Charming restaurant, spectacular shrimp carbonara special. Kitchen was swamped with a large party and our order was delayed. Understandable, but other guests arriving after us did not wait for one hour. read more

Good average . Service adequate at best. Nice room. Very Pricey ! Rude !!!!! Not going back again read more

I grew up in Boca Grande and have fond memories of the Temp and Frank and Ricky. I love the shrimp and get it every time. My wife got the triple tail special- but my other go to is the steak! Enjoy! read more

Old Florida atmosphere. Opened in 1946. Vinyl tile flooring (probably the original tile). Murals painted on the plaster walls. White table cloths for lunch and dinner. A wonderful time capsule taking you back to the 40's. You feel like Humphrey Bogart could walk in any minute. The specialty here is fresh, locally caught seafood which typically includes grouper, snapper, pompano, shrimp, oysters and soft shell crab. We enjoyed the Grouper Reuben at lunch. Small bar on side. If you come in the winter months, you need a reservation. read more

See all

The owners seem very nice and the food is good but........ Tables are crammed on top of each other. Old people screaming at each other. More iPhones lighting up menus than fans asking for an encore at. Sammy Hagar concert. If the place is crowded turn around. Could not wait to get out of there. Time to put an outdoor patio on the lot next door and pull some tables from inside. When no one is there; I am sure it's great but I doubt that ever happens. read more

Great food! Love going for lunch and the grouper fingers are fabulous! Highly recommend!

Very hard to get a reservation Last visit seated my party of five next to rest room and kitchen entry in front room. Visited a week earlier and got nice table in Caribbean room. Service both times was good and guests enjoyed their meals. Other than crowding and sometimes loud talking noise levels was good enough to recommend. Will be going back read more

Love The Temp. Food is great, atmosphere is old school, love it. Bar is robust and great place to have dinner too.

Our captain recommended this place after a morning of fishing. Located downtown, but easy to find. The inside gives you an old-school, speakeasy like vibe. Unfortunately, due to freezer issues the day we visited the seafood selection was limited. We split the snapper, which was cooked well and served over the most delicious brussel sprouts. read more

Summary: Go! Just get on the phone and call for a booking. I don't give very many 5-star reviews, but temptations was just great. I'd take a few points off for the room, but what they lack there is more than made up for elsewhere. Room: Definitely not Temptation's strong suit. Very utilitarian. In the full light of day it would look a bit like an elaborately decorated cafeteria. They even deliver the meals on those gray, plastic push carts I remember from the high school cafeteria. Service: Exceptional. Our server, Pete, was vey friendly and steered us toward a few things that we really appreciated. The appetizers came out quickly (soup and salad) and when the entrees were taking a little longer than we thought normal, Pete was there to entertain for a few minutes and take our attention back. Food: this is where Temptations really shines. We started with a Bibb lettuce salad and a lobster chowder and both were delicious. The salad was dressed really well and everything tasted fresh. For entrees, we had a seared tuna (special that day) and pompano piccata. The tuna was a really big block of very fresh, rare tuna, seared on both sides with an Asian noodle salad and a side of ginger fried rice. The Pompano was beautifully cooked with a delicate, flaky texture and the piccata sauce was delicious. It came with a potato croquette and both entrees came with sautéed asparagus. Everything was seriously delicious. Dessert is always a tug-of-war with us. We're up for it if it's something really special, but otherwise we're rather not waste the calories. Again Pete came through, suggesting the pecan pie and it was among the best I've ever tasted. Value: Temps is a very good value for what you get. Our dinner with two apps, two entrees, one dessert, and a bottle of wine was $185 and the wine was about 1/3 of that. Considering how really delicious it was, and the terrific service, I believe it's a good value for a splurge or celebratory event. read more

we dined at the temptation last night, had the best waitress Marci, she was so attentive , informative, so knowledgable about the food on the menu. She was so great, and the food was so fresh, hot an appealing visually and tasted even better. The best fried oysters on the planet. Would highly recommend this restuarant with no hesitation !!!!! The place is clean an crisp, not much to look at from the out side, its a hidden gem!!!!!!!But make reservations , lunch or dinners. Can't say enough good things about the service and the food. read more

Had such high hopes based on reviews. Ordered lobster chowder, shrimp cocktail, triple tail with avo crema and fried shrimp/grouper. Chowder and cocktail were good. We are from Louisiana so know fried seafood. This shrimp arrived with no batter, no flavor and tough. Felt it was like a bad long John silvers. Do not recommend Service was sweet and swift. read more

DISAPPOINTING We took a day trip up from Fort Myers to Boca Grande and Gasparilla, and decided to eat here because it had the highest Yelp reviews. I can only conclude that the tourists are so relieved to find a white tablecloth joint in this remote outpost that they enthuse a bit too much. We started with the Lobster & Corn Chowder. It was okay, with one prominently placed piece of lobster, much corn and 1/3 potato cubes. We also had the highly acclaimed Strawberry Salad. It had lovely clumps of cheese and candied pecans, but aside from that it was nothing very special. What makes it strawberry? Sliced strawberries ringed the plate. The rest was lettuce. The dressing, which must be taken on the side because it is so rich, is a sort or balsamic reduction and is quite nice. We also had the Grouper Bits with French Fries. The fish was fresh but completely lacking in any seasoning. Very bland. And the fries were not crispy as advertised, but rather thick and rather limp. This place would have difficulty surviving someplace where the competition was a bit stiffer. read more

See all

After a long day in the water, dinner at the Temp was just what we needed. Caught a grouper and brought the fillets in to the restaurant, handed them to the waiter, and they cooked it for us to perfection. We came as a large group and tried many items in the menu, everything was delicious. Service was fantastic and very attentive. Love the atmosphere. A must try when in Boca Grand! read more

See all

I love "The Temp," as locals refer to it. My parents have a house on Boca Grande and it's their favorite restaurant, which says something. I love the retro old school ambiance and decor. The service is excellent and food excels as well. You're crazy not to order fish here as the selection is wonderful, and always fresh. You can have the fish prepared a couple of different ways, and they are very accommodating of special requests (e.g. double side of vegetables). It's not cheap, but you get your money's worth. It's definitely better to eat in the front room as the atmosphere is MUCH nicer. That being said, if you are a larger party, or have kids, you're better off getting a table out back. My only compliant is the wine list. There is a decent selection BUT the labels are all pretty low quality and they charge a premium for them. You're better off buying a bottle if you want something of decent quality. There is a nice bar which is great for a drink in the afternoon, or beverage pre, or post, dinner. read more

Get the lobster corn chowder!! Food was great, sat at the bar and had a great conversation with the bartender! Will be back next visit!

Love the atmosphere! It's like going back into 1940s Florida. The murals on the wall are wonderful, the long bar as one enters is surely filled with locals, the food is delicious and there's even an old-fashioned cigarette machine near the bathrooms, which was just hilarious. It's a great place. read more

Wow, best meal I've had in FLA by far. Waitstaff is amazing, and the Island Favorite is the best grouper/fish dish I've ever had read more

Temptation Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Boca Grande, Florida

Best place for any occasion on the island! Fish and cocktails outstanding - and the package store is a lifesaver. read more

Food was good as it has been in past visits, but service of entree was very slow. First course was delivered in timely manner but one can only drink so much wine waiting for the entrees. read more

Temptation Restaurant was a surprising little gem that my friend had always wanted to try. We decided today was the day! We entered and saw what seemed like a little dinner set back in time. E wandered to the other side where there was a bar and one bar height table in the window with two chairs. We decided to sit there. Our waitress was bubbly and kind. Came right over and asked what she could get started for us. We asked for a drink and lunch menu. Promptly ordered a Prosecco drink and an old fashioned. We then ordered a bouillabaisse salad with crab and shrimp and a raspberry vinegarette, a lobster and corn chowder and a platter with fried grouper and shrimp, sweet potato fries and a fresh fruit bowl. The lobster and corn chowder was so thick! But it was delicious! The platter was tasty and my friend enjoyed her salad. The old fashioned was surprising. Wisconsin old fashioneds are completely different from Florida old fashioned. There was a giant ice cube with about an inch of whiskey in it, Dark cherries on a stick and a bit of orange peel in it. Back home they fill it with sprite or something! Not here! read more

See all

Food was fantastic! Had the Lobster Corn Chowder, which is among the best soup I've ever had. Then had the Red Snapper, which was cooked to perfection. Everyone in our party was very pleased with their dishes. Server was very knowledgeable, friendly, and attentive. Even the head chef visited our table to ask how everything tasted. Wonderful evening. If you're looking for delicious food and great dining experience, off the beaten path, I highly recommend making the trip out here. Not likely to disappoint! read more

Really delicious lunch! The best! My husband had The Island Special and I had the strawberry salad! Even the coffee was good! (Unlike a lot of places!). Highly recommended! read more

The four of us had different lunch dishes. My seafood was good and the service was excellent. We'd probably go back if in the area again.

Great restaurant ! Fish specials are always fresh off the boat that day . We had triple tail last night and it was fantastic. Service was great ! My favorite restaurant in Boca Grand! read more

The restaurant is not much to look at and the ambiance is lacking, but the food was very good. We came here for lunch one day. We had good beer and nice salads. It was good, but nothing to "write home about". The restaurant itself is a little dark and dated. It was fine for lunch, but it did not feel particularly special. read more

Excellent food and service. Was recommended by tour company. A Boca Grande original. Would recommend the Island favorite and the lobster bisque. read more

See all

Fried softshell crabs, the best I have ever had! Kitchen manager came out and chatted with us, I thought was very nice. An older lady which could have been the owner, definitely could change her attitude and seem more friendly. Food was awesome, waitress was awesome, kitchen manager was awesome, Old Lady wasn't, may need to look into retirement! read more

Four of us stopped for lunch. One salad was OK, one soup was fair, two Joy grilled cheese (cheese, bacon, tomatoes, onion) were fair, one oyster stew was outstanding. One grilled cheese was HORRIBLE. All in all, a casual, very friendly place with barely average food. The waiter was very accommodating and the oyster stew was as good as any, but the rest was fair at best. Visited December 2016 read more

Bartender Christine is always friendly and always on the move to serve ppl!! Great food...recommend Lobster Chowder, Shrimp and Grouper Platter, Cobb Salad!! It's all good!!! We sit in the bar for a casual experience. However, we have sat in the dining area for a special occasion. read more

You can't help but feel like you were transported back into the 1950's when you walk into town, and the Temptation restaurant is not different. My family and I have been a number of times as we come to this restaurant at least once during our trips to Boca Grande. Though we've sat in the front area of the restaurant, we usually choose to get a reservation in the back room, where the atmosphere is a little more casual. The food, especially the fresh seafood is out of this world fabulous! Their strawberry salad is something we order each time, and it is always delicious, though sometimes the dressing can get a little heavy, so order it on the side to be on the safe side. Their hot crabmeat temptation appetizer is also delicious, though rich and heavy, so be sure you have enough room for the entree too because they are just as worth the room in your stomach! We have heard wonderful things about the fried oysters, the fried shrimp and many of the other fried dishes, but our group tends to order the fresh fish dishes, because they simply can't be beat. The blackened grouper is phenomenal! Time and time again, we leave there saying that it was the best grouper on the island. You have your choice of sauces with this dish, which makes it even better. The side choices are also quite numerous, though a favorite that is not always available is a Jamaican twice-baked potato--heaven in your mouth. The desserts are simple and more basic than some of the others on the island, but they have a strong slice of key lime pie and their goldbrick sundae with the hardened chocolate crust takes you back to your favorite ice cream parlor as a kid and is commonly ordered by our group. read more

When I go back home to Boca to visit, the rallying cry is always: meet you at the Temp for happy hour! The bartenders might as well be a part of my family, but they'll treat a newbie the same way they treat the locals. (Well, the locals might get a little attitude, but probably because they deserve it.) Go with a group, or go by yourself. After you spend a half-hour checking out all the things on the wall, turn to your neighbor and say hello. Chances are you'll lose the next couple of hours to great conversation. I brought my New Orleans boyfriend to visit for the first time, and The Temp bar was the place he was most comfortable, because it's the most authentic and real. It's a little bit of preserved Boca Grande -- everything that makes it a great place to live or visit. All my family loves it here, and I do too. Have a Moscow Mule. Or two. But NEVER three. Trust me on that. read more

What a great dinner! I had the strawberry salad, South Florida Grouper with the corn sauce and the Jamaican jerk twice-baked potato (not on the menu, but knew to order based on another Yelp review). My wife had the cedar plank salmon and Cajun fingerling potatoes. Seldom have we had a meal with so much flavor. The grouper with corn sauce was spectacular! My wife's salmon really had that smokey plank taste. Oh, and we had the key lime pie...I recommend you do the same. The only critical comment I have relates to the dressing on the strawberry salad. The salad itself was delicious, but the consistency and taste of the dressing was a little strange. Make sure you get it on the side. The wait staff was great! Oh, did I mention the garlic butter for the warm bread? Every time I think of the meal, I remember another great flavor...! read more

I've been dining at The Temp for over a year now and leave happy every time. The food is great and the service is the best I've had on the island. While the Caribbean Room can be a bit noisy, the quality and experience are more than worth it! read more

First time to Temps. The ambiance is great and the staff super friendly. We ordered the spicy fries shrimp appetizer and it was very good. I had the surf and turf dinner and it's was beyond good. The grouper fingers were perfectly fried and the filet was amazing. The sweet potato and the brown sugar sauce that comes with it are heavenly! read more

Seafood hidden gem...all the tourist trap restaurants were empty, this place was busting at the seams, and apparently there is a daily run on the fresh made crabcakes! They even had a passable veggie burger! Nice local joint, attached to the locals-only bar. Just be ready for 1970 decor and poorly painted murals... read more

Great find on Yelp. Not the fanciest looking pls e but very clean. But the service and good was great. The lobster chowder was yummy-with a big piece of lobster propped on top. And the grilled grouper on shredded Brussels splits was delicious read more

If you are staying on Boca Grande, don't miss the TEMP! It is the place to meet, have a drink and a great meal. The food is always excellent and abundant. The fish is fresh, service friendly and the bar is lively and fun. Frequently, i pass the main bar and sit at the rear bar for a bite of dinner and a glass of wine. Truly, the best fried shrimp I have ever had and the coconut pie is amazing. The Temp has their own pastry chef that makes all of her crusts from scratch. No mistaking quality of the baked goods here. Order the strawberry salad... its huge so you may want to share it! I have never been let down by the food, drink or service at the Temp! Call in the summer months to make sure they are open. They close for vacation and cleaning at some point! During high season, call ahead for a reservation for sure... Plan ahead its a busy spot but very well worth planning ahead! Enjoy! read more

Why did we wait so long to eat at The Temp? It won't happen again! Next time we will eat there everyday! The lunch menu is very reasonable and everything you would expect. It was difficult to make a decision. The service and atmosphere was wonderful. I had the watermelon salad and grouper ( both to die for). My husband had the soft shell crab ( also very good). Do not leave Boca Grande without having lunch at The Temp. The bar is fun also. Dinner looked a bit pricey. read more

Temptation Restaurant - Delicious lunch at The Temp. - Seafood Near Me - Boca Grande, Florida

Day 1 of our vacation. We arrived at 8:40pm. They close at 9pm. They still accomadated us. We ordered the Garlic Clams, Ceasar Salad, Stuffed Shrimp, Kids Fettuccini Alfredo. $64.66. $$ We finished everything! Our server was attentive to have our water refilled. Customer service was excellent! When we left, the the owner gave us a map of the city. We would eat here again. read more

Temptation Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Boca Grande, Florida