Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Baker's Thumb

    5.0 (2 reviews)

    The Baker's Thumb Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - The Baker's Thumb

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Jody A.
    127
    14
    0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Cupcakes 439 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Selina's - Selinas Red Velvet

    Selina's

    3.7(3 reviews)
    3.5 km

    Horrible experience. I ordered cupcakes for my office and everyone got sick. There was literally a…read moreline of people to vomit in the bathrooms. And the actual cupcakes tasted like they were baked in a Honda. I don't think cupcakes should smell like diesel. AVOID AT ALL COSTS!

    I heard about Selina's red velvet cupcake delivery when I was watching Bay News 9 in my dentists…read morewaiting room! Imagine being in such bad pain and needing a root canal but your brain drifts off to cupcake land! I was intrigued by Anthony's story. He started baking and perfecting his mom, Selina's, red velvet cupcake recipe. Once they were as good as Moms, he began selling them on FB to help raise money for his mom's breast cancer treatment! How could any human not be moved by that business model!?! I went home and looked them up on FB and "Liked" their page. I carefully read the order details and didn't hesitate to order my first dozen red velvet cupcakes! Please keep in mind, Selina's only sells red velvet with cream cheese cupcakes or a full cake. I messaged Anthony with my first order to be delivered a few days later, on a Saturday afternoon. The cost was $15 (plus tax) for the 12 cupcakes and $3 delivery fee. Saturday came and knock knock on my door.... there's a sweet young man smiling at me and handing me the MOST DELICIOUS red velvet cupcakes I have ever eaten! The cream cheese frosting was so creamy and smooth. Definitely not grainy like most! I know he makes his mama proud! My middle son is picker than picky and raved about these. He helped polish off the dozen and then asked when I was ordering again!? I have since ordered once more and it was consistently as amazing as the first time! And don't forget to tip Anthony!!!

    Photos
    Selina's
    Selina's - The best red velvet cupcakes you've ever eaten!!!

    The best red velvet cupcakes you've ever eaten!!!

    Selina's

    See all

    Sweet Tooth Cakery - Response from the business regarding my email to them about the encounter with the delivery driver.

    Sweet Tooth Cakery

    2.7(3 reviews)
    3.3 km

    I was on Symmes road today when a car advertising this business ran a stop sign and pulled out in…read morefront of me. I didn't honk or get mad but I was close behind because I had to slam on my brakes to avoid hitting her when she pulled out. She then sped up and flicked me off and slammed her brakes when I caught up to the light in hopes I would hit her. I appreciate them advertising their business so I know how unprofessional they are and I can let friends and social media followed know not to use this business. Enjoy washing your car! Lol Update: emailed the business about the encounter with the delivery driver and received a response (attached). I appreciate the response and expect they'll address it. May give the business a try but avoid delivery. Lol

    After an overly expensive quote from Publix for a two tier, square wedding cake, I began looking…read morefor someone who could help with my seemingly simple request for an appropriate price. I came across Pam's bakery and LOVED her designs. We went with the original idea of a two tier square design with vanilla cake and raspberry filling. She happened to be delivering my area (South Tampa) and offered to drop my cake off to me vice me coming to get it for no additional charge! The cake was delicious - soft, not overwhelmingly sweet, or excessively coated in icing/fondant. We even ate the cake for breakfast after the wedding! Everything about the process, from ordering to consumption, was perfect. I'd recommend Pam/Sweet Tooth Cakery for any wedding, birthday party, or simple cupcake request!!

    La Creación Bakery 2 - Brandon

    La Creación Bakery 2 - Brandon

    4.0(25 reviews)
    3.5 km

    Another day, another bakery! This Puerto Rican bakery serves authentic Puerto Rican sweets and…read moresandwiches, and they also have another location in Tampa. The space is spacious with plenty of indoor seating, and the service was quick and efficient. I tried the media noche sandwich made with their sweet pan sobao bread, along with their coffee and a cheese pastry. The pastry was huge and tasted really good, but the texture was a bit off for me. It was overly flaky, which made it messier than usual to eat. Don't get me wrong--it was still delicious, just a little harder to manage! As for the sandwich, it didn't quite hit the mark. It wasn't bad, but it felt like it was missing something--maybe just a better balance overall of the ingredients. That said, I think the prices here are great, especially considering the portion sizes. I'd definitely come back to try other sandwiches and explore more of their sweet treats. There's a lot on the menu that looks promising!

    4.5 stars for La Creacion. This bakery is not big. But it has a sandwich that not many Puerto Rican…read morecarry. The Las De Cayey is a special sandwich with Mallorca bread. This bread dust with sugar powder. It comes with ham and cheese insert. Very delicious. We also got the regular flan that rich in milk base. This is an indulgent dessert. We also got the tamarind juice. Not sour at all. Lovely drink. All good are good. Service is good too.

    Photos
    La Creación Bakery 2 - Brandon - Las de Cayey mallorca sandwich with ham and swiss - A new favorite from La Creación Bakery.

    Las de Cayey mallorca sandwich with ham and swiss - A new favorite from La Creación Bakery.

    La Creación Bakery 2 - Brandon - Pastelillo de guayaba y queso

    Pastelillo de guayaba y queso

    La Creación Bakery 2 - Brandon

    See all

    The Baker's Thumb - cupcakes - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...