The Cookie Connect
Order The Cookie Connect Takeout or Delivery
The Cookie Connect Photos
The Cookie Connect Popular Desserts
You might also consider
More like The Cookie Connect
Recommended Reviews - The Cookie Connect
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
I went to a brewery event and cookie connect was there! So many options and in mini size- so fun. We enjoyed the cookies n cream and peanut butter cookie. I love the concept but sadly never think to stop into the store - overall very good!
Once in a while when I have a sweet tooth craving or want to pick up sweets for a special occasion, I place an order from The Cookie Connect! The cookies are huge, they have a nice range of flavors, and they're delicious. They aren't like Crumbl Cookies (the flavors pretty much stay the same) but the quality is just as good. Our go-to favorites are Cinnamon Roll, Stuffed Peanut Butter Cup, and Nutella Stuffed Chocolate Chip, but you can't go wrong with any flavor!
Fast service, huge cookies, stuffed but not overstuffed where the filling is overpowering. Smaller space with limited seating. A decent place for a sweet treat after dinner.
Since I was in the area, I HAD to order from The Cookie Connect. The last time I ordered from there was years ago at their other location in Bloomfield. I ordered for pickup and found a spot right in front (shocker)! I love how cute this shop is; from the neon sign to the seating and wallpaper. Of course I had to take a picture of my cookies in front of the sign before leaving. I ordered their limited edition cookie which was the Apple Cider Donut Stuffed Snickerdoodle... AMAZING! I also ordered a box of four to share with my sister: - Cookies n Cream - Apple Pie - NYC Cheesecake - The "New" Classic My favorite out of the four was the NYC cheesecake and cookies n cream. Two thumbs up for The Cookie Connect!
Try: Nutella, Cheesecake, and The New Classic! Why: It's not often you can find a Nutella cookie chocolate chip cookie and this was my favorite! I also liked the NYC Cheesecake with cream cheese filling and raspberry drizzle. Lastly, I liked The New Classic because of the semi-sweet chocolate chips, European chocolate chunks, and sea salt! Notes: The Apple Pie was my least favorite as it did not remind me of apple pie flavors. I love their unique menu and looks like they have new weekly flavors. I want to come back and try their cereal inspired cookies! Cute small shop with cool decor. One wall was painted and had a neat color projector. The other wall has a fun neon sign that says "Don't go baking my heart!" It's self checkout with two pads to order and they were quick to bring out the warm cookies!
Ohhh lord, I never expected the day to come where I can walk into a cookie shop and melt away in a decadent artisanal cookie MmmMmmmmm! I came here to pick up my Yelpie award and walked out with a smile as if I was a kid in a candy store, but a store for grown up cookies... grown up cookies is the sh!t =] What makes this unique cookie shop so heavenly is the creations and specialty cookies that they come up with. Who in their right mind can deny a warm, gooey, tasty and tantalizing cookie at any time of the day or night! Yes, night... they are open past midnight for you munchie addicts. If this cookie is your last meal of the day before bed be ready for some wild and exotic dreams... no pun intended LoL!
I ordered a batch of cookies for delivery. All of them were delicious. Super soft and moist with satisfyingly crunchy edges. Each cookie is quite large. The stuffed nutter butter had a little less filling than I would've expected, but it was still tasty. My favorite was the birthday cake. Sometimes rainbow sprinkle cookies can have an artificial taste, but the vanilla flavoring came through in this one and it was great. This place is an excellent option for any occasion that needs a sweet treat! They have very cute packaging too.
Came in here at 12:40am(they close at 1) for a late night dessert and they still had everything available from their menu. Other cookie spots that I've been to only had a few or a couple items left when they're about to close, so I was pleased that I had all the choices. I got the box of 4 and ordered Cookies 'N' Cream, Nutella Stuffed Chocolate Chip, NYC Cheesecake, and The *NEW* Classic. Cut everything up to try each one of them... And they were all good! I was expecting them to be too sweet just because of the fillings and toppings, but they each had a good balance of everything. I love sweets, but I don't like my sweets too sweet so this was perfect for me. I cannot wait come back and try their other cookies! I already recommended it to my friends and family.
Got a box of 8 cookies last night for a party and they were all a big hit! They more expensive than Insomnia, but the cookies are bigger and the creative flavors are worth the splurge if you're looking for something special. We tried: Top row: Salted Caramel Pretzel, Stuffed Peanut Butter Cup, Birthday Cake, S'mores, Bottom row: Cookies 'N' Cream, Nutella Stuffed Chocolate Chip, Mounds of Coconut, Apple Pie My favorites were the Birthday Cake and the Nutella Stuffed Chocolate Chip (worth the $0.50 extra!), From their website, it was not clear whether you could stop into Cookie Connect and buy cookies on the spot, or if you have to order ahead. I went ahead and ordered online for pickup. They did not text/email to confirm the order is ready, but they were ready at the time I selected for pickup. In
Came here twice and has mixed impressions. The cookies are big and perhaps that's why it's slightly pricy. Once you placed the order, they will then assemble the cookies with the toppings you want. In terms of flavor, I like the nyc cheesecake, s'mores, salted caramel pretzel. I disliked the Chocolate Covered Strawberry Brownie Batter Stuffed which was the Limited Edition Cookie. It was too sweet and pricier. I gave 3 stars also cause of the hair found in one of the cookies during 2nd visit. We found about it after leaving the store so I contacted the customer service via email. However, they fixed it by refunding the entire order.
A tad bit too sugary but so yum. 10/10 and the service was so quick and smooth absolutely loved it
Our go-to for cookies in this area! We get delivery usually from here but even then, it's always perfectly soft, chewy and warm! Highly recommend for your next cookie craving!
2 years ago
Warm cookie goodness on a cold winter night!! We ordered: Hot Cocoa Cookie Limited Edition Cookie And The *NEW* Classic chocolate chip Loved the cookies!! Great murals! Do't Go Bakin My Heart!! Love the sign too!! read more
20 days ago
It was good. One of my cookies melted before it got to me but that wasn't the persons fault. The dunkaroo cookie was SO GOOOOOD. I would get it again. This was my first time trying it and I loved it. I got a 4 pack and shared with 2 other people. It was great and i love the variety of the flavors that they have! read more
I went to a brewery event and cookie connect was there! So many options and in mini size- so fun. We enjoyed the cookies n cream and peanut butter cookie. I love the concept but sadly never think to stop into the store - overall very good! read more
Once in a while when I have a sweet tooth craving or want to pick up sweets for a special occasion, I place an order from The Cookie Connect! The cookies are huge, they have a nice range of flavors, and they're delicious. They aren't like Crumbl Cookies (the flavors pretty much stay the same) but the quality is just as good. Our go-to favorites are Cinnamon Roll, Stuffed Peanut Butter Cup, and Nutella Stuffed Chocolate Chip, but you can't go wrong with any flavor! read more
4 years ago
Since I was in the area, I HAD to order from The Cookie Connect. The last time I ordered from there was years ago at their other location in Bloomfield. I ordered for pickup and found a spot right in front (shocker)! I love how cute this shop is; from the neon sign to the seating and wallpaper. Of course I had to take a picture of my cookies in front of the sign before leaving. I ordered their limited edition cookie which was the Apple Cider Donut Stuffed Snickerdoodle... AMAZING! I also ordered a box of four to share with my sister: - Cookies n Cream - Apple Pie - NYC Cheesecake - The "New" Classic My favorite out of the four was the NYC cheesecake and cookies n cream. Two thumbs up for The Cookie Connect! read more
Try: Nutella, Cheesecake, and The New Classic! Why: It's not often you can find a Nutella cookie chocolate chip cookie and this was my favorite! I also liked the NYC Cheesecake with cream cheese filling and raspberry drizzle. Lastly, I liked The New Classic because of the semi-sweet chocolate chips, European chocolate chunks, and sea salt! Notes: The Apple Pie was my least favorite as it did not remind me of apple pie flavors. I love their unique menu and looks like they have new weekly flavors. I want to come back and try their cereal inspired cookies! Cute small shop with cool decor. One wall was painted and had a neat color projector. The other wall has a fun neon sign that says "Don't go baking my heart!" It's self checkout with two pads to order and they were quick to bring out the warm cookies! read more
Ohhh lord, I never expected the day to come where I can walk into a cookie shop and melt away in a decadent artisanal cookie MmmMmmmmm! I came here to pick up my Yelpie award and walked out with a smile as if I was a kid in a candy store, but a store for grown up cookies... grown up cookies is the sh!t =] What makes this unique cookie shop so heavenly is the creations and specialty cookies that they come up with. Who in their right mind can deny a warm, gooey, tasty and tantalizing cookie at any time of the day or night! Yes, night... they are open past midnight for you munchie addicts. If this cookie is your last meal of the day before bed be ready for some wild and exotic dreams... no pun intended LoL! read more
I ordered a batch of cookies for delivery. All of them were delicious. Super soft and moist with satisfyingly crunchy edges. Each cookie is quite large. The stuffed nutter butter had a little less filling than I would've expected, but it was still tasty. My favorite was the birthday cake. Sometimes rainbow sprinkle cookies can have an artificial taste, but the vanilla flavoring came through in this one and it was great. This place is an excellent option for any occasion that needs a sweet treat! They have very cute packaging too. read more
3 years ago
Came in here at 12:40am(they close at 1) for a late night dessert and they still had everything available from their menu. Other cookie spots that I've been to only had a few or a couple items left when they're about to close, so I was pleased that I had all the choices. I got the box of 4 and ordered Cookies 'N' Cream, Nutella Stuffed Chocolate Chip, NYC Cheesecake, and The *NEW* Classic. Cut everything up to try each one of them... And they were all good! I was expecting them to be too sweet just because of the fillings and toppings, but they each had a good balance of everything. I love sweets, but I don't like my sweets too sweet so this was perfect for me. I cannot wait come back and try their other cookies! I already recommended it to my friends and family. read more
Got a box of 8 cookies last night for a party and they were all a big hit! They more expensive than Insomnia, but the cookies are bigger and the creative flavors are worth the splurge if you're looking for something special. We tried: Top row: Salted Caramel Pretzel, Stuffed Peanut Butter Cup, Birthday Cake, S'mores, Bottom row: Cookies 'N' Cream, Nutella Stuffed Chocolate Chip, Mounds of Coconut, Apple Pie My favorites were the Birthday Cake and the Nutella Stuffed Chocolate Chip (worth the $0.50 extra!), From their website, it was not clear whether you could stop into Cookie Connect and buy cookies on the spot, or if you have to order ahead. I went ahead and ordered online for pickup. They did not text/email to confirm the order is ready, but they were ready at the time I selected for pickup. In read more
3 years ago
Came here twice and has mixed impressions. The cookies are big and perhaps that's why it's slightly pricy. Once you placed the order, they will then assemble the cookies with the toppings you want. In terms of flavor, I like the nyc cheesecake, s'mores, salted caramel pretzel. I disliked the Chocolate Covered Strawberry Brownie Batter Stuffed which was the Limited Edition Cookie. It was too sweet and pricier. I gave 3 stars also cause of the hair found in one of the cookies during 2nd visit. We found about it after leaving the store so I contacted the customer service via email. However, they fixed it by refunding the entire order. read more
2 years ago
A tad bit too sugary but so yum. 10/10 and the service was so quick and smooth absolutely loved it read more
2 years ago
I usually go with insomnia cookie but wanted to give these guys a shot. Look at how it was delivered, ARE YOU KIDDING ME? Never again. Don't order here. read more
2 years ago
Our go-to for cookies in this area! We get delivery usually from here but even then, it's always perfectly soft, chewy and warm! Highly recommend for your next cookie craving! read more
Okay, wow best cookies ever! I was driving by this place and had the window rolled down and smelled the cookies and HAD to check it out. I figured I would try one basic cookie and one crazy cookie. The small shop has a counter where you order on an iPad and someone bakes your cookies fresh and brings the box to you, such an efficient system. Both cookies are so chewy and soft, they're the perfect texture. I love that they were baked fresh (not sure if they do this all the time) but they were so warm. The flufatella s'mores cookie was delicious it was stuffed with Nutella and had a chocolate drizzle topped with marshmallow fluff; hence the name flufatella. The classic is a chocolate chip cookie, you can't go wrong with a delicious chocolate chip cookie. I must say the cookies are quite rich, especially the flufatella one, so if you don't like a lot of chocolate, go for something simpler! read more
4 years ago
Hole in the wall place with digital ordering when you come in. Pretty quick in getting the cookies ready and they have plenty of options. The cookies come warm and this pumpkin one was a real treat. I was surprised it had syrup drizzled on it as that's an interesting combo. But nonetheless it was a really good cookie. read more
5 years ago
Ahhh-mazing. My friend brought hot cookies over Saturday morning and I'm already planning my trip back. The base of each cookie was so chewy and delicious. Often times bakeries with these interesting toppings don't focus enough on the cookie. No problem here. The stuffing/ toppings are just an added bonus. Our favorites were the Oreo, Nutella and birthday cake. No matter what you choose you won't be disappointed. They have a few locations in north Jersey. read more
2 years ago
I loved these cookies so much, the service was amazing and fast! Cant wait to try this again! read more
1 year ago
2 years ago
5 years ago
Got the cookies n cream cookie and it was delicious! Can't wait to try more cookies on the menu. read more
So happy there's another cookie spot in Hoboken and right by my apartment :). There were so many interesting cookies to choose from and I ordered the s'mores and the Oreo cookies. The cookies are a lot bigger than Insomnia Cookies and were stuffed with chocolate inside! Service is a little slow since they prepare your order right after it's received unlike other cookie places where it's premade but at the end you get a warm cookie which is a plus! read more
3 years ago
Great service! You definitely need a sweet tooth and a low A1C count. Their sweet treats are delicious! The cereal shakes are enough for three and that was the small one! Enjoy! read more
3 years ago
3 years ago
These cookies are absolutely gorgeous! However I felt the flavor to be really lacking. The dough of the cookies don't have much taste and I'm guessing because they want the toppings to do the heavy lifting. But I don't feel like the toppings make up for it. The syrups used on top are store bought and you can taste the artificial flavoring. Price is pretty reasonable for the cost as they are on the larger side. read more
3 years ago
Ordered a box of 8 cookies to satisfy my late night sweet tooth. My favorite was the Oreo cookie. It was stuffed with an Oreo cookie which was a nice surprise. The rest I found lackluster and underdone for my liking. The centers were pretty much raw cookie dough. $42 on flat, okay cookies definitely soured the night, read more
Business owner information
Ali H.
Hey there Azarel! Please message contact@thecookieconnect.com with…
3 years ago
4 years ago
I probably was a little tough on them the first time. The cookies here do have a unique touch and hit the spot. The cookies and cream had an oreo in it and was delicious. The cheesecake one was delicious and literally had cheesecake filling in the middle. These cookies are more than just toppings. The peanut butter cookie is also one of my favorites. They are a little expensive but that seems to be the theme these days with bakeries. All good. 4 stars all the way! read more
Holy smokes! Best cookies in Hoboken definitely tops Insomnia cookies by far. They are made fresh to order and handled with delicate care. I can tell because I got these delivered and when I opened the box the 8 cookies were so gentily spaced. The cookies were delicious! Not too sweet and perfectly chewy. read more
5 years ago
The ice cream tastes just like cereal milk. It was great & better than expected. Fine corn flakes were mixed into ice cream. Caramel syrup & corn flakes topped the ice cream. The cookies were good. Fun flavors & the drizzle is a unique concept. The cookies were not thick which was nice because all of the flavors were heavy & very sweet. Cookies & cream cookie was stuffed with an oreo & drizzled with a lot of chocolate sauce (too much drizzle I think). PB&J was stuffed with peanut butter & was drizzled with an overly sweet raspberry sauce (again, too much drizzle as it made the cookie way too rich & sweet). Cinnamon roll had Cinnamon Toast Crunch on top & a sweet drizzle. Birthday cake was my favorite. It was delicious & not overly sweet, especially compared to the other flavors. Your hands will be very sticky from the drizzle so you'll need more than a napkin! Overall a fun treat. I liked the ice cream the best. read more
5 years ago
4 years ago
Cookie connect over Insomnia for so many reasons. The cookie choices here are superb. The hours are also superb for the late night munchies. You can choose from any cereal inspired cookie under the sun. They also offer delivery and the staff are always very friendly and kind! read more
2 years ago
Page 1 of 2
More info about The Cookie Connect
Ask the Community - The Cookie Connect
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
1 review that is not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
5 years ago
