Like all thrift stores, it can be hit-or-miss whether you find anything. This store is attached to…read moreand shares a parking lot with a cafe. On a Friday afternoon, the cafe patrons took up almost the entire parking lot. We parked two doors down at the post office and walked back (there are no sidewalks on the side of the road). This shop is well laid out by category - women's, men's, home goods, shoes, accessories, etc. Everything was clearly tagged and almost everything seemed to be under $10. The store and the items were clean and in good condition, but the clothing styles were pretty outdated and mostly mall brands. This would be a great place if you're in town or nearby for a vacation and realize you forgot something like water shoes or wanted to quickly get a sweatshirt for a chilly night.

I'm staying on the Cape for a few months this winter and spring, and this is one of the few local…read moreshops that feeds my thrifting fix. Mid to high quality items displayed with care and priced incredibly well. It's also great that the store supports a good cause!

I was excited to visit Coffee With A Thrift and when I stopped by I absolutely loved it. They have…read morea huge variety of clothes for all ages, as well as toys, books, household decorations and more. I bought a few items and the prices were fantastic, you can get a lot without spending a lot. The owners are lovely, and are doing a lot to build community. They give to those in need as well, which is so nice to see. I look forward to going back soon!

Great prices and selection! Will be back. Owner was very pleasant and helpful. Easy to find and…read moreplenty of parking.

Always a great mix of goodies from clothing, shoes, accessories and home goods. Great prices…read more Size inclusive which is a bonus! Friendly staff and it's spotless and organized

Great place for thriftiness. Proceeds go to a good cause. Sad that they may be changing location.read more

A little pricey but not too bad. They have some really interesting and unique things in here. We…read morefound a stuff snake, snow pants, puzzle, clothes, and necklaces all at decent prices. The lady was very sweet and helpful. I'd definitely go back to check out new items that come in. It's definitely worth a look if you like thrift stores.

I can't believe I didn't review this store in 2017, when I bought:…read more 1) A lighthouse about 18 inches tall that has three shelves inside. Everyone who comes to my apartment asks about it. 12 dollars! 2) A charming pastoral scene in a frame. 12 or so also. 3) Old Pottery Barn candleholders (variable height) in blue. Popular years ago, sort of beaded. I just went in again and SCORED! 1) Needlepoint pillow with Santa Claus golfing. 2) Kitty earrings 3) GORGEOUS small wreath for the fireplace (brick/marble). I usually just put a ribbon up there but this is so much better. 4) Two little beaded bracelets 5) A hanging wooden sign: "A spoiled rotten kitty lives here!" When I buy a cottage upstate, I will come here. Great used furniture, lamps, and of course AMAZING Christmas everything. Laurie is great. 10 years in business. A woman with some valuable Yankee memorabilia tried to get her to buy. "I can't sell that here," she said. The woman (who became a major consigner) thought she meant that her conscience would not permit the sale of Yankee gear. She meant it literally, as in no one on the Cape would buy that s%*)! I love this store. Lots of trinkets and jewelry for very little money.

I've been 3 times. The woman who works in the shop is very sweet. I bought several hanging…read moreplanters and a Paddington bear. Had bought books on my prior visit. Worth checking out.

Not there anymore should've called before driving out…read more Mondays aren't days to shop thrift or consignment stores Too bad I have to leave the cape in a few days or I would look for more deals oh well

Great place to stop and browse if you are in the area. Lots of interesting items, good prices, and…read morefriendly service. The store is a lot bigger on the inside than it looks on the outside. More smaller items than large furniture pieces. Great selection of fish

This is a great store! I always find stuff here, sometimes one item other times a whole arm full!…read morealways reasonably price! do check it out!!

I got the most amazing items from here can't wait to go back! Well back again this time brought two…read morethrifters with me we can't wait! Florida can't compare to New England thrifts!

Consigning items system needs some work. I've stopped by at least 3 times to have them review my…read moreitems to be consigned. Due to their system of first come first serve I was told once that there were 12 people ahead of me. No respect for my time. They need to do a better job with some sort of consigning system or make appointments available. Blooming Resale in Cataumet has a very efficient system. Maybe follow them. By the third attempt I had had enough and donated all of my items including several brand new unused items to Mary's Closet. I will not be returning to Penny Lane Consignment...

Love this place to consign as well as purchase I spend all the money I make on consignment with…read morepurchases there always find good stuff

Always new stuff to browse. Lots of clothing, home decor…read moreand small furniture pieces.

Disappointing selection of very used overpriced goods, even on tag days. At best this is a once a…read moremonth stop for devoted thifters. The selection is not local goods, poor parking.

Poor over priced selection of very worn goods. Not worth…read moregoing out of your way to shop. A consistent disappointment no matter what you are after.

Great selection of size inclusive clothes. Shoes and accessories are also a great mix. Loads of…read morehousehold items The staff is friendly and helpful and the store is always clean and organized