We were staying nearby and a friend recommended we try Carl's and I'm glad we did. We ordered…read moretakeout. The service was not so good and they were not very friendly or I would have given them a 5. The pizza however was delicious. We got a thin crust, cheese with bacon. The cheese had a great flavor and the crust was extra crispy. I would definitely go back and order takeout if we were close by.

Wow! The pizza was absolutely great! We had 1/2 cheese and 1/2 sausage mushroom and I must say the…read morecheese was better. We came on a Greenup Car Cruise night and sat in the patio. And watched the rides roll by. Great stop and completely unexpected taste!

maybe don't offer delivery if you can't deliver. thanks for making me wait for nothing.read more

Last time I hear I had a carryout and it was the hardest crust and no pepperoni never come back…read moreagain

Best pizza in Effingham hands down. Don't sleep on the pastas! Family owned and operated!read more

Ordered Baked Mostacioli with a side Greek for pick up…read more The mostacioli was delicious. Healthy portion with a sweet marinara sauce and melted cheese...alot of cheese! The small Greek salad was a great accompaniment with plenty of feta and a tasty Greek dressing. I would have love kalamata olives instead of black,but a great salad. I kinda regret not eating in after walking in and seeing what a cute restaurant this place is. Like something from an Americana movie. I will go back!!

Fantastic Pizza! Been eating it 44 years and it is still perfect! Great family dinner spot and…read morereasonably priced.

Out of state visitor, wanted to order the spaghetti dinner to go, but they only sell the 1\2 gallon…read moreto go. i got it and i am glad i did, it fed me for 2 nights. sauce made just whe way i like, nice and meaty. Great family vibe and atmosphere here. service was quick, ready when i arrived. love it here, coming back next time in town! thanks

Fantastic dining experience and properly sized 8 inch pizza for a single diner. Service was…read morespectacular and food was even better. Highly recommend.

Amazing pizza and amazing family that makes it!!!…read more It is a must when my siblings come back to town to visit and we often take some to them on our visits. So excited to see the Vitale family growing and opening restaurants all over Illinois and now Indiana too. You have to get extra sauce!!! Simply delicious!

As a tourist I had to visit a Casey "K-C" in Casey "K-Z" but it's one of their old school gas…read morestations that aren't like their newer predicesors I've been too but it has that great charm. It's busy, great locals and Amish folk too! Fair priced food, average restrooms, quiet with little traffic.

What kind of simpleton hires minors at the register when they can't sell alcohol? Why hire them in…read morethe first place? If they're too young to sell alcohol, they shouldn't be at the register at all. Then we're stuck waiting on the kitchen girl or guy to ring us out. The dude was loaded with order tickets one night and I couldn't wait any longer. Whoever the manager is really needs to be more strategic on who they put to work at the front cause right now their set up is stupid.

First time here, not from the area. The pics looked…read more absolutely delicious so we tried Chubby's. A MUST GO! Fresh crust, toppings and sauce!

Exellecent taco pizza, service is good, and ambiance is good. On the main street on Lincoln averead more

This is one of our favorite restaurants in the country! We have been here probably 4 or 5 times…read moresince it opened. We have a place not far from here but live full time in Texas. My wife was spending some time up here and drove up to surprise her for her birthday! Reservations at the counter so we could watch Chef Geno work his magic! The food is usually spectacular and tonight did not disappoint! We split the Caesar Salad to start which was plenty. And then I had the Pasta Rags and my wife had the Pasta Carbonara. Both were as good as they looked! Perfection! No splitting dessert! I had the Tiramisu and she had the Chocolate Cake. Both to die for! It's byob so bring a nice bottle of wine and round out the experience. As Chef Geno says..."Cheaper than a plane ticket to Italy!"

The good: The food was absolutely magnificent. The chef is likely classically trained. Presentation…read morewas excellent. The sauce was as good as i have ever had. The bad: The wait staff was not very engaged. I wanted this review to be about the food but that just wasn't meant to be. The Ugly: I am very well travelled on 3 continents. I've dined elegantly as well as from street vendors and I have NEVER had service that was this off putting to the point of being overtly rude, and I am an American who has eaten in France and doesn't speak much French. When we wouldn't sit at the bar, even though the main area was only 1/4 occupied They moved our party of 2 into the side room with chairs up on tables. It went downhill from there. Due to this, it wasn't possible to really enjoy what should have been a fine meal. I will say it is a wise policy to ask for payment and tip ahead of this type of service before it is provided.

Pretty basic pizza. We got the thin crust and it was just ok. My friend got the cauliflower crust…read moreand loved it!

I visit Marshall a couple times a year for the last 10 years. Each time I've visited I've enjoyed…read morelocal pizza. I haven't been too impressed. I'm happy to say that Rosie's gets the job done. The wait times are long but I'm sure they're working out the kinks. I really like this spot and I'll look forward to it next time I visit.

In town for the 2026 Hot Rod Power Tour and stopped here with the crew for some pizza. Initially we…read morewere a lil concerned because the place although open was empty but to our surprise The pizza was amazing - Thin crust, plenty of toppings. Perfect crunch on the crust. We ate 2 large pies and were very happy. If you're in town you must stop by and give it a try.

I have eaten here many times! The one thing I love about this place is the food is ALWAYS sooo…read moreyummy! The bread is homemade daily and there is nothing like it. The wait staff are always helpful when I'm stuck on what to order! The restaurant is really nice and has 2 different areas to eat in. You can also order carry out and enjoy at home!