We typically like to try new restaurants from time to time and this one has been on our radar for months.
So for our 35th Anniversary we took the opportunity to go to the "Grille at One" for our dinner. We are so glad we did, the whole night was wonderful! Our reservations were for 6:45 on a Wednesday night. When we entered the restaurant we were presently surprised by the warm cozy feeling of the restaurant and bar. We arrived a bit early so decided to go the bar for a cocktail before being seated. They were in the middle of a wine tasting that they do on the third Wed of the month. The bartender and hostess explained the tasting process which includes small plates served with wine pairings. We will definitely be coming back to do that. They even offered us a slice of the deep dish pizza to go with our drinks that was being served to the wine tasting party at that time.
Once we were seated our waitress came by and introduced herself and acknowledged that we were celebrating a special night and really made us feel very special. It seemed like everyone that waited on us from Hostess, Bartender, to Waitress all treated us as special guests. By the end of the night it was evident that they treat everyone as special guests. Wow, what a change from many of the restaurants you attend, where you are treated like a number or an interruption to their evening.
We looked over the wine selection and was surprised by the affordable prices and good selection. We quickly found a good selection to go along with our meals. We had already taken the opportunity while at the bar to start looking over the menu. The menu is straight forward and not complicated by offering you too many selections. It is still diverse though and offers, appetizers (small plates ), salads, upscale burgers and entrees ( large plates ).
We ordered the Fried Calamari as an app while we decided on dinner. The calamari came out very lightly battered, almost tempura like. It was soo tender and light. I would have preferred a sauce with a bit more heat but the sauce that came with it had a light orange flavor and paired well with them. The best we both have had in years.
For dinner my wife ordered the salmon, which was served over a portion of crispy polenta. The fish was done perfectly and the polenta was a great pairing. I ordered the veal short ribs. They came with a side dish of Truffle mac and cheese and a red wine sauce over the ribs. I would have liked the ribs just a little rarer but that is just my liking, I am sure that they were cooked perfectly for most diners. The sauce was velvety and the mac and cheese, I want the recipe! Mac and Cheese will never be the same after eating theirs. I'm a very accomplished cook and can sometimes be very critical of dinners I get outside of my kitchen but that dish of mac and cheese was the most delicious I have ever eaten.
For me, the topping for the night was the Chef coming out to our table and inquiring about the meal and thanking us for giving him the opportunity to cook for us. What a treat! I will say my wife's special moment was the complimentary Chocolate & Cherry Roulade dessert that came to the table with "Happy Anniversary" written in chocolate on the plate.
This is one of Rochester's best kept secrets. I know once the word gets out this will be the Go-to-Place in Rochester. Until then it will stay our little secret! read more