Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Sugar 'n' Spice Cakery

    1.0 (1 review)
    Open Open 24 hours

    Sugar 'n' Spice Cakery Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Sugar 'n' Spice Cakery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Sugar 'n' Spice Cakery

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Custom Cakes 245 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Bakers of Buffington

    Bakers of Buffington

    3.7
    (94 reviews)
    0.1 km
    $$

    Baker's of Buffinton made the cake for our daughter's wedding celebration. It was magnificent!…read more They absolutely brought our vision to life and it was delicious too. Thank you!!!!

    Gotta say, I've had wildly mixed experiences with BoB over the years. From snotty counter help to…read morecakes not designed as discussed. This last experience, well, it takes the cake. I was gifted a birthday cake and the first piece ticked a lot of positive boxes, but left something in my mouth. Literally. It was almost the consistency of shredded coconut and I dismissed it as such because I didn't order the cake so wasn't sure what the person who had ordered it had asked for. The second piece, same thing - only this time I noticed I couldn't really bite through whatever the mystery shavings were. I've been baking for over 40 years and as I considered what "whatever" it was could've been, it wasn't the right consistency for coconut. I managed to pull a bit of it off my tongue and the only thing I could liken it to in my years of baking was when I accidentally shredded part of a rubber spatula and it ended up in the cake. I was able to track it down to the frosting. Specifically the blue. I scraped all the blue frosting off and tried a small piece and no more mystery matter. I plopped all the blue frosting that was left, which was mostly a set of frosting balloons, in the sink drain. I first ran hot water over it and this was what was left.The attached image shows what is left - after having used the sink for FOUR DAYS. It still hasn't broken down. If it were butter and powdered sugar it would've been gone long ago. I don't know what that was/is, but I don't see myself eating another one of their cakes anytime soon.

    Photos
    Bakers of Buffington
    Bakers of Buffington
    Bakers of Buffington

    See all

    The Creamery At The Farmhouse

    The Creamery At The Farmhouse

    3.1
    (17 reviews)
    0.6 km

    No clue why reviews are so negative, the ice cream is great and it's such a cute place, and the…read moreservice we received on a Friday night was so friendly and quick! We stopped in after dinner and I tried a double with two flavors - strawberry and peanut butter swirl. The ice cream is from Basset's and it's delicious! I found the ambiance of the shop and the outdoor patio to be extremely cute and homey, it's very inviting for sitting down and enjoying a cool treat! I look forward to visiting again and having some more great ice cream!

    I went here a couple times when they first opened and was moderately happy. Never walked away…read morethrilled mostly because of the higher prices compared to other local spots and the length of time it takes to get our order. I love supporting local, so much so that we went here again a week ago to see if anything changed. Sad to report, nothing has changed. The high prices are okay. I get it, everything is expensive nowadays. But the sheer amount of time it takes from the time you walk in the door until you get your order is astonishing. On our last trip, we ordered three items. Arrived at 8:25 and got served after 9:00; after they officially closed for the night. When served our three items, two were wrong and had to be redone. Hopefully things change because there is true potential here. Maybe we'll try again in 2024.

    Photos
    Double scoop of strawberry cheesecake in a cup
    Double scoop of strawberry cheesecake in a cup
    The creamery menu
    The creamery menu
    Chocolate waffle cone!

    See all

    Chocolate waffle cone!

    Sugar 'n' Spice Cakery - customcakes - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...