Pricey for what the selection is and I tried to donate some books, but was rejected. I saw a woman…read morewalk in after me with a BIGGER box of books and they accepted hers. The manager stated they weren't taking books right now. But clearly didn't want the books that I had. I suspect it had something to do with the books being queer/LGBTQ+ friendly. Very disappointed in this transphobic/homophobic run store. The cashier woman was very kind, though. 5/5 stars for her.

I've been coming here for YEARS and love it. I love the mission behind the organization and as…read moresomeone who works in healthcare dealing with hospice patients it's close to my heart. Hard not to support such a stand up business that supports its community. It's great for clothing, then antique furniture. Sometimes they have other bits and baubles but the clothes and furniture are most consistent good finds.

We explored the aisles at the 4th Street Mercantile on a trip to the coast. There is such a variety…read moreof items and the prices are reasonable. Staff was friendly and we found some beautiful vintage linens, jewelry and a big bell. Definitely worth the stop!

Oh wow! This is a one-of-a-kind store. 4th Street Mercantile…read moreis the kind of place where you walk in just to "browse," and suddenly it's two hours later and your arms are full of treasures. There's truly a little bit of everything here! One of my favorite finds was Ramona by Helen Hunt Jackson--a beautiful, vintage copy that was originally gifted to someone for Christmas in 1910. Over a century later, it's in my hands. That's the magic of this place--you don't just shop, you uncover stories. The store is massive, with over 50 sellers showcasing their creations under one roof. It's a vibrant blend of vintage goods, handmade art, furniture, trinkets, jewelry, candles, home decor, clothing, books, wine glasses, and kitchenware. And for those with a dark heart like mine--yes, there are skulls, crystals, Halloween vibes, and goth-inspired items too! Make sure to give yourself time to explore. This is hands down my favorite store in downtown Eureka. The staff were super friendly and helpful. 5 stars, no doubt. Can't wait to come back!

An actual thrift store. Extremely reasonable prices (no junk they've decided is worth 10x the price…read morejust because), easy to donate to, nice staff, and great resource for the community. Many of my favorite clothes came from here. This place is my holy grail when I start getting too depressed by modern thrift markups and goodwill style price gouging

I had a great time seeking and searching in this store that does so much good for the community. I…read moregenerally know I'm in the right spot when the staff has green hair. It gives me comfort. Regarding selection, they've got the room for a large and varied inventory, which they DO have. And . . . Prices are happy.

I have been shopping here for two years, and usually get my velvet scrunchies and cozy over the…read moreknee socks from here. Recently had the chance to bring them an Anthropology wedding dress that did not work out for me and the ladies working here were very accepting and kind. Beautiful selection and great store.

Upon entering I was delighted by the eclectic inventory which is dominated by color, variety, and…read moreuniqueness. Pleased as well to be able to purchase items made by local artists.