If there's anything "lost" about The Lost Pizza Co. - Northport, I haven't found it yet. My wife and I make it a point to visit about once a quarter, and it never disappoints. Consistency matters, and this place delivers it every single time. Now, me being me, I don't branch out much. When I find something I like, I stick with it like duct tape on a screen door. Enter: the Happy Hippy with cauliflower crust. Now hold on -- before you start picturing edible cardboard, let me clarify. This cauliflower crust tastes nothing like cardboard. It's actually delicious. And yes, I'm aware that just about anything covered in cheese has a head start in life, but still -- credit where it's due. The crust holds up, the flavors balance well, and I can enjoy every bite without worrying about a late-night visit from our old acquaintances, Acid Reflux and his cousin Heartburn. My innards are at peace, and that's worth mentioning. The name Happy Hippy always makes me smile. I'm about as far from a hippy as you can get, but it's a fine conversation starter when ordering. And when the pizza arrives, I'm happy enough to live up to the name. The atmosphere is part of the charm. The walls are decorated with license plates from everywhere -- California to the Northeast -- mixed in with good old Alabama tags. One California plate in particular caught my eye: a personalized "90210." That zip code is permanently etched into my memory. Back in the day, every high school girl seemed to be glued to the television after an episode of Beverly Hills, 90210. I never watched a single episode myself, but somehow that number is burned into my skull for life. Funny how that works. Add in a few musical instruments hanging around and you've got yourself a laid-back, slightly nostalgic vibe. Then the speakers kick in with 80s and 90s classics, and you know you're in the right place. When "Down on the Corner" or "Old Time Rock & Roll" comes through loud and proud, it just feels right. Good pizza tastes better with good music -- that's just science. The staff is consistently friendly and helpful, and the restaurant is always clean -- which, let's be honest, should be standard everywhere but unfortunately isn't. If you've got small kiddos, there's a game room to keep them occupied while you sit back with a cold Coca-Cola and enjoy your pie in relative peace. All in all, it's good pizza, good music, and good people -- with just enough Southern charm to keep you coming back. We'll see them again next quarter. Some habits are worth keeping. read more

See all

Highly recommend!!! Amazing food, pizza is great, sandwiches are delicious! Every appetizer is great! (You can add any topping you want, to the Cheese Bread Sticks) and for a fantastic dessert, get a dessert pizza!!! Service is excellent.... The bar is small and quaint... $5 pitchers on specific days of the week!! Go see em! And thank me later read more

One of the best in Northport! Customize a delicious pizza or choose a fan favorite (The Otis, The Kujo, or The Lucille). The wings are out of this world every single visit! Crispy, packed with flavor, and sure to fill you up. Start with the tamales, grab a glass of Lost wine, and make your main choice from there! read more

The Lost Pizza - Pepperoni BYO Pizza (SMALL) - Pizza Near Me - Northport, Alabama

See all

I was in Nport getting my car serviced and saw this place across from planet fitness and me and the kids decided to check em Out ! It has similar vibe to MELLOW MUSHROOM AND HAD A NICE CROWD! The menu had ALOT of options from pizza to pasta but we played it safe and got 2 large thick crust pepperoni pizzas and it looked and smelled good BUT we didn't particularly like the pizza ! The cheese had distinct flavor that tasted sorta ricotta cheese maybe idk but my kids gave it 5/10 ! I hate doing reviews like these because maybe it just wasn't for us but the service was good and the girl behind was helpful so imma give extra points for that and then bringing the pizza out to my car ! Maybe I'll try the thin crust pizza or maybe the pasta! read more

See all

Very casual pizza spot. We enjoy a thicker crust and they deliver with that. When they first opened, the pizzas were cooked very well and the crust was salted nicely. This last time we went, the dough in the middle felt undercooked and soggy and the crust lacked flavor. read more

Great Greek salad and the pizza one of the best I have had! The service was excellent and very customer oriented.

Me and my son ordered the wings and they were lot of meat in the wings. The Jamaican jerk flavor did get old while eating 12 piece wings. My son got the mild they had a good taste as well. read more

Incredible service every time I come. Today one of the cooks messed one of my takeout pizzas up so the manager took over and made me a fresh one from scratch and gave me a gift card as an apology. No apology was necessary, I was totally fine. they're just that nice because they like to be. I have plenty of other great things to say about all my other experience including not just the impeccable service but also the cleanliness and atmosphere, BUT today's event made it necessary for me to put a review out. This location has things figured out. read more

You can't beat the pizza from here. There are so many options that there will be something for anyone to love. The wings are great too.

Warning: No pictures lol. I've ordered from The Lost Pizza several times. I have never taken a minute or two to snap a few pictures before eating ... I hope that statement points to just how good this food is. This will be a takeout review. I ordered the: - The Otis (pizza) - Chicken Alfredo (pasta) - Caesar Salad The Otis is my go-to order at Lost Pizza. As a meat lover, it covers all of the bases & then some. The grilled chicken is a nice addition and separates their version of a meat lover's pizza from the others served by other pizza places. I do wish they had an in between for the crust as the options are only "thick" or thin". 9/10. The Chicken Alfredo was surprisingly good. I didn't expect it to be average but I didn't expect the nice flavor. The Alfredo cream sauce was the perfect consistency to be paired with the angel hair noodles. The chicken was cooked perfectly. The only thing I would improve is the portion size. 8/10 The Caesar salad is also apart of my go-to order at Lost Pizza. Their Caesar dressing is one of my favorites! Simple & good. 10/10. read more

Food allergies can be deadly! Take that extra second to verify the customer's ticket correctly. ~It is literally a life/death situation~ read more

The Lost Pizza - It is my review. I have been unable to reach the restaurant since our delivery. The line has contuined to have a busy signal. - Pizza Near Me - Northport, Alabama

THE best pizza in Tuscaloosa county!! The cheese is sooo good. Great family and friends place to eat.

Worst pizza I've ever had. Greasy, no flavor, half of the toppings were missing. Tasted like a microwaved pizza. read more

The Lost Pizza - Happy Hippie (SMALL) - Pizza Near Me - Northport, Alabama

Excellent food and Hospitality! They were kind and remade a pizza that had originally been made with the wrong crust at no extra charge even after we had eaten the first pizza we are frequent customers and love it every time! Highly recommend this restaurant. read more

The food was delicious. The service was amazing!!! The ambiance was worth it. I give this restaurant a 5 star rating!!! I would recommend eating here, if you want great food and great service!!! read more

I am a happy hippy and they have a pizza named just for me. Loaded with vegetables, crispy crust and I even added pineapple ( push your glasses back up and don't judge me) which made it amazing. The place is very clean and organized even with lots of foot traffic. There is plenty of room to dine in and carry out is also on point. No pictures, sorry, just a stuffed happy hippy leaving a review. I will be going back every time I am craving pizza. read more

Cute place and good food. The place stays busy during peak hours. Quite a few dirty tables when I was there, but they were cleaned soon after we finally found a seat. read more

Nice new restaurant in Northport/Tuscaloosa. Have seen this restaurant in Columbus, MS, but never tried it. What a transformation of the space from the former Mr. Bill's. Large dining room decorated with old memorabilia that can accommodate a lot of people. A good place for larger groups. It looks new and clean. Even a game room for the kids. It's an order at the counter then be seated place. Large menu of pizza, sandwiches and the like. Service was polite and efficient. Ordered the thin crust Kujo pizza. It had lots of toppings and was tasty with just right amount of sauce. The crust was a little more chewy than expected. Also ordered a small side salad. Not sure it was worth the $4 as it was mostly just romaine lettuce and a couple of slices of tomato. It's a nice pizza option in the area. Worth another visit. Will try the thick crust on next visit. Not sure it will be our favorite go to pizza place in town though. read more

See all

I wanted to like this place. We got a thin crust pizza (over cooked and dried out), fried ravioli (over cooked and dried out), boneless chicken wings and bread sticks. The bread sticks were the only thing edible! We at least had a family laugh at how much of a thud there was when we tapped the hard pizza on our table. Seriously, it was like a brick. I'm so disappointed in this place. I type this as we are headed to Taco Casa for "second" dinner since none of us like this place. My husband did say service was fine but the food just isn't good. read more

Long lines, but they are quick . Seems like they treat their staff good so I hope that continues and people continue to work. The pizzas and service is amazing ! So far I can only speak to the pizza. read more

The Lost Pizza - Kujo. I may have spelled it wrong but my fav! - Pizza Near Me - Northport, Alabama

To start with I have heard people compare this place to Bama Bino... LOL. Not even close. Second, we both ordered our own pizza. Wife wanted green peppers taken off and wanted to add banana peppers. This is a $1 up charge. I however wanted banana peppers taken off and wanted green peppers added. Another $1 up charge. My question is why an extra charge just for changing one vegetable for another? It's not like we were adding premium items here. Maybe these pizza are premade and they have to physically take the ingredients off and add others ones...? Wasn't impressed. Third, wife and I walked in and wanted to sit at the bar. Unfortunately they allow children (3 kids) to sit at the bar. Not talking about the bar area but at the main bar. On top of that they spent most of their time in the gaming area and came back periodically for a drink of coke or whatever. We should have just gone to Chuck E Cheese. Come on Lost Pizza. You can and should do better. Service was good. This was our second trip after giving it another chance and will not be back. read more

The olive bread is to die for. This place is always super busy but the food is worth the wait!

Pizza was great! Plenty of staff and tables were bused promptly. Will return....love the atmosphere!

We have been here several times and the food is always top notch. The Greek salad is PHENOMENAL! However, the past 3 times we have visited during dinner, people have had to clean off the tables they wanted to sit at. Last night, along with the dirty tables, there was no ice in the machine, no lids and barely any straws.... As a former server, I absolutely understand a rush, but there seems to be no structure, no hustle from the servers/runners and I also noticed the bartender was waiting on someone to run drinks, but could've easily run those on their behalf. There were two tables close to us that ended up getting two pizzas due to a mix up in the kitchen. While there were a few who were hustling and trying to keep things running smooth, the rest of the staff could use a pep talk. We are going to give it a few weeks before we return. read more

I really wanted to like this place more. Atmosphere was good, line moved fast. It's counter service by the way. No where near enough parking for a Friday night but sufficient tables were available. My order was timely. Northport really needs some quality gourmet pizza. I had assumed it would be comparable to another gourmet type pizza place in town. Sadly, this isn't it. $70 for two large pizzas and cheesy bread. I can live with that if the quality is there. The thick crust tasted like typical delivery pizza. The thin crust so limp it couldn't hold the toppings. Yikes. The most important part of pizza making is the dough, y'all. I will go elsewhere for good pizza or settle for cheap delivery. It's unfortunate. read more

Best pizza ever, great service, nice location, clean organized. Worth every cent, Taco pizza is amazing.

I was reluctant to try this place because I ate at the one in Starkville a few years ago and it sucked. But this was a pleasant surprise. Some of my family ordered take out here and the pizza, as of now, beats all the chains in the Tuscaloosa area by a mile. The strawberry dessert pizza Is amazing. The tamales are also the best in the area. I hope they can maintain this standard. If they do, I will be getting my pizza here from now on. read more

The food was absolutely amazing and the service was incredible! We originally ordered the margarita pizza special, but they were unsure if they could still make it, as it was a limited time item, so we went with the pepperoni. The pizza was incredible and we were satisfied with the pepperoni, but then they came out with the margarita pizza free of charge! The prices were incredible for the portions and how great the food was!! Cannot recommend enough! read more

The food is so good! The place is decorated fun and they have a game room for the kids. The crust reminds me of the Pizza Hut crust from the 90s when they actually pan fried the dough. I had the Pit Boss and my daughter had the pineapple and ham. It's walk in and you order yourself which makes it so efficient! read more

The Lost Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Northport, Alabama

The service was good, they were super nice. However, the food took forever to come out when there was hardly anyone else in the restaurant. I'm not trying to be strict on them, I understand it's hard sometimes because I am a server, but it took a long time for them to make spaghetti, 2 pizzas, and a sandwich, then when we ordered dessert, it wasn't that good. I would go back for the pizza and pasta, but I'd definitely order food to go. read more

Food was good. This was our first time here. Everything was cooked correctly. Service was fast. There was a long line but it went pretty quick. Loved the ambiance as well. I do they they are a little to expensive, but other than that we had no complaints. read more

See all

It took 45 minutes to an hour to even place an order. I guess that is not too shocking when groups of 6 are jumping mid way in the line. When I pointed that out to the management they did not take any actions to resolve the situation. Letting that sort of stuff go in in an establishment that serves alcohol is a recipe for a disaster. Poorly trained staff and indifferent managers will be the downfall of this place. My experience is this poor and I have not even had the food served yet. read more

Good fresh ingredients, great customer service . The Tamales are a good appetizer. Games for the kids to play

I have had three different pizzas there and all of them were wonderful. I also love their delta tamales. I like to order a dozen and eat one or two for a snack for a few days until they are all gone. This is a great pizza place and we eat there once every week or so. The food is wonderful, the staff is friendly and the manager is super nice. It does take a while to get your food if you go during the busy times, so make sure you take someone you don't mind being with for a while. The food is totally worth the wait. read more

Trina was an amazing server! She always makes us feel right at home and goes out of her way to give us the best service ever! If she ever leaves, we will follow! She is great! read more

The inside seemed pretty cool. But i ordered a thin crust with sausage and onions and it was the worst pizza I've ever had. Extremely undercooked and had no sauce at all. read more

Very much enjoyed our recent visit to this establishment. The staff were very nice, the restaurant is family friendly and the food was delicious. read more

Great food, great atmosphere. It can get very crowded at normal lunch and dinner hours but the service is good.

First time we went it was wonderful , second time they lost my pizza , this last time it was just AWFULLLL!!!!! We brought our friends and spent 116.00 on pizza and it took 45 mins to get out our BURNED UP pizzas and the employees are down right rude and I'll never come back !!!!!!!! The reason they are called the lost pizza is because they absolutely loose your pizzas!!!!! read more

Great food for a great price, saved my life many of time. A large pie will feed you all the way through a weekend of football.