My party and I dined in for their first night of doing full service, and it was very apparent that they were still figuring the new system out. An order consisting of a junior cheeseburger took almost an hour to come out of the kitchen due to the disorganization of the staff, which I don't necessarily blame them for considering they were clearly understaffed. In light of this, everything else was an incredible rebound in the right direction. My tenderloin was excellent and my party (even the person whose food took nearly an hour) thought their food was great, too. A definite improvement from my last visit and I applaud them for improving the quality so substantially. read more

The Superburger - Jumbo Breaded Tenderloin - Burgers Near Me - Paoli, Indiana

I ordered 12 Nuggets only got 10. Fries and 2 burgers 28.50$. I used to come here all the time but it is just not the same. Also the worker and friend were smoking right outside the front door. Not professional. Turned a place that you would stop at after a game to a sit down restaurant in order to get tips ? I will stick to the ritz and Hardee's for future orders. Super disappointed. Also price changes and up charges on little things. read more

This place is absolutely horrendous. Not only did it take 20 minutes for them to take my order they then gave me tom pearls stinky scat for food. read more

The Superburger - Burgers Near Me - Paoli, Indiana

The service was awful didnt get my drinks for 20 mins and the food hasn't been here in 40 mins

My family was just passing through. We stopped here to grab some lunch. Amazing is all I can say. Huge portions, great taste, awesome and friendly service. Our waitress even took the time to have a conversation with my kids about the local safari we had just done. We live two hours away but we will for sure be back!!!!!!!! read more

Went to Wilstem Ranch for my birthday today and followed up at Superburger because of so many good reviews. Not impressed. They get a star for the nice staff working and a star for their great cottage cheese, but the burger was dry and the cheese was like an afterthought. I got the Jr. Cheeseburger with cottage cheese, husband got the double bacon burger and fried mushrooms. He said the mushrooms were good, but only ate about half the burger because it wasn't great. Maybe we came at a bad time (Tuesday at 5pm) I love supporting local places and I hope that others are able to enjoy their food in the future. read more

The Superburger - Jr. Superburger with cheese, mustard and pickles. And Some Amazing Cottage Cheese - Burgers Near Me - Paoli, Indiana

We visited Superburger as passing through town. The small restaurant is clean. We ordered at the counter. Our order consisted of the superburger, grilled chicken sandwich, sweet potato fries and coleslaw. We were the only customers in the restaurant and our food took well over 20 minutes for our order. The chicken sandwich was very thin and overcooked. The grilled portion was so tough I was unable to chew it. The burger is 1/4 lb. served on a huge bun and wasn't anything special. Both orders of our sweet potato fries were over cooked and not hot when we received them. The cole slaw was ok but the portion was very small for the price. We spent over $30 and left hungry. We will not be returning. read more

This is a great little place to stop during our road trip. They have a big menu aside from just burgers. I tried the tenderloin and it was huge. Definitely a proper Indiana tenderloin because the meat was twice the diameter of the bun. Very good. The boys had burgers and my wife had the patty melt. I have to say, the patty melt was my favorite. We were stuffed after leaving. I'll be back soon! read more

Amazing food and service! They also have great shakes. The portion sizes are also huge!

We were headed back to Louisville today after visiting Wilstem and we're looking for something different for lunch. Superburger seemed like a cool local place to check out and it did not disappoint! I had the double burger with cheese and a side of cheese fries, my mom had the bacon burger, and my kids had a grilled cheese and chicken nugget kids meal. Everything Came out quickly and was hot and fresh. The burgers were very tasty and my mom was very pleased that the bacon was nice and crispy! I enjoyed the coating on the fries and the cheese sauce on them was delicious as well. Both kids loved their meals also and have already asked to go back if we're in the area again! The kids also got to get ice cream after lunch and they were in heaven! I tasted my daughter's Mint Chocolate Chip and it was excellent! Everything was also very affordable. It was only about $30 for the 4 of us to eat lunch including the ice cream for dessert! The service was wonderful as well. Very friendly and very attentive with refills. We will definitely stop again next time we are in the area! read more

See all

Yes, the burgers were pretty super! Thumbs up from everyone in my family. We stopped here after a recent trip to nearby Paoli Peaks for some skiing. Superburger was a great choice for dinner. Everyone did love the burger and my wife really enjoyed the cheesy potato soup. And even better was the fried bologna sandwich. Always order the fried bologna! read more

Really great place to eat! Food is great and it is near the school so perfect to eat at in between games if playing there on the weekend.

Every time I stay in a new area I seek out local places. This one did not disappoint! Kind and courteous staff! Amazing funnel cake fries! I only say that because we ended up ordering them 3 times because they were such a hit! Great burgers and fries! Highly recommend this joint, great people and prices! Will be back if I am ever this way again! read more

It's hit or miss typically a miss. Their food has something left to be desired. I eat here just to support the local style restaurant.

My family ate here on a Saturday evening in the freezing weather. The food was very good. Service was quick and the meals were all completed as ordered. We were the only ones in the restaurant, but we were treated well and it was a really good value for the money. read more

Amazing! We stopped here after being at Wilstem doing the spa experience. Such a great burger & very divey vibes. Highly recommend the bacon cheese burger, hand breaded pork tenderloin, pepper jack balls, & the Oreo milkshake. The fries weren't the best ones I've ever had, get a more unique side :) read more

Excellent post-Covid prices! Everyone ordered different items from salad to burgers and sides. Ordered at the counter and food delivered to the table. Very nice staff and ample off street parking. Will go there again next time we are in town. read more

Great burgers and fries. The online photos are misleading. Portions are larger than the photos.

Delicious. Great food. Try the jalapeno cheese bites. A must try! Fantastic onion rings.

When you visit Paoli, don't expect much. It's a small little town about 2 hours south of Indy. There's slim pickings for places to eat, and everywhere is full of locals. I went to Paoli to visit a friend who recommended we eat at Superburger which was her families favorite place. I arrived before her and of course received looks from the locals, but the staff was friendly. They asked if I'd been there before and proceeded to explain how the place was run. You order and pay at the counter with everything ale carte and then they bring it to your table. I ordered the cheeseburger and fries with a drink, which came to about $8-9. All of thier meat is locally sourced, but as far as the flavor I didn't notice any difference. It wasn't anything spectacular to me. It just tasted like a cheeseburger and fries. They have plenty of parking and a larger room in the back to accomodate parties. There are a couple TVs mounted on the walls and a variety of options from the menu. It's a great place to dine if you have kids. read more

Waited an hour for cold soggy fries. Tables left uncleared and dirty whole time we waited. 5 employees standing around doing nothing while people waited.... read more

The Superburger - Burgers Near Me - Paoli, Indiana

See all

On our way to French Lick we stopped in Paoli and decided to try Superburger. When you walk in you'll see a counter with a sign, and you order there. I ordered The Superburger and cheese fries. The burger was good, however I thought the fries were a little underdone and not very crispy. As far as value, it was very reasonable. Staff was very friendly. Definitely a quick and inexpensive option going into French Lick. read more

Dining options in Paoli are limited, but the Superburger is a star. They raise their own beef locally which is unusual anywhere you go. To find it in Paoli is a huge plus. The burgers are great (local beef is not just hype) and they also make amazing milkshakes here. You order aThe decor is not much to look at, bu read more

I love a good burger & this place serves a GREAT BURGER!! More bacon on it than most places put on a BLT too! Fixed just how it's asked for. PepperJack balls are the bomb too! Wife had fried mushrooms & they aim to please your palate as well. Will definitely be back each & every time we're headed through Paoli!! read more

See all

Wow...just WOW!! We traveled to Paoli for a basketball game and had a friend who grew up recommend Superburger and so glad he did. Everyone had something different and there were no complaints because they kept their mouths full of this delicious food! We live a good driving distance from this place, but are already making plans to drive the hour+ just to eat there again! read more

The Superburger - Always awesome when businesses support High School Athletics! - Burgers Near Me - Paoli, Indiana

Darn, I wish that I had discovered this place years ago. I stopped here now become someone told me that it had a good reputation for good burgers, so I gave it a chance. Glad I did!! This place serves a fantastic burger! I am a basic burger person...I don't want weird sauces or goat cheese or strange culinary creations on my burger. I want a good hot traditional American hamburger (like they used to be in the pre-McDonald's days. And this place delivers to the max. SuperBurger is most definitely on the keepers list. read more

I'm in town for training today February 5, 2019. I found this place online and read the reviews. I ordered the double cheeseburger with bacon and a side of mushrooms. Both the sandwich and the side was very tasty. The hamburger was busting with flavor. read more

The Superburger - Inside Superburger - Burgers Near Me - Paoli, Indiana

Best burger for miles! Great food selection. Large portions. If you like fries they are tasty and give you lots! Bet you can't eat them all!

I had soup in a bread bowl, delish. Hubs had the burger and onion rings. Food and service GREAT. value. Top notch.

Excellent stop on the way back from French Lick! The burgers were top notch! Staff was VERY welcoming & the price was right, too.

Great food very cheap prices I literally plan on taking the long drive to go back. I fed three teenagers and myself there full meals everyone got full and had leftovers for less than $20 read more

Stopped by here on the way home from French Lick for lunch and the food was really great! I ordered the Super Double cheeseburger and cheddar balls! The burger was not your typical hamburger, it was Big and Juicy!!!! The cheese balls were a little dry but still great along with the cola! Super burger is my kinda of place! read more

I do not often give 5 stars but this place! A hidden gem. I discovered it by doing a internet search for "best burger in Indiana" The Superburger was listed as one or two on three of those lists and God bless, less than 15 miles from me. Their burgers are 100% top notch and not expensive. These are basically smash burgers. You can taste the high quality of meat they use. I am going through their menu. Everything so far is excellent. Their onion rings are about the best I have ever eaten and I'm a old dude. Tonight I got a double cheese burger and a sloppy joe (just to try out) OUTSTANDING! these guys do a hell of a job. Next trip I am, gonna get their RibEye sandwich. I will keep you posted. But all that aside if you live or are traveling through, you are doing yourself a disservice by not trying this place. If you have kiddies they have a huge ice cream and milk shake menu. Try them out, you will thank me. read more

Great place to eat. Love the atmosphere, local high school sports teams hanging on the walls from throughout the years was cool to see while eating. Small place but surprisingly large selection of food to choose from. Any sandwich you can think of along with shakes, salads, and soups. Everything my family had was great. Grilled chicken, ribeye sandwich, and cheeseburger. read more

This is my favorite place to eat. They have the best staff and always make sure we are satisfied.

They charge $ .50 for water . They don't post the charge on their menu and when they ask you what you want to drink , if you say water they sneak a $ .50 charge on your bill . They don't tell you they are charging you for water and I bet most people never notice the charge . After all who charges for water !! $ .50 today and before long $2.. . they will do with water what they have done with soda , give you $ .30 worth and charge 5 to 10 times profit .I just happen to ask if their was a water charge and when they said $ .50 i cancelled my order and left . No one should do business with restaurants that charge for water . read more

As advertised. SUPER BURGER!!!!! Great grilled hamburger on ur way to the resort. And when u leave. Yum yum.

My wife and I done a pick-up order on our way to patoka lake. We used to eat here often but not after this Order both of our tenderloins was over cooked and had a burnt taste to them. My side order of cheese balls had broccoli or something mixed in with it. I called and explained that our sandwiches was burnt and was told "well I'm the one that cooked them and that's just how the breading is because theyre raw meat we have to cook them that way" I have honestly have had better from from gas stations. Wasn't trying to get a refund or anything was just wanting to let them know it was burnt. I've been going there since it was bob's Super burger. But after that phone call I'll never spend another dime there again. read more

We stopped in for lunch after being at French Lick, and was so glad we did. Superb burgers, the fried cauliflower was amazing and the broccoli cheese bites were delicious. Service was great, our waitress was on it! We will definitely be back! read more

Foods was spectacular. Fair prices and great Ribeye sandwich. I would definitely recommend stopping by Paolis best greasy spoon