Great looking corner bar on the East end of Main St. I didn't think it was looking like a kid…read morefriendly place for lunch, but the bartender Kyle was extremely friendly and insisted we were good to go. The inside has dark colors, but brightened a bit by the sunlight coming through the outer wall windows. I liked the wooden barrel lights over the bar, barrel wall sconces by the booths and the small bikes made out of pipes with Edison bulbs in them that hang over the front tables. The interior had exposed brick on the outer wall, brown painted patterned ceiling tiles and a gorgeous long antique wooden bar. We sat in one of the cushioned booths in the back. Their menu is small and simple with about ten apps and six handhelds. They have some uncommon menu items that peaked our interest like Goat Birria Tacos, Sloppy Joe's and Mahi Sliders. My wife and son ordered the Sloppy Joe's at $8 that came with seasoned beef and their "House Sloppy Sauce". They both enjoyed them and said the seasoning was good and sauce had a bit of a sweetness. My youngest son had a plain chicken wrap $13 bacon, ranch, LT and Cheddar Jack. It was sizeable and fresh. We ended up splitting it up later for an app before dinner so its shareable if you have a smaller stomach. Kyle recommended their Smash Burger - Smashed Crispy Beef Patty, Cheese, LTO $13. It was average and there was nothing bad to say about it. I enjoyed a Mosier's Mosaic IPA by ShawneeCraft with it. They have a small house cocktail list and their tap list is small, but they do have some craft offerings and cans/bottles. The kids watched sports on a couple of the several TV's around the bar and we had a nice relaxing lunch. I'd stop in again if in the area. Thanks Kyle!

Loved the vibe in here. Thursday night i was in town for a show, my friend & I sat at the bar,…read morebartender really cool. Made me a nice vodka collins! We munched on wings & nachos. The nachos were such a hearty app, I'm not sure how anyone can eat anything after that, so that was also a bonus.

Cheesesteaks are the best! Never disappointed!! Always friendly. Comfortable local gathering place!read more

Love this dive bar good food and drinks. Dark hole in the walk bar but the wings will make you fly…read moreout soooooo good

Been coming here for years and have never had a bad meal. Definitely a good night life crowd for…read morethe pool tables and quiots...you can smoke inside this bar

Love it here! Bartenders are awesome! Food and drink prices are excellent!! Great food!!read more

Always. Made the 3 hour round trip just for a couple of beers, a good lunch and a nice weather…read moreFriday ride. Always.

Awesome great people great service great prices in this economy. Please don't come here and make…read moreit hard for locals lol

Great Bar and Staff. Always friendly and treat you like family. Highly recommend this placeread more

Cheap beers and I mean, you'll do a double take and ask the bartender like 3 times, how much??…read more Even the bar eats are prime cheap! Liverwurst sammie for $3.50?! Where am I fam?? The interior was bigger than I expected, def a local hangout and oh, they have a touchtunes machine so can totally put on Spice Girls "Holler" and no one needs to know it was you... 'oh who played this crap?!' (thanks joey i love this song!!!!) If i lived here I would def be chillin and drinking here on the often

Friendly bartenders and with fast service. Wings were good! Had the McHale's sauce which is a hot…read morebbq. It was more tangy than hot but delicious. Good prices. Very casual/divey pub which I enjoy.

I've been coming to this place for quite a few years!! Everyone always makes you feel at home…read more Bryan and Cari have done an excellent job of creating a warm and fun/friendly environment. You can't ever go wrong with the "Best" wings in the Poconos, the MOST friendly staff, and a great outdoor deck to boot!! In a year of crazy rules and unpredictability, the Old Mill Pub has maintained the fun laid back atmosphere it always had. Definitely a must when in Sciota or even if you're just passing through.

Our merry little group was visiting the Pennsylvania area and stopped in for a quick bite. We had…read morethe best time! We ordered the drink specials and a bunch of different wings and food to share. Everything was delicious, the jukebox was fun and the drinks great. Our waitress was the best ever! We had the best time. I definitely recommend.

Happy hour wings were delicious and at a great price! Cheyenne services were also phenomenal making…read moreus out of towners feel very welcomed!

Everything is Great except for the fries, they are the worst. Drinks are nade well and service is…read moreusually attentive and properly staffed.

Food was ok nothing special and the service was good. Food prices were on the high side. They add a…read moresurcharge to the bill that's around 20% and expect a tip also. We will not be going back.

We expected "bar food" from this old-timey landmark but instead were blown away by a perfect NY…read morestrip salad and a massive Cuban sandwich. Lots of tempting options for lunch, full dinner, or just the munchies, all very reasonably priced. Clean and comfortable retro decor and atmosphere, full bar, and super-friendly, efficient service. We'll be back for special occasions and everything in between. Don't change a thing!

When the food is good it's very good, but on the off days it's not good. I like the old atmosphere…read moreso to those that say it needs an update, I disagree. Service is usually pretty good.

Wandered into this old school establishment for the first time ever on a dreary Saturday afternoon…read morein February. Didn't know what to expect but, was pleasantly surprised. A dynamite Roast Beef Sandwich piled high and served with homemade au jus - a great Cheese Steak sandwich - and wings served with really excellent homemade bleu cheese dressing. Plus the sandwiches are served with a bag of Martin's Potato Chips. Our waitress was also super nice.What's not to love, seriously? What Cliff's is to Ice Cream, this place is to sandwiches, and like Cliff's easy on & off from RT 80 if you're passing by. (It's the Columbia NJ exit, actually.) Totally worth the stop.

Went there with a group of 6 on Saturday night. All except one ordered sandwiches. Took over an…read morehour to get our food. The place was not crowded. Meanwhile the two owners were sitting at the bar socializing. If their kitchen was that backed up, management should have been in the kitchen pitching in. Also, one person at our table ordered one of their sandwich specials. Came out wrong; sent it back. Again, came back out wrong. The kitchen should know their menu and management should make sure they do. Probably won't go back.