Let's review the Sweet Jody, out of Destin, FL, or as my crew fondly dubbed it, the "Vomit Comet" June 2014.
The good- The Captain did call the night prior and warn it would be a bumpy day- 1-3 foot swell. (+)
On this day lots of wildlife, 4 sea turtles spotted, lots of dolphin who put on a show after they cleaned all your fish off your line- that's fishing. Dolphins like Snapper too:) Lots of flying fish. (+)
Deck hands were so -so, not the worst I have seen and certainly not the best.
What I did not like; and as a local, pretty upset about. The best place to fish and most stable on a head boat is the back quadrants of the boat. these spots were unavailable due to the 4 quasi-Deckhands who claimed them before anyone hit the boat. I say quasi because these guys fished the whole day then were begging for tips and they were not the two "Deck Hands" on the charter. Now they could have been regulars and probably were, but they got treatment and demanded treatment not available to all.
My next tidbit is the deckhands and helpers trolled going out to the fishing grounds and when they slayed a Bonita or undersized king fish, they reeled them in, did not hand the rig to a kid who would have loved the experience. The reason they gave is to get some good grouper bait, while this is very good grouper bait, make no mistake none of it ever hit a paying customer's rod. The other excuse we got for not letting a kid reel one in was that we did not want to "slow down" the boat getting out to the fishing, but we stopped FOUR TIMES on the way out to let the deck hands reel in fish. So if we are stopping let a tourist kid reel the fish in- it would make his or her day.
By the 3rd Bonita slaying stop we had about 1/3 to 1/2 half the boat hugging the rail calling on Ralph, Pontiyak, and Buuuik! No big deal, this is a tourist head boat right? We did appreciate all the free chum and buddy we saw a lot! Our two yellow shirted adults (our favorite hurlers) threw up in the trash can, the cabin, the deck, and FINALLY made the rail - Yeah!
The Captain did a good job for the 48 total minutes we got to fish, it was bumpy and hard to hold the boat over the spot. Good job CAP! And I do mean that - been there done it - it is hard to do.
My take on this is we only found good fish once (first hole) and pulled off after 11 minutes. By good fish I mean more than 5 people of 40 caught a keeper fish on the drop. After that pretty much down-hill. It was hit or miss on the next couple of spots with one or two Red Snapper coming in and that was it , we headed in.
My favorite part of the trip - Last hole of the day- young lad hooks what he thinks is a monster grouper, it was bending his rod double and our larger deck hand, (Over 200 lbs) quickly took the rod away and a titanic battle ensured, after a minute and my 25 years of Destin fishing, I realized a) he had a wreck hooked, or b) he had the bottom of the boat, or c) It was not a fish! The Caps wife assured all close it was a monster fish, I think not says I! I walked to the back of the boat and what did I see? One of the quasi-deckhands was also in a titanic struggle with a denizen of the deep! At one glance the story was apparent-as one of the 200 lb men would reel down hard, and raise the rod; at the other end of the boat, quasi-deckhand would nearly be pulled over board! After my crew laughed itself so hard WE almost hurled I manged to gasp out "You mighty Quinns have each other you knuckle heads" at which point one yelled to the other "I think you have me hooked". THAT epic sweaty and furious 5 min battle was our highlight reel for the day.
Tipping- a locals take, if the deck hand does a good job - by all means take care of him, they hustle and they do keep you safe, they do clean your fish. So do the right thing. That is how they get paid. Don't be cheap.
If, however, he is a hungover, surly, not friendly or not helpful deck hand - you have no obligation to tip.
My take on Head Boats, you are getting what you pay for, the cheapest, entry level deep sea fishing trip available designed for the out of town tourist. If you don't know if you will like it or if you will get sick, for your first time, not a bad deal.
If you do get sick - too bad; the Cap will not turn around and take you back- The other paying customers might chunk him overboard. So if you get sick you are stuck the entire trip. You might think your dying, and that is sad but you ARE NOT coming back in until the trip is over! Plead, beg, cajole, cry - baby you are there.
My recommendation- If you really want to fish deep sea and have a really good chance on a big fish, (Grouper, Snapper, Trigger, Amber jack, Scamp, Wahoo) save your trophy money and charter a boat like the Back Lash or, Reel-Em In. I have fished both with out of town family and never have had a bad trip, expensive yes, but you will have a lot better time, catch more and bigger fish, providing you have sea legs. read more