Swung by after a quick golf session at spring valley. Pleasantly surprised that this place still exists and under new ownership. The people running this place now seems really chill compared to the angry Asian lady that I remember 15 years ago. They have $7 jumbo slices and they're humongous! Enough to split with my girlfriend. We got the almighty slice that is essentially their combo. Super tasty, good crust, and a ton of toppings. Definitely a competition to a New York slice. Overall, a true staple to Milpitas when it comes to Milpitas. Definitely worth a stop if you're looking for pizza! read more

The Pizza Box - Almighty slice of pizzza - Pizza Near Me - Milpitas, California

Pizza box sucks ass. I just left there the pizza box in Milpitas and got two slices of combination. The fucking dough wasn't even cooked. The toppings weren't even cooked and the sausage taste like regular fucking potted meat fucking garbage. I paid over $20 for two slices of pizza and a can of Coke I will never go there again and I will not go to the one in San Jose. I felt like I got ripped off. I didn't even call them to complain because the guy looks like he's fucking half stone the guy that makes the pizza there he doesn't give a shit so if he doesn't give a shit, I don't give a shit and I'm telling people not to ever go here I could've went to Little Caesars and had better pizza. That's where I'm on my way now to buy a medium pizza because I was having craving for pizza pizza box is pizza shit thank you read more

Used to go here as a kid. Went back recently and got a pepperoni and cheese slice. Unfortunately this is not it. read more

The Pizza Box - Pizza Near Me - Milpitas, California

See all

We ordered the Almighty minus the olives, medium size (14 inches diameter) on a Thursday evening. I was surprised to find that they close at 7pm, as it seems super early for a pizza spot, and slightly inconvenient for our dinner plans. But I asked to pick it up at closing time, the latest time possible, and the worker who helped me was super friendly and accommodating and didn't make me feel rushed. That same courtesy was demonstrated when I arrived. The pizza was coming out of the oven, hot and freshly baked. She offered, cheese, peppers, and sides of ranch at no extra cost. She even gave me a loyalty card, for a free slice after 10 visits/transactions. The restaurant was a tiny space, I didn't see any seating, so it looks like they only do to-go orders. It actually looked like the restaurant dining/waiting area is just being used for storage. The place looks like it hasn't been updated in the last 2-3 decades... I mean, it IS the original location, maybe they wanna preserve the look of the place!?! The pizza was amazing, a nice balance of cheese and toppings, a perfect savory combination of flavors from the salami, sausage, mushrooms, and plenty of other meats and veggies that made up this delectable pie. Everything tasted of quality and the thin crust had a light crunch to it at the ends. Great spot for New York style pizza! read more

See all

I visited this place years ago and the pizza was amazing. There was a lady that owned it then. She could be mean but her pizza was amazing! I'm from out of state and I happened to be in town and ordered with intentions on getting the same great pizza. When I got to my destination and opened it, IT WAS AWFUL! The pizza was burnt to the point that I didn't wven know what was on it. It looked like bugs were cooked on it. The wings had a good flavor but they were burnt as well! I took a pic and sent it to my sister who was grossed out as well. She turned me on to this place when she lived in the San Jose area. Needless to say, I threw the whole pizza away and went to Pizz'a Chicago which I should've gone to in the first place. I will be writing a yelp and google review. read more

The Pizza Box - Only the worst pizza EVER! - Pizza Near Me - Milpitas, California

I've liked this pizza place since the old lady ran it. After years, this time I ordered the Almighty and the Chicken Dinner. Wow, they were horrific. TOO SALTY. Ownership should taste their own pizza and adjust. Don't think I'll be back. read more

Customer service is cute. Food is terrible. Burnt af, new ownership needs to tale dome pointers from the former. I called about the pizza being burnt, they offered a new pizza -one size up, geat! Thank you. But it's still burnt and missing toppings. I'm calling the Po-lease read more

See all

What more could you want out of a mom+pop shop pizza place that has the freshest pizza dough around? You don't come here for the looks/ambiance/service, it's a grab-and-go situation and the pizza is well worth it! It's like a NY-style pizza and there aren't a lot of combo options but my favorite is the cheese pizza & garlic knots! If you're looking for ambiance & grabbing beers with friends, I'd recommend Stuft Pizza instead but if you're happy to eat at home with friends, then Pizza Box is the place! Don't forget the garlic knots. You won't regret it! Milpitas honestly has some of the best local food spots around and this is one of them. read more

I ordered a personal pizza & seems like it's a new owner & the pizza didn't taste the same like it was before & pizza was kinda burnt & I wouldn't go back anymore I'm good I'm disappointed.. been going there for years . Smh read more

This is one of the best pizzas I've had in a while. Wasn't too oily and the crust (which is usually my least favorite part) was soooo good. Wasn't too chewy, wasn't too crispy. It was like a good breadstick but on the pizza. It was nice and fluffy and really complimented the pizza well. We got a Large (14 inch) Almighty for 3 of us. We also got a personal order of garlic knots (5 knots, meant for 1 person) and that was really really good too. No unappetizing chunks of garlic or overwhelmingly buttery, just nice and soft. It came out very hot. We called in our order and they told us a wait time of 20min, but they'd call when it was ready. The lady was very nice and service was great. Parking in that plaza is pretty easy, doesn't seem like it'd fill up. Definitely will come back here! IMO, the best pizza's I've had in the Bay are Curry Pizza House (only their Indian flavors), Cheeseboard in Berkeley, and Pizza Box. read more

The Pizza Box - A Large Almighty, personal garlic knots, and free cake pops! - Pizza Near Me - Milpitas, California

The food is really tasty! The only problem is the phone number doesnt work so it causes some inconvenience so i hope this gets fixed! It is only a few mins drive but caling is faster especially since we need to wait for the pizza to be made. If the phone number works then i will give you guys a 5 stars! Also, just drived here and they are planning to be open tmrw so hopefully next time we can order here! read more

The phone number doesn't work so I ordered somewhere else. Their food is good but ordering to go on the phone doesn't work.

Our cousins brought over some pizza and bread sticks shaped like wontons for dinner and this was the first time we had it. The slices of pizzas are huge. We got 4 slices and there was 2 slices equivalent leftover. Bread Shaped Wontons: These are only good if you heat them up and eat them warm. They have the cheesy garlic bread taste that is nastolgic of Litter Caesar's. East Meets West: This was my favorite as it's very umami and unique. Papa Juan: This is my second favorite but I was surprised that the chorizo didn't give the pizza more flavor. The Almighty: Reminds me of the Costco combo pizza. The Margherita: My least favorite as it was pretty tasteless. read more

This is probably the worst pizza ever had. I honestly think it cannot get any worse. I was on my way from work, a bit hungry, the found the pizza box place, I order a slice for 7.50 to go, as I was eating I realized it's literally garbage, burnt at the bottom and the crust was uncooked, you cannot screw up a pizza like this read more

The Pizza Box - It's garbage - Pizza Near Me - Milpitas, California

See all

0/10 Pizza was terrible. Got a Regular Pepperoni slice was burnt to a crisp. I Was recommend this place a while back and finally came to try it, was no where near what it was hyped up to be. The pizza box located on the Eastside San Jose has stepped up their game! & is 10x Better then this place. read more

I won't be able to finish these in one sitting garlic knots are decent as well. Once slice is all you need to be honest if a slice is all you are going for. read more

The Pizza Box - Slice of cheese and slice of mushrooms and onions - Pizza Near Me - Milpitas, California

See all

This SLICE moved me. The picture does NOT do this place Justice. firstly, I chose cheese only bc I didn't understand the true potential of ANY slice for 5.50. low expectations going in but was delighted to see the absolutely massive piece of pizza I'd just been handed. Ill admit it was hard to manage. It was in a brown bag that bled thru w grease and I couldn't set it down anywhere in my car. And it was so fresh that I couldn't hold it without burns. But the good outweighs the struggle. And I DIDNT SEE UNTIL AFTER. their $8 meal is an incredible deal. Full slice, drink, dessert, and garlic knots. I'll be really sad if they increase price but until then I'mma be back every week!! Too good read more

The Pizza Box - Cheese Slice Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milpitas, California

Best pizza in town Huge slices for a good price and great customer service. Stop by and try the Papa Juan read more

The Pizza Box - Papa Juan - Pizza Near Me - Milpitas, California

It was amazing but now it's pretty mid. It's sad when a great place becomes that way. Do better, be better!

In my entire 35 year existence, there's not a small business on this planet that means more to me than The Pizza Box in Milpitas CA. Growing up less than one mile away from this fine establishment, my family's 1990s "TGIF" dinners were afforded by none other than this one-and-only maker of the UNCLE SAM and KING KONG. Former Pizza Box proprietor Emily, whose icy demeanor was legend in our neighborhood, was a person so dedicated to her pizza-making craft that she would sacrifice all superficial notions of decency in order to focus her entire being on producing the best pies ever known to mankind. Veggie slice for $3.95 at 7PM in the evening? Here you go-- piping hot out of the oven. Crispy at the tip, yet doughy and crunchy towards the crust. Generous mozzarella to give you the string cheese effect upon the first bite and just enough marinara-basil sauce to fire up your olfactory engines, but not too much to overwhelm the palette. A mountain of fresh mushrooms, peppers, olives, and whatever other fixin's your heart desires, if you so wish. In adulthood, sitting 3,000 miles across the country in Cambridge, Massachusetts, I long for a bite of a slice from the Pizza Box. While I love my family (who remain in the same childhood house in which I was raised), a slice from the Box sits in equal weight to my cherished ones as reason for making the trans-continental trek. I am pleased to inform you all that new ownership appears to faithfully carry on Emily's masterful work AND the existing supply chain of fresh ingredients for the benefit of the public. I feel deeply indebted to these people for this, as I continue to enjoy every delectable bite when I place my order at the Pizza Box. Thank you so very much for your hard work, and I look forward to many more of these bites to come. With much love, respect, and appreciation......your loyal customer. read more

The Pizza Box - I heart Pizza Box, now and forevermore. - Pizza Near Me - Milpitas, California

This place sucks go to Costco 100 times better The bottom of the pizza was burned to a crisp pepperoni sucked. I should've turned around when I saw there was no one in there. read more

I used to go here as a teen and young adult. I haven't been back since the new ownership but today was a really nice experience. I ordered via telephone and my two large pizzas were ready in about 20 minutes or so. I ordered around 2:25pm on a Saturday afternoon. I ordered: 1 Large "All Veggied Out" & 1 Large " Big Kahuna" It was worth it :) The dough, sauce and toppings are at the right ratio that creates balance of taste. Not overpowering each other but blending and teaming up to satisfy my taste buds. My stomach is happy. I normally don't go for pineapple pizza but the Big Kahuna was awesome. I would go back. If I could, I would eat pizza daily. Haha. read more

See all

To my opinion, since the new ownership it's not the same. I grew up in Milpitas hanging out at Golfland playing Street Fighter back in the days. read more

Well, I try to give this place a shot... I look at the new menu and decided to try the $12 deal which was advertised one for u and one for another... At the end of the day, it was for a personal pizza with a can soda... Why not just be clear about it I thought u can get any drink so i got Snapple. Then I saw a $3 charge... And question it. The girl said that is not part of the deal. So I said cancel it. Then I didn't know what was going on... So, I just got pissed and cancelled the entire order and forget about it.... The dude was like I think u just confuse yourself. And I was like yeah I'm just stupid thats all... So stupid to have come here to give this place a shot after new ownership. Just stupid I even stop by after I've read all the negative reviews... I really like the old mean lady way better when this place was a hidden gem. Straight forward honest is way better than tricky upsell bs... Now, forget this place. So many pizza places in Milpitas. There is no freaking reason to even come here ever again... read more

Pizza Box is great! If you need pizza for a party or event, this is definitely the place to come to. You can get a very big pizza for a very reasonable price. Plus? The pizza is delicious, too, so it's a win all around! I really liked the crust especially. On top of your regular pizza sizes (Small-Extra Large), there's the King Kong (24 inches) and the Uncle Sam (26 inches). If you get either of those, be prepared to put that baby in your truck because it's not going to fit in your car, haha! I'm a fan of this place and will definitely order again for a crowd! read more

I ordered a pepperoni pizza. A basic, simple pizza. It was delicious. I love the crust. Nice and chewy. Prefect amount of cheese and a perfect amount of pepperoni. It's your classic thin crust New York pizza. I'm coming back. read more

Their website hours don't match their operating hours. Under the new management, they're never open. I miss the arguing with the old lady, at least they were open when they were suppose to be. read more

3 Star Review (New Pizza Box) When Pizza Box closed I was a little sad inside because the best pizza joint in Milpitas was gone. News started to spread that the place was under new ownership so we were rejoiced to hear the news. I had visited earlier during the social media sneak peak free pizza giveaways and to tell you guys the truth I came across truly disappointed. The free slices were thin, very salty, a little well done. Nothing representing what the "Pizza Box" used to be but free pizza is free pizza so nothing here worth complaining about. We weren't sure what the pizza was going to be like when they actually opened. Now for the actual pizza review (compared to old Pizza Box) A day after the grand opening we ordered a 2 topping Mushroom and Sausage Uncle Sam for $65 dollars. - Pickup time was reasonable (45 minutes) for the size of the pizza - Crust was spot on, thick but soft crust on the outside almost like a freshly baked baguette and thinner towards the middle but enough to support itself - Sauce a little more robust/thicker than before so an improvement here - Cheese: Good, what we expected. Just the right amount. - Toppings: SAD, THIS WAS A BIG MISS. We didn't get the amount of toppings we were expecting to see it was a very underwhelming amount. We were expecting 2 to 3 times the amount of toppings we received. Granted some of the toppings are more "imbued" into the cheese it was still far less than what we were hoping. We expected to see at least double the amount of toppings than what we had received. Comments included, "We ordered Uncle Sam breadsticks" , "I didn't have sausage in the slices I ate" and "cheese pizza" (See posted pictures) Overall: The recipe is a faithful re-creational of the original Pizza Box recipe but the sparse amount of toppings was a HUGE miss. Toppings and value was the reason why we kept coming back unfortunately the value isn't here. read more

See all

I'm still mourning the loss of OG Pizza Box. So much so that I had to get a slice and see if I could drum up some nostalgia. This place ain't it. It's not that bad, but it definitely ain't the Pizza Box we knew and loved. Despite what other reviews have said about them using the same recipe, the dough is different and there is no end crust. You know how there used to be a big bubble at the end and when you bite in to it, it's like almost like a French baguette? Soft and chewy, yet crunchy? Ain't like that. Half the size, but (almost) double the price. read more

The Pizza Box - $8.72 Alice's price: under $6 - Pizza Near Me - Milpitas, California

Mtown classic. Delish crispy thin crust, reasonable prices and good customer service;) what more can you ask for!

pizza box Milpitas is the best Slice of Linguica and Shroom. Extra crispy. Thank me later . read more

The Pizza Box - Linguica and mushroom slice extra crispy - Pizza Near Me - Milpitas, California

See all

I think it's awesome that they were giving away free slices! I wasn't living in the area when the old mean owner was here apparently, but the new lady who was giving away slices was really sweet and friendly. I got a free slice of pepperoni/olive/mushroom. Not sure if it's just cause it was free but the slice was pretty small and thin crust without an actual end crust bit if that makes sense. Cheese was generous but just tasted okay and toppings seemed hearty and fresh. For a cheaper pizza joint it's pretty satisfying and filling. Also I really weirdly like the texture of the bottom of the dough -- it has hole/bumps like bubble wrap and the contrast of its drier texture and the greasy cheese is really satisfying lol read more

Stopped in and got a slice. Crust was a good mix of crispy and soft. Sauce is GREAT - good tomato flavor but not enough to override the rest of the pizza. Cheese was good consistency and amount, they use locally sourced cheese blend so taste could change depending on the cows I guess. Lots of toppings. Staff greeted me as soon as I walked in and my order was custom, so I waited about ten minutes before I got my order. Tasty - I'll be back! read more

The Pizza Box - Pizza Near Me - Milpitas, California

The Pizza Box is the perfect way to feed a lot of people without breaking the bank! The staff is friendly and extremely accommodating (although some reviews express some frustration with language barriers or rudeness, remember that these workers are human and have off days!). I never leave The Pizza Box unsatisfied because they make sure that I get what I want or the next best thing! The only reason my rating is 4 and not 5 stars is because the don't have bread sticks. Which is understandable because their pizza is sooo good! But bread sticks are a must for me. Also, checkout the pizza they made for my daughter's 6th birthday! I love these guys! read more

The Pizza Box - Pizza Near Me - Milpitas, California

Ever since the management changed, the pizza no longer tastes the same as before. I've been eating here 30+ years, you can't tell me it's the same. read more

Tonight I called and ordered the largest pizza they had for pick up. They told me that I needed to pay for it over the phone which was completely fine so I did and had a co worker go and pick it up. After he went to pick it up he called and said "thanks bro you could have gave me a heads up that I needed to pay for it" I immediately checked my bank statements to confirm if I was charged the $45.50 they told me they were going to. Sure enough my bank account was charged while they also charged a colleague in store. After THE CUSTOMER noticed the mistake and addressed it, the manager (I don't remember her name) confirmed this was a mistake on their end due to a new employee with inadequate training. To compensate the customers findings of a costly double charge, she offered a "free slice" next time I come in. I work nearby and at least twice a month order from them to provide lunch for my team. The unfortunate manager service experience did not meet the minimum expectations of a manager who treats customers right. Moving forward I will take my business somewhere else. read more

The pizza is really good here, I was hesitant at first because of some of the reviews but we were happy with just a small cheese. This one of those hole in the places you don't see unless you actually look for it must try! read more

I like the soft dough, texture and flavor. The pepperoni is good but just about every other pizza is suspect. Staff has always been super friendly. read more

Another hidden gem in a strip mall setting. The proprietors have been here for over 20+ years. ...this is family owned and patrons come from the neighborhood and by word of mouth, everywhere else. There are a few tables for a no frills dining experience. Otherwise, to go seems to be the main choice. The pizza here is out of this world tasty. read more

The Pizza Box - Pizza Near Me - Milpitas, California

See all

I am giving 2 stars just because I love pizza. However, the pizza was 1 - sorry to say :( The last time I tried Pizza Box was about 4-6mo before they sold. It was really heartbreaking to here the news. But I guess all good things must come to an end. I still regret not stopping by and ordering an Uncle Sam as a final send off. But, after trying it today, I am regretting it even more so. The pizza today is extremely different. The flavor of the ingredients seemed lackluster to me and to my fellow homies. We found ourselves staring at each other with the classic "WTF" look. The pizza was more dough than pizza - if that makes any sense. I understand we could have ordered "thin-cust", but with the OG Pizza Box, that was not necessary. The old Pizza Box knew exactly how my friends and I wanted it. And that mean old lady delivered something fierce - a deliciously amazing pizza! The cheese was meh, the sauce was meh, and the pepperonis seemed to have lost their "pep" so to speak. There were other ingredients but without much taste, so yeah.... Its a shame I will never be able to experience the mean old lady serving me up some of the best damn pizza I have ever had in my life as a native Milpician again. But like I said, all good things must come to an end :( read more