I would recommend…read morethis restaurant to everyone!

This was our favorite meal on the island this week, which surprised us because no one had…read morerecommended it to us- and it definitely felt more local than some of the more tourist-popular establishments Great waiter (very patient with our questions) and good Chevre Salad, add whitefish for $9 more Friend had the nachos (first meal on the island she wanted to take home) and overall, most worth the $ also Best mule I've had in awhile too

We ordered pizza after having some drinks at the bar! We liked the pizza and it was nice that they…read morehad a gluten-free option :)

We were looking for a quick bite while we were on the island. After reading YELP reviews, we…read moredecided to give this a try. We were delighted that we could sit out on the back patio that overlooked the lake. What a great view. We also were entertained by a mama otter and her three pups. Super cute. Our server was delightful. Very helpful and guiding us through the menu. We asked what's her favorite thing on the menu. She said not only is this my favorite thing on the menu. It's everyone else's favorite. She suggested the chicken tenders. Not normally something I would order at a restaurant, but boy, I'm glad I took her suggestion. Probably the best chicken tenders we've ever had.

We saw pickle pizza on the menu and thought, "Who would order that?!" Sent a photo to our grown…read morekids who tolt us- "You gotta try that!" So we did. And I'm shocked to tell you that we really liked it! I'm not kidding! Light, creamy sauce. Cheesy. Nice chewy crust. And, although I don't LOVE pickles, we both thought it was tasty. I'd order it again. Service helpful and quick. Order at the counter. Ambiance was aigght. Regular local place as you might expect. Nothing special, but decent and clean.

The man running the tables and talking to guests - 10/10 sir. Your hospitality is appreciated…read more Loved the pizza and wings! Crust was SO good!

My friend and I visited Mackinac Grille on a Saturday night in October around 8:30 PM after a long…read moreday of driving to St Ignace. The restaurant was busy but we were seated on the enclosed patio right away. It was warm enough with their heater and our jackets. Our server stopped by our table soon after our arrival but seemed very rushed and didn't spend much time with us to answer our questions about the menu. We ended up ordering the pastie and patty melt. The pastie was a copious portion of ground beef, and more than one normal size meal. It tasted good. The patty melt tasted good but nothing I couldn't make at home. The sides were about two ounces of canned baked beans and Cole slaw with way too much creamy dressing. I might go back for another meal, but would not order the patty melt again.

I have been here a numerous times and somehow have not written a review…read more With overdue the place needs a face lift outside and inside. The staff is great and very welcoming. The food is somewhat hit and miss White fish cakes are phenomenal perfectly crispy on the outside and flaky inside. Burger was huge but was ok needed some seasoning. Chefs white fish creation is definitely different but not bad by any means. Great view of the lake. May be some music in the background during lunch time would make this place a bit more lively.