Cancel

Open app

Search

The Gathering Table Coffeehouse

5.0 (1 review)
Open • 6:00 am - 5:00 pm

The Gathering Table Coffeehouse Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - The Gathering Table Coffeehouse

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of J F.
2
26
106

6 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Cakes and Coffee Cafe - BLT

Cakes and Coffee Cafe

4.8(13 reviews)
28.5 mi

Took a detour through Petersburg on our to see the great eclipse and found a fantastic…read morebreakfast/bakery that I won't soon forget. Cakes and Coffee Cafe are housed in an old bank on Main Street in downtown Petersburg, Indiana. The dining room is large with a counter and about a dozen Cafe tables. The place is not fancy decorated with vintage baseball memorabilia and toys. The walls are adorned with antique and vintage photos of the area. We were allowed to pick any table but encouraged to take a private room which was a converted bank office complete with original safe. Cinnamon rolls are their specialty so we ordered one ($1.99) with a side of sausage. I ordered 2 eggs with bacon and rye toast ($4.99). The menu offered a variety of coffee options which we enjoyed until our food arrived. When the food arrived, it was clear that the rye toast bread was homemade and the sausage was fresh. Our waitress said the bread is made by local Amish and the sausage comes from a butcher in Evansville. The ingredients were indeed fresh and tasted wonderful. The cinnamon roll was definitely made from scratch and sinfully good, perhaps addictive. I only wish the preserves had been homemade. The service was friendly and she kept our coffee cups full. They had a case full of delicious looking cakes and pies.

This was a super random find as I was driving from Evansville to Indianapolis the "back way". I…read morejust planned to get a to-go coffee but decided to stay for lunch. It seems like it's been untouched for decades. It may be confusing for some because on Apple Maps it comes up as Cakes and Coffee Cafe (as it does here on Yelp), but the menu says "Randy's Americana Cafe" - not sure if the name changed at some point. Regardless, it was a cool old building with this really long high top lunch counter out in the middle with traditional table seating all around. I came in on a Monday and there was a steady trickle of mostly seniors coming in. I ordered a BLT and it was great- and came out in less than 5 minutes. They had a nice selection of cakes and pies. But the real charm of this place is all the obscure Americana stuff on the walls AND the old vault in the back, which is essentially a guest book. Literally thousands of people have signed the walls in the vault. They even have a step ladder because the walls are so full that the ceiling and mechanicals are about the only available real estate. Super fun blast from the past place.

Photos
Cakes and Coffee Cafe - Main dining area

Main dining area

Cakes and Coffee Cafe - Front dining area

Front dining area

Cakes and Coffee Cafe - Menu

See all

Menu

The Gathering Table Coffeehouse - desserts - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...