The Shell Bar is, in a word, Wyoming's "Cheers." if you remember that award-winning TV series or…read moreyou've caught it in re-runs, you know its appeal is much more than the setting; it was the characters who made the show a smash hit. In my opinion, the same applies to the Shell Bar. Now don't get me wrong, the setting in tiny rustic Shell Wyoming is awesomely scenic and refreshingly serene. And the completely rebuilt bar, designed as an homage to the structure that historically occupied the same footprint, is nothing short of spectacular. But just like "Cheers," it's the people who make the Shell Bar the kind of place "where everybody knows your name and they're always glad you came." The newly redesigned, completely rebuilt and recently (July 2024?) reopened Shell Bar was just getting going for limited hours a few nights a week when we visited in August, but it was bustling with locals and out-of-town visitors alike. The atmosphere is relaxed, welcoming, fun and inclusive; nobody is allowed to be a stranger for long! While Wyoming is famous for its cowboys/cowgirls (or is it "cowpersons?"), and there's no shortage of authentic Wyomingites at the Shell Bar, you'll find them friendly, easy-going and more than happy to tell you interesting stories of life in their rugged, landlocked state. Even if you're not a card-carrying member of a certain political party that dominates the state (guilty as charged), you'll be welcomed respectfully and as a friend. The Shell Bar does have a full kitchen and I believe the owners have plans to eventually offer food made on the premises, but for now they seem to be happy hosting a variety of rotating local food vendors who feature their delicious fare each night the Shell Bar is open. As for libations, this place has it all. From several beers on tap and an even more options in bottles/cans, to wine, cocktails, soft drinks and more, Shell Bar has what you want. Their liquor selection (including an impressive range of Scotch whiskeys), is top shelf and their prices are quite reasonable, particularly compared to what we are all paying in more urban drinking establishments. The bottom line is that if you find yourself anywhere near the feet of the gorgeous Big Horn mountains, stop by the Shell Bar for a memorable visit to a true local gem. "You wanna go where people know, people are all the same. You wanna go where everybody knows your name."

From the owner: New Bar - Gather, Drink, Playread more

Amazing food!! Great ambience and great service!!!! We started with vodka martinis with really…read moregreat hand stuffed blue cheese olives. The spinach and watermelon salad was to die for!!!! My husband had a meat pizza and said the best pizza sauce he's ever had and I had the vegetarian pasta which was amazing!!!! House margarita was a solid deal for happy hour!!! Highly recommended!!! Make a reservation as we went on Tuesday and it was busy!!!!!

One Legged Magpie is truly a gem and an unexpected culinary delight in Red Lodge. I wasn't quite…read moresure what to expect as we walked in, but from the moment we entered, I knew we had stumbled onto something special. The interior was a little on the dark side, but the warm, inviting vibe pulled us in. We navigated our way to the main section, finding two wonderfully comfortable plush blue chairs next to the bar. The small details immediately caught my attention--each table adorned with fresh flowers in charming vases, adding a thoughtful and personal touch. Our server was genuinely sweet and attentive, setting the tone for a relaxed and enjoyable evening. I did notice they have an outdoor patio out back, but the atmosphere inside was too good to pass up. We began with the spring pea salad--an absolute standout--featuring creamy ricotta, crisp snap peas, fresh mint, and pistachios. It was fresh, crunchy, and beautifully balanced. We added a slice of toasted ciabatta bread, topping it with the salad to make our own bruschetta-style bites, which turned it into a perfect little dish. Next came the spice-roasted carrots, which were every bit as flavorful as they were beautiful, followed by the pork belly barbecue with a blueberry barbecue sauce. The sweetness of the sauce paired beautifully with the rich pork belly, creating a dish that was both comforting and elevated. For drinks, I had the Jayne Mansfield--a bright, refreshing, and totally unique cocktail--while my mom enjoyed the Lauren Bacall, which she loved. The restaurant's name comes from a fun and memorable story: the owners were discussing their plans to open the restaurant when they spotted a one-legged magpie. It stuck--and now it's part of the charm of the place. One Legged Magpie delivers on every level: warm atmosphere, thoughtful touches, incredible food, and a sense of place you won't soon forget. If you're in Red Lodge, this is a must-visit spot.

This is one of our favorite places to eat in Northern Wyoming. Worth a drive for great food and…read morewonderful people. 100% recommend!!

Incredible pizza, and wonderful folks who are the owners/servers…read more Excellent service, need to try the Philly cheese pizza.

Easy pickup for to go, excellent burger as always. Fries were obviously fresh and toppings were on…read morepoint. We make this a choice for dinner every time we are in town. Outside patio with live music is also good.

the service, the atmosphere, the food-- all incredible!! came here as a recommendation that it was…read morethe best burger in town and it did not disappoint. I was able to sit outside on the patio and they had live music and it was a great ambiance and place for gathering, having drinks and eating good food. the servers were so kind and helpful making sure everyone was well taken care of. highly recommend the rodeo burger, it was so flavorful and yummy and the fresh french fries were an added plus! definitely could say it is the best burger in the west!

A solid place to grab a decent meal. Who knew that restaurant reservations were a thing in Cody?…read morePizza was a touch overcooked despite explicit instructions to the contrary, but the cherry pie made up for the miscue.

Food was meh. Prices were too much for what it is.. is it horrible? No. Do I plan on being a…read moreregular? Also, no.

Food was outstanding - loved everything…read more My miso grilled salmon salad was the best I've ever had.

Fourth night of dinner in Red Lodge and our least favorite place. Let's start with the positive…read more Love that you can sit openly in the bar area. The waitress was also very nice. We got the Street Corn Dip and it was not as described. It was very smoky which we would have never ordered if the menu stated as such. We ate about 1/4 of it and normally that would acknowledge the waitress or someone to notice but no one asked. All good. I had the curried gnocchi which was a decent vegetarian option but just ok. My husband ordered a tall boy Coors Light which was a normal 12 ounce can (not sure why it was called a tall boy). Oh and there are flies everywhere in the restaurant so I was constantly trying to swat them away. Not sure why as we haven't been in one place in Red Lodge with flies (not even open bars with all the windows and doors open). That part was really gross!!!!

It was a great venue and the band was amazing! Loved watching the country dancers…read more The drink prices were reasonable and the pizza connect to this venue was amazing! Fun night

Although I didn't stay beyond several sound checks, the bands I heard weren't that good. Further,…read morethis place is packed with very young people who aren't even old enough to drink...even though they're sitting at the bar. There are also some CHILDREN here. Personally, I don't want to hang out in a BAR that caters to under age teenagers. Why this place has gotten so many good reviews, I'll never know.

We were in over the the week of the Fourth of July. Food was great. Definitely a busy place…read more Got a dinner and a show. One of the servers had pants on so short she about need a second hair net. I mostly watched the customer look at her butt cheeks hanging out of her shorts. Old men, women and kids (young girls) were looking. Five stars for the food.

This place is rad!!! Great atmosphere, great drinks and live singers! We went to this place because…read moreit stays open late. What a pleasant surprise it was. Service was on point!

Great food, full bar. Great ambiance m, but not pretentious. I had ridden motorcycle from…read moreLivingstone, MT to Sheridan, WY through a downpour. Got my hotel room and changed clothes, but was still looking a little ragged, almost didn't go because I wasn't sure I would be welcome in jeans, boots and t-shirt and a mop of wet hair. Couldn't have been more wrong. Great bartender, Bridget. I ordered a Scotch Ale. She asked if I would like a shot of Vanilla Vodka in it. Never heard of that before. It really perked up the ale. Ordered the In & Haute Burger it was great; Apple Bread Pudding with Caramel-Whiskey Sauce. It came in small cast iron skillet which kept it hot through the entire time I was eating it. It was cooked perfectly, almost burnt, but not quite, crispy char on outside warm moist and fluffy on inside. Customers at the bar and servers walking by were all friendly and welcoming.

We were traveling through and found this spot on Yelp. What a gem!…read more Alissa was our server and she was exceptional! She was attentive and charming. The restaurant is so charming. I loved the decor. Both our dishes were delicious. I had the salmon tacos and they were fresh and extremely tasteful. I really haven't had such delicious tacos in a very long time. My husband had the elk bolognese. The pasta was definitely made in house, just delightful. The sauce was rich and savory. Lastly we shared the bread pudding which we highly recommend. It was amazing! Wonderful experience!