Ixnay on the Yelp-a, it's time for the ol' trusty default three star Yelp gas station check list!…read more Good price? Who knows because it's been a bit. The first time we ever experienced this Rutter's it was back in March on the way to Gettysburg. We've stopped two more times since then and the price is usually higher than what I pay locally at home so blech on this one. Did I trip over any random tire shards, radiator parts or left behind wing nuts? No, everything was nice and gas station clean! Easy on/off to the highway/road of my choosing? Check, as the off/on Route 15 isn't bad at all. Human intervention needed? No!!! Three star gas station bliss almost a no on this one but what the hell, yep!

The service here is always quick. The store is clean! For gas station coffee, the coffee is good…read morewith a wide variety of choices, offering different creamers and even caffeine shots to add in! The help is friendly, I've always had good service here.

The black chicks that work there are obviously racist. I've never felt more not welcome somewhere…read more It's a gas station. Basic manners shouldn't be difficult considering time spent in the store plus time spent actually completing the purchase is an average of less than 5 minutes. If they can't even at least fake tolerate customers at the very least, it's a huge problem. I realize the climate in the country has could be better when it comes to race relations but this is ridiculous. It's every single time! Last time I was at this location I asked for directions because there was a construction detour on the same block as the speedway and the girl rudely said " I don't know the area" ok... you don't know how to get home from the gas station you work at? I was still polite and said " thanks anyway" then she left my stuff on the counter and walked away. I asked for a bag and she laid it on top of the Red Bull I bought and walked away, leaving me to reach across the counter to get it myself. Today when I was there, I saw a different employee working and I said " good morning " like I normally would and she said nothing at all. Then she rang the stuff up and stood there. I asked if it was ready for tap pay and she rudely pointed at the credit card screen and still said nothing. I paid and said "have a good day" and she still said nothing! This employee actually went through the entire process without saying a single word! It's honestly unacceptable. She smiled and interacted with the black customers so I know it was personal even though we never met before. If you don't want to deal with white people then fine but maybe don't get a job in a place where there's majority white people. I've never felt less welcome and I'm just not going to go back. There's better service at sheetz.

the sodas are a good deal for a low prize any size soda, but a lot of times they are flat and don't…read moreget changed enough. the card to get free drinks is nice though.

For every four times i could come in here. At least two of them they'll make a mistake on their…read morefood orders. Today i ordered and asked for a sub not toasted. They toasted the heck out of it and rather than remake it first they use their food ordering screens, order it again and make me wait even though they screwed up. Get your act together sheetz. Your staff make almost as much as I do at my job. Your staff aint exactly proving they deserve the pay they get.

Love this place. So easy to order food your way. I had the steak salad and it was greatread more

Always a friendly staff. Good specialty drinks. What you see is what you get. If not tell them…read moreand they will make it right!

As far as Sheetz locations go, this is a pretty standard location. It's conveniently located off…read moreof Route 641 and features all the standard items Sheetz is known for (MTOs, great coffee, soda cave, etc). I ordered an iced coffee here not that long ago, but it was significantly more ice than coffee. When I reached out to Sheetz about it, they offered me free coffee and asked which location had done this so they could correct the mistake so it wouldn't happen again. I'm happy to say every coffee I've had from this location has been perfect ever since! Great location, friendly staff, highly recommended!

Nov. 2025 | Low Prices, High Marks…read more Customer service - 5 out of 5 Wait time - 5 out of 5 Cleanliness - 5 out of 5 Atmosphere - 5 out of 5 Food quality - 5 out of 5 First time at Rutter's since they're rare in my area. Think Sheetz, but better. Huge food selection, shockingly low prices. I went overboard on hotdogs (they all looked too good). See photos for reviews. Honorable mention to the men's restroom: easily one of the cleanest public bathrooms I've ever seen. I'll be back whenever I'm in the area.

Running low on fuel for the car and needing a lunch break, decided to stop in here…read more Gas you pay and full up. Inside the store: Bathroom are clean though might have to wait. Rows of snacks if you want and some phone accessories. Self-service kiosk to order order food and drinks. After ordering you bring the receipt to pay at the cashier then wait for your order to be made. I ordered: - bowl of chili - regular (not pictured) - small bowl that you can add cheese to it. I chose not to. It was satisfying. - churro fries with powdered sugar and cocoa powder. I wasn't expecting to fall in love with these and wish we ordered more. - Hazelnut Shake was the perfect combo to the fries. It wasn't sweet. - Egg Nog Shake is seasonal and has a bit of sweetness after taste. If you need a break this is a place to go.

Even after a complete remodel/renovation...the new staff can't seem to make MTO subs that are…read morephysically edible. A half sub with no extra condiments/addons should not look like a shotgun was used to apply the contents of said sub. What I received was an open faced MESS that I immediately returned. Get some training in there on how to make a normal sub.

Wrong orders, burnt food, missing food items when ordering , workers have no clue what they are…read moredoing , they are focused on distractions

Every single time I come in here everyone is always welcoming. Never had a problem. Love the…read moreupdates to the store as well.

My mother was verbally assaulted there by a man blocking the gas pumps. She did not have her phone…read moreon her and ran into the store for help. The cashier refused to call the police or demand that the man leave the premise. The aggressive man eventually did leave, but returned as my mother was fueling her vehicle and continued his abuse. Ultimately, my mother stopped fueling out of fear and left.