Cancel

Open app

Search

Sugarcreek Tavern

4.0 (2 reviews)
Open • 3:00 pm - 12:00 am (Next day)

Sugarcreek Tavern Photos

Recommended Reviews - Sugarcreek Tavern

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of Z P.
30
7
0

2 years ago

Tim the bartender is great. Go see him he has stories and has been there forever. Beer is cold and there is a bar dog

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

19 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 6
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Sugarcreek Tavern

Verify this business for free

People searched for Bars 162 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Angry Troll Brewing - Buffalo garlic wings and ranch wings with a side of celery/ carrots/ blue cheese.

Angry Troll Brewing

4.1(281 reviews)
13.8 mi
•$$

This place is huge! If you tell someone you are meeting them there, you better specify specifically…read morewhere, because there's an outdoor area, a downstairs indoor that is more like a pool hall, and multiple upstairs areas. Anyhow, I found myself here after a hot day of golf outside of town, and this was the perfect place to please everyone, get a cold drink, and something tasty to eat. Beverage wise, I was too dehydrated to jump into beer, so I just pounded a bunch of water while there. Food wise however, we had lots of tasty things. The hot chips app that comes drizzled with bbq sauce and ranch is better than it sounds, though I preferred the pickle chips for sure. To me, the star here were the wings. They were nice and large, plump with plenty of meat. I had a korean sauce and a hot honey sauce and thoroughly enjoyed all 10. Maybe even had a leftover drummy or two from some of my companions. Would come back here for more casual eats and drinks again!

Walked in on a Saturday afternoon. We were seated right away. The vibe was great and the decor was…read morespot on. The hostess and our waiter were very friendly and helpful. The draft list was only accessible by scanning the QR code. Not normally an issue for me but it was a little annoying since my cell service wasn't great in this area. I finally got it to pull up and asked for the Angry Troll PB Porter (I forget the name), the waiter asked if I wanted a sample first and I was so happy he did because it was not very peanut buttery to me. I decided to try a can of Docs: Pumpkin cider which ended up being a MUCH better choice for me. It was delicious. We started with some cheese curds as an appetizer. The kids split a kids cheese pizza (it comes with fries) and my bestie and I split a Philly Cheesesteak pizza. The cheese curds were amazing! I didn't try the kids pizza although the fries seemed a little over seasoned, especially since they were served to kids. My Philly pizza was not great though. The primary taste was banana peppers. Not meat, not cheese...the vinegar-y, sour taste of banana peppers. I was not a fan. Then the bill comes....I guess I should have asked for the price of the cider (NONE of the beer has a price listed.) My CAN of Doc's cider was $9.50. Not sure if that's normal in this area but in Durham, that can would have only been $6 (MAYBE $7.) TLDR; service - good, drinks - expensive, food - hit or miss.

Photos
Angry Troll Brewing - Inside upstairs

Inside upstairs

Angry Troll Brewing
Angry Troll Brewing - Downstairs

See all

Downstairs

The Depot Restaurant at Cody Creek

The Depot Restaurant at Cody Creek

3.5(152 reviews)
2.8 mi
•$$

The 6 of us dined at Cody Creek and had a good experience! The food was great and service was solid…read moreas well! There were a ton of people at this restaurant - the parking lot was massive and we STILL had to park in the grass!! And people have good taste! Like what I said, the food was great! The restaurant is also large. We had to wait about 25 minutes, but that wasn't too bad. We got seated and service was a little slow, but that was ok because of the 'rush hour traffic' going on at the restaurant. Once our server did get to us, she was great! We got the bloomin' onion as an appetizer. YES, they have a bloomin' onion. We love those things, and had to get one. Theirs is pretty good! The sauce is pretty close to Outbacks, and is not too greasy. I was surprised at how tender their Filet Mignon was. It was great! The sweet potato casserole is like a dessert (so good)!! And Mac and cheese is pretty ok as well. They gave us a ticket at the end of our meal for free ice cream for all 6 of us!! (Of course we had to use it since it's free). They have a shop to the left tucked away from the restaurant, with ice cream, shirts, a parrot, and many old timey merchandise! The blueberry cheesecake ice cream had good flavor, and had good texture! Not too icy. If you're in the area, come dine at Cody Creek! You will enjoy your experience.

Fun atmosphere, good service and delicious food! The prices are very reasonable and the portions…read moreare big. Expect to wait if you do not have a reservation. There is also an on site gift shop that sells ice cream and the ice cream is free on Saturdays! One of my personal favorite things about this restaurant is the Republican decor.

Photos
The Depot Restaurant at Cody Creek
The Depot Restaurant at Cody Creek - Fried catfish

Fried catfish

The Depot Restaurant at Cody Creek

See all

Margarita's Mexican Cuisine & Bar - Tacos Al Pastor

Margarita's Mexican Cuisine & Bar

4.2(43 reviews)
13.5 mi

We traveled across country from Southern California, and we were craving Mexican food. I didn't…read moreknow what to expect in North Carolina. To my surprise, the food was great! We had carnitas street tacos, rice, beans, guacamole, and flan. The tortillas and chips are made at the restaurant and are amazing. The guacamole was excellent! The carnitas street tacos, beans and rice were perfect! The flan was the best that I have tasted. It is also made in-house. The ambience was good with Spanish music playing in the background. The staff were attentive and personable. Overall it was a great evening out. Would definitely eat here again when passing through the area.

We had no idea what to expect since we saw Margarita's was in a strip mall but it works! They are…read morein the corner so they have a nice little outdoor seating area as well. At first when we found out it was karaoke night (Friday) inside we were a little put off BUT when lots of Latins/Mexicans started arriving and the music inside started, I was lifted into a fun foreign country atmosphere instead of small town America! What a treat! GREAT food, GREAT service, fun drinks, very reasonable prices....not your run of the mill Mexican food or ambiance. Highly recommend the Shrimp Ceviche, probably one of the best I've ever had - would include an order of rice with that. We also had the single Chile Relleno with meat sauce, $6 and nice portion, excellent taste and value! Absolutely worth every penny.

Photos
Margarita's Mexican Cuisine & Bar - Seafood Menu Item

Seafood Menu Item

Margarita's Mexican Cuisine & Bar - Seafood platter

Seafood platter

Margarita's Mexican Cuisine & Bar - Outdoor patio seating area

See all

Outdoor patio seating area

Sugarcreek Tavern - bars - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...