2nd time here. First time the pizza was EXCELLENT, far better than any other in the surrounding Gun Lake area. So went back to try one of two Specialty Pizzas. We tried the BBQ Chicken and it was good, just good. Chicken was of good quality and the dough helped to deliver good pizza. I have had A LOT of versions of this pizza over my 25-30 years this one was only good. If one of the brothers are paying attention hears some free actionable advice. Tweak the following to make it outstanding: slightly more chicken, use a ticker bbq sauce that's not watered down, add grilled or fresh slivered onions on the surface so they roast, add well cooked bacon, and then you will not need to add so much cheese because the other flavors will stand up on their own. Yes this might cost a little more but if it's outstanding the increased price won't be hard to swallow . ..see what I did there? lol. Judging by all the other reviews this does not look to be sold frequently or worth raving about. Thanks for the good pizza. We'll be back! read more

Three Brothers Pizza - BBQ Chicken Pizza with added onions - Pizza Near Me - Middleville, Michigan

See all

One of the best pizzas! The service was quick and friendly, and the pizza was great! We got the basic pepperoni pizza for take out and it was fresh out of the oven when we got there! The sauce is less sweet, which is awesome and lots and lots of cheese. The crust was thin and toasted perfectly! Super fresh and tasty! Definitely will be back! read more

Love the pizza and cheese bread-it's always hot and cooked perfectly. It's our go to pizza place in Middleville. Everyone is always very friendly too. read more

We had a large party at Barlow Lake, which was out of their delivery zone, so we picked up an order over $120! We probably could have done smaller pizzas because they were massive and basically everyone took a box home with them. The Hawaiian was definitely a fan favorite as well as the pepperoni that had a kick. The cheesy bread was a little bland but was still a favorite for the kids. We will definitely be grabbing take out from these guys more often. read more

Three Brothers Pizza - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Middleville, Michigan

Ordered a couple of pizzas while visiting family. Crust was great, toppings plentiful. Great pizza joint!

The best pizza in the Middleville area!! Every time each pie is perfect! And staff is always friendly.

I don't know how this place only has 3.5 stars! We were hungry, and they were open, and so we called in a 14 in cheese and it was fast and SO GOOD! So good, in fact, that I feel the need to correct the record. Great pillowy crust, lots of cheese, and a sauce that was my favorite kind- not too much oregano. It all came together beautifully! The Middleville location was great and should be commended! read more

Pizza is very good, also the wings are delicious. I order my pizza well done and it's perfect every time. The staff can sometimes seem to be in a rush and a little off putting read more

Yum. so good yum pumpkin love it like spice and sage orange yuuuuh brown green brown rice

We stopped ordering from any other pizza delivery option because the quality of the food (pizzas & salads) are far superior and generous with the toppings. The pizzas are not greasy or oily like other more nationally advertised chains. The pizza toppings taste fresh and are well distributed over the entire pizza. We really have nothing negative to say about the food or the service, this the 5 star review. My husband usually opts to go pick it up versus delivery, but both pick-up and delivery options go smoothly. No errors in our order and always on time. I've been in once and the staff was nice and helpful. read more

Well. Drove to Middleville to pick up a pizza and bring it back to Wayland. Completely different experience. After taking my order and ringing it into the cash register, same person moved back to handle, bare-handed, ingredients for my pizza. No hand washing. Task completed. Still no hand washing. You don't handle money then food. Absolutely disgusting and disappointing. Please train people in food hygiene. Just discovered. Pleasantly surprised to find out they delivered to the Cobb Lake area. Pizza was still pretty hot and delivered earlier than estimated. Loved the sauce which tasted fresh. Crust was good also. Toppings fresh. The whole experience was better than expected. Will definitely give them another try! -UPDATE- Have now ordered for delivery 3 times now to Cobb Lake. Each time the pizza has been fresh and surprisingly pretty hot. Very good pizza. Recent transplant to Michigan. Best pizza so far. Haven't tried other menu items. Will in the future. read more

We called to have pizza and other food delivered and they were unwilling to deliver where ever other pizza place will deliver. We won't call ever again. read more

Best pizza in town! No exaggeration. You might save a couple bucks by ordering from the big chains outside of town but why put yourself through that? 3Bs is the best and willing to customize your order which is always nice. read more

From out of the area, stopped by while passing through town. The pizza was super great! Loved the taste, the cheese was cooked perfectly, with just the right amount of crispyness! Tried the cheesy bread too and it did not disappoint either! read more

Four years later, we gave it another shot. Much better experience, no metal shards this time! Smelled awesome coming out of the box, we ordered a large pepperoni and between the two of us it was dinner and breakfast! Had to laugh after placing the order, the girl on the other line was very... Direct. "What do you want? What's the name on it?" Didn't even ask if it was delivery or not, she must be psychic though because we were picking it up after work. read more

The people are plesant and helpful. The Pizza was fine. The sauce and the crust were a little too sweet for my taste, but for the area it was good, not great but good. read more

Their phone etiquette stinks.... Every time I call Three bros. I have talked to what seems like a Neanderthal. He doesn't say hello, he just says "three brothers... what?" Like a trained monkey... I think (wish) this place would shape up and hire someone who knows how to use a phone. I enjoy their chicken wings so i guess it's all part of the game....when I call I prepare myself to talk to what seems to be thick apes, not able to work a phone properly. As far as I know, this is only an issue in the Middleville branch. Other than that, I suggest the chicken wings! :) They are also Terribly rude and unfit for business when you go to pick up your order. (dont even say hello, just say "pickup?"...."Name?" "credit or debit?"...thanks) I still go to 3 bros because it's close to home. They do a pretty good job of imitating Waldorf in Hastings (Waldorf makes a better pizza, and much better wings...) I will suggest Waldorf any day of the week over 3 bros...hands down... just too far for me sometimes. read more

Good pizza at a great price! You can buy it my the slice at lunch time also, two slices and a pop for five bucks!

Ordered four large pizzas of various types - BBQ chicken, meat lovers (equivalent), supreme, and pepperoni. All tasted pretty good. The BBQ chicken was my favorite by a mile. None of it was really great after being re-heated (crust was a little too greasy). The thing that kept me from giving it a great rating is the price... 4 larges and a 2 liter was over $70, picked up. Delivered it would have been over $80 after tip, thus more than $20/pizza. It was good, but not that good. read more

I am a fan of their pizza. I suggest trying the BBQ chicken pizza as it is probably my favorite, but the regular pizza is great as well. Generous toppings so eat it while it's hot and don't forget the napkins. Available by the slice at the counter for cheap if you just want to stop in for a quick lunch/dinner. read more