I have been to this pub on a number of occassions for lunch or evening meal. It is outstanding in…read moreterms of the quality of the food on offer and the very competitive price charged. A two course lunch, main meal with either a starter or sweet course, costs only £5.25 a bargain! Food is well cooked and attractively presented. The waitress is friendly as is the landlord. There is a daily menu which, typically, has a choice of 2 starters, 8 mains and 4 sweets from which to select. Highly recommended as a place to eat and relax!

This is a lovely countryside bar/restaurant, literally in a stable, it's very warm and cosy, dog…read morefriendly and the food is good. However the seats were grubby, the service was slow and it was expensive but it's good if your in the area, even if you just want a pint and warm up by the fire but I wouldn't go out of my way to visit.

Back up again! The…read moreStable Bar has hit its stride. Good staff, a great rotation of beers (local and not) and food which I would be happy to receive in any bar in towo, let alone out in the sticks as we are! It's grapeat to have somewhere child friendly where we can get nibbles and refreshment. They have recently put in a TV, which is treated perfectly as it's only on for big events rather than showing rubbish all the time. Really pleased with the Stable Bar as it is now.

This was my first visit, It was quite honestly flawless. I…read morepopped in with my girlfriend after a walk in the Pentlands to get out of the cold. Grabbed a table right by the indoor log burner (Fantastic!) you can smell the wood fire and feel the heat, perfect for a cold day. I had one of my favourite beers (Edinburgh Gold) and we both ordered the Steak pie. Portion size was good, The Meat was tender, could probably cut it with a spoon and the Gravy was spot on, full of flavour. I will definately be back!

Everything you could possibly want at the end of a Pentlands hike or bike ride. Delicious, great…read morequality food, friendly service and good beer. And a warm, cozy pub atmosphere. If you're up for something warmer than beer - their hot choc is amazing, and comes with giant marshmallows, and they have a selection of desserts to tempt you with too.

Hey, Yelpers, less of a review, more of a preview. However, I have eaten at The Melville Inn, so…read moreI've put my mouth where my money is. Yes, you'll find the landlord, or manager as they're called these days - Derek - out on the floor, serving customers, just like the rest of his staff. Don't take my word for it though, Carolyn, one of the top team, won the Scotland round of the in-house servers competition, and was silver medalist in the whole UK in 2012 - against 200 other Vintage Inn pubs. What's got me excited though is the October Tarot Evening. It's a first for the venue and, given the low-lighting, log-fire intimate surroundings, it should be a hoot. I'm minded to notch up five stars, because the Melville delivers what you expect, and delivers it well - good, family friendly food; plenty of atmosphere; and just the occasional surprise too. Rate me, rate my rating when you go.

This place is right next to the Butterfly Farm, and the massive garden centre which is worth a…read morevisit in itself. The beer garden looked inviting, although not today, it was raining. We walked in and once we finally got noticed it was sooo friendly. I picked the lamb koftas to start and the beef and merlot pie. Great service and fast, my koftas came and they were not bad, just a little more dense and just a little more spice for me though. My beef and merlot pie was the exact dish I'd had in the Balloch House a couple of weeks ago, but it seemed to me it was just slightly more lacking in meat, but still with the oversize bits of mushroom, still tasty though and certainly a nice Sunday lunch.

We went to the pub on a Thursday night for live music and open mic. This is a wonderful relaxing…read moreplace. All the people are friendly. Fun conversation. Since we are from California ee got special treatment in song. California Dreaming and one gentleman ad libbed a funny Trump song. Mostly the music was country and blues. Strange to go to Scotland to listen to that. :) The food was great also.

The Laird and Dog has been around forever, and for us a regular spot for a meal and a pint with…read morefriends from the sometime mining villages south of Edinburgh. For years, the meals were very ordinary, but the standard has been improving steadily and consistently over several years to the point where we now go there for the food as much as for the company. The menu is based around traditional Scottish ideas - steak and ale pie, haggis-neeps-and-tatties, and the like, but these dishes are well executed and nicely presented. Of late, menus have become a bit more adventurous, and the quality of materials and cooking continues to rise. Given that this pub is part of a chain, I can't see it ever aiming for a Michelin star or even "fine dining" status, but it is way above the typically dire standard of pub food in Scotland and on the very short list of places we are willing to go to for a meal out in south Edinburgh. Cheerful and friendly waiting staff only add to the positive experience. Recommended for a hearty meal.