Pretty good ice cream - my daughter got the strawberry cheesecake and I liked that more than my…read morewhite chocolate raspberry - I didn't know it had dark chocolate pieces inside and it was a bit too chocolatey for my liking. The waffle cones taste delicious highly recommend you get one. No complaints on the chocolate ice cream my hubby got. The prices are insane $9 and change for one scoop of ice cream in a cone or a medium in a cup.

There was wide selection, although I wish that there was some soft serve ice cream. The kids had a…read moregreat time sampling and trying the different flavors of ice cream and gelato.

The ice cream here was decent. Flavors a bit limited and prices kinda high for a small scoop of…read moreice cream. I suppose you can do that when you are on an Island and one of the only ice cream places around. The show itself is small, but cute.

The owner of this place, her name is Linda, Is a miserable person. I am not sure why she owns an…read moreice cream store, because she's not interested in serving ice cream to anyone, she will let you stand there waiting, and waiting without ever acknowledging you while she chats to some dude who isn't buying anything. If you do manage to actually get her to acknowledge you, she will more than likely be gruff and act like she is doing you a huge favor by scooping ice cream. Once the small sized portions have been scooped, she will tell you how much you owe her.... More than likely you're going to be over charged (aka ripped off). Good luck to you. UPDATE: After eating the ice cream from this place, I got sick for several days. Disgusting. Figures.

This is a nice little shop with fudge, candy, and ice cream. The latter is what brought us in (it's…read moresummertime), and they've got some slightly surly teens that are not excited at all to give you surprisingly large tastes their selection. You'll find your standard favorites, and a couple I've never heard of as well. I have to ask though...in what world is a "small" two scoops? This is the smallest size you have available? It's impossible to only scoop once in this shop? You're going to FORCE me to get both cookies and cream AND moose tracks? Obviously in a cone, because I'm not some sort of animal that eats ice cream with a spoon. Is this some sort of evil conspiracy to make me fat? Just so you know, if you did offer single scoops for slightly less money, then my wife and I would've gotten a cone each (more money for you) because I don't want to share anything with her ever. As it is, you probably ruined my marriage, Ice Castle.

The nicest place on the island! The girls working here are amazing, very friendly and helpful. I'm…read morenot a huge fan of ice cream so I was mostly focused on the fudge options. I tried a few options of the fudge and decided to go with the walnut fudge since it was the most delicious option. My friend got the birthday cake ice cream and said it was really good. They have a pretty big selection of ice cream flavors to choose from. Like many places on the island this place is cash only, the prices were pretty reasonable considering the quality. Overall this was a super cute spot with some amazing customer service, will definitely come back on my next visit!

My first time on Fire Island! Wife has been coming here since she was a kid, so we had to get…read more Superman Ice Cream was super good! Definitely recommend. Cute little shop. No complaints about service or anything. Will be back!

went in for a small soft serve ice cream. th cup wasn't even 1/2 full and there was virtually no…read morecaramel sa ce when I asked for extra. the group I went in with got 2 scoops each for there smalls. We spend the summer here and will not go back.

Finally got to stop by this local ice cream shop. It was nice not having to track down the truck…read morethis time. The store itself is simple, with no seating inside. There's a small merchandise area where they sell hoodies, T-shirts, and even a toy ice cream truck. I noticed they had a large selection of ice cream and really appreciated the assortment of cones available. The prices were a little higher than I expected, but the customer service was good. They also offer a BOGO sundae special on Tuesdays, which I definitely plan to take advantage of in the future. For such a nostalgic company, though, I do wish they had some seating so people could sit, talk, and enjoy their ice cream with family and friends. Overall, it's a fun stop for a sweet treat, but adding a small seating area would really make the experience feel more complete.

Came for a late night sweet treat to celebrate my moms birthday! I was surprised how small the…read moreselection of ice cream is considering this is an ice cream shop. I went with the ice cream burger which comes with 4 kinds of ice cream so I did Cookie Monster, biscoff cheesecake, chunky monkey and I forget the last flavor but it's sandwiched between two waffle cone 'pattys' dipped in chocolate with sprinkles-it was huge and very tasty! My mom went with the ice cream nachos which was waffle cone 'chips' ice cream and she chose peanut butter sauce. This was just ok-the pb sauce tasted like skippy pb-it does not compare to Ralph's peanut butter sauce at all. There's no seating so we took it to go but the prices seemed ok for what we got.

Great icecream. They take fire department discount. Super yummy. I got chocolate and Mary Jane.read more

loved the flavors... different and delicious. Great selection of candies in the back as well.read more

Cute little spot to grab ice cream! The kids enjoyed. They also have dairy free options, but not…read moremany. The 1 employee working was helpful. The price was a little high for the quality.

Stopped into Scoop & Cone in Farmingdale NY. Maria made it 5 stars with her complete service. She…read morehelped me pick what I wanted and how I wanted it. Donut alamode. They have been there for a few years. Thing is- they are a bit in the corner so not immediately visible. In an ajacient widow is a sign of info for rent of other available stores. The shopping center sign on the outside caught my eye and I entered to check them out. They have a few machines for toys and candies. (see pix) A cute little place with a variety of ice cream and toppings to stop in if in the area.

I always stop by this little ice cream window when I want a sweet treat in Port Jeff. They do an…read moreincredible vanilla peanut butter swirl that I just love. Their waffle cones are so good too, crisp, sweet, and noticeably fresh. I've had many stale cones in the past but not here. I'll still sample a new flavor every time I visit but it's going to be difficult for any flavor to knock my vanilla PB off the top.

If you're looking for a spot to grab ice cream in Port Jeff, this is it. I grew up coming here on…read moresummer nights, followed by walks down the boardwalk and that is still one of my favorite things to do when visiting NY. Locations in Chandlers Square, this ice cream shop is a walk up window and the line is always worth the wait. The service is great. It's usually college kids working here and they definitely work hard! They have every flavor you could think of, and they offer Only 8, which is the non fat frozen yogurt (low cal, too!) I got the chocolate chip cookie dough in a waffle cone with chocolate sprinkles. There was cookie dough in every bite, YUM! We sat on one of the benches and enjoyed our ice cream, while watching the live music outside of Castaways. This spot is a true 10/10. Expect to was for a few minutes if you're visiting on a warm summer night, but I promise it's worth it!

Very disappointed! I ordered a bonico and the girl who made it had no idea what I was talking about…read moreand had to call her boss to find out how to make it. I took it to go and she did a terrible job packing it because it got all over the bag and all over the paletas I got from there too. The bonico wasn't even good.

We were anticipating this ice cream place in Elmsford for a while now. What a delite to see the…read moremultiple ice cream choices, to paletas (frozen pops), and many different type of Mexican and South American treats. El Chavo decorations on the window took me back to my childhood. They also make smoothies and coffee if you rather go in that direction. Un poco para todos! Recommend the Mangonada and Salchipapas enjoy our favorite new spot in Elmsford!

Love this place and their ice cream! A go to whenever we are in Greenport. They have a ton of…read moreflavors and a few tables both inside or outside so you can eat with the family. There can be a line but it always moves quick!

Cute shop with arcade games and a carousel in the back (parents beware!!!) they serve Hershey ice…read morecream as well as soft serve and lemon ice. A good option for a sweet treat but def disappointing that their stuff isn't homemade!