Service was kind. Easy to access with lots of seating available. Walk up windows. The ice cream was…read morejust ok; I wasn't wowed by it. My cone was kind of sloppily made. I wish they had more soft serve options or maybe even a flavor burst option. I didn't try the hard ice cream but they did have quite a few flavors.

Service is great. I think that they have changed ice cream brands-my soft serve cone was fine but…read moreheavier and a little less flavorful than the Perry brand they've had in recent years. But it's still really good and I'll be back!

Great food! Highly recommend the bbq -- food was fresh and bbq sauce DELICIOUS! Good variety of…read morebeers and drinks, as well as ice cream. Excellent service and covered outdoor seating options. Definitely recommend!

Beautiful outdoor setting close to Dreams Park! A great spot for wiffle ball and outdoor fun with…read morefamily and teammates! Unfortunately, the food was just ok and super overpriced. I was happy to get the Mexican salad but adding chicken costs $6 and you get maybe 2oz of chicken. The best thing on the menu was the nachos!

One thing that immediately stood out was how confusing the ordering process was. Like most ice…read morecream stands, there are menu boards posted outside, so we naturally assumed we would order from those. Instead, the family in front of us was handed a separate paper menu from inside. We had no idea that was how ordering worked, so I had to excuse myself past the people in line just to ask for one. It would have been much more customer-friendly if menus were readily available or if there was a sign letting customers know to ask for one. I was very disappointed with my visit. I ordered a hard vanilla ice cream sundae with fudge, peanut butter, and marshmallow, and it was nowhere near worth the $9 I paid. The vanilla ice cream tasted freezer-burned, with a dry, icy texture and a noticeable "crunch" that wasn't from nuts or any toppings, but from the ice crystals in the ice cream itself. It had a stale taste, and the texture made it seem like it had been sitting in the freezer too long. On top of that, there were barely any toppings. The fudge, peanut butter, and marshmallow were so sparse that I honestly wouldn't even consider it a real sundae. For the price, I expected fresh ice cream and generous toppings. Instead, I got what felt like a cup of old ice cream with just a small amount of topping. I don't mind paying premium prices when the quality matches, but this experience was very disappointing, and I wouldn't order it again. Also, there was an older gentleman wearing suspenders who appeared to be the owner or manager. While I was waiting for my order, I watched him speaking to the young employees in a way that came across as rude and dismissive. I obviously don't know what was going on behind the scenes, but from a customer's perspective it was uncomfortable to watch and created an unwelcoming atmosphere. The way employees are treated says a lot about a business, and unfortunately it left a negative impression on me.

Huge ice cream for the price, good quality, we will return when we are in the area. Open on a rainy…read moreday in early May, no food available yet

A wonderful store with many different items, including souvenirs, candy and syrup, and chocolate…read moretruffles as well. Many unique items for sale in this store. I found maple syrup in a cool jar, and some delicious chocolate too. Definitely recommend to check this store out while in downtown Cooperstown.

The best candy anyplace Fresh candy, excellent old fashioned…read morefriendly service Can have your own box assortment of as many as you like A great place for one of a kind gifts that will be rememberd Bottom line Will be back Carl L

Wemple & Edick's is truly a destination in the middle of God-only-knows-where (seriously, I had no…read moreidea it was in Fonda until I looked it up online!) but it is so worth the trip from anywhere within a 30 mile radius! This is your archetypal "old tyme" country store where you can get delicious homemade cookies, penny candies, and some of the best ice cream anywhere. They offer flavors like lemon, pumpkin, and D2P5 (chocolate ice cream with peanut butter cups, cookie dough & chocolate chip) that are creative but not totally off the wall and appeal to folks of all ages. The drive out here is beautiful, especially right before sunset, which adds to the overall experience. I would highly recommend seeking this place out if you have any reason at all to be in the area.

Everything about this story brings up such great memories. From the oldies & disco music to the…read moredelicious ice cream and baked good it is all the best. The staff is always pleasant and has the best service with a smile.

5/21/26-love their Reeses Vanilla frisbee Place is very…read moreclean, great help, good service Obviously well run A real Destination ice cream stop Will be back Carl L

Best food best service eat inside or outside very clean my favorite place to eat Can't wait until…read morespring when they reopen

Such an adorable place! We loved the vibe and the service! Amazing selections of ice cream…read moreflavors. So glad we came here after a late game at Cooperstown Dreams Park.

I came here the other day with my family, and when we went it was pretty great, so we came back …read more The service was friendly unlike what i've read in many of the reviews Also the serving sizes are crazyyy! But not crazy small, crazy big! I loved that we got what we paid for and it was pretty great tasting too.

What a charming side window spot with Perry's ice cream and excellent soft serve options! Fast,…read morekind service and great prices. Highly recommend.

Great prices and great ice cream, with tons of options! Great spot to stop by to grab a sweet treat.read more

We love Granny's! Every time we come, there are new special sundaes, and everyone always has a…read moregreat time here! We came August 21st for some ice cream (like always when we come up to the lake) at around 8:00 (it was a Friday) and there was a line. We waited for about 10-15 minutes, then ordered. Ice cream was great as always, I got the Dirt Cup with chocolate ice cream and it was great! Thanks for reading, -A

Delicious ice cream, generous amount, reasonable price and friendly staff. Open till 9:00 pm this…read moreyear 2026.

Excellent ice cream. I'd seen a recommendation for this place on a baseball thread in Reddit, of…read moreall places, & it was spot-on. Reasonable, good choice of flavors. I got the soft serve "twist," my friend got a hard flavor. We both said it was "as good as any other we've ever had" & we are both ice cream afficionados. Reasonably priced, good-sized portions. A bit hard to find as the address is Rt 28 but it's in the back. Nice array of pigs, chickens, ducks, a cow & several goats in the back. We're "city" people so enjoyed seeing the animals almost as much as we did eating the ice cream.

Cooperstown seems like the ice cream haven or something. As we drove here from my mom's we passed…read moreby like 6 places. I only wish we could have tried them all. I picked this as the 2nd place to try our following night after dinner. No one was disappointed. If you can only go to one ice cream place I'd go to this or the other one I went to if you look at my reviews :P