Cancel

Open app

Search

St. John's Fish Exchange

4.0 (103 reviews)
PriceySeafood, Bars
Closed • 4:30 pm - 9:00 PM

St. John's Fish Exchange Photos

Business Info

ST. JOHN'S FISH EXCHANGE ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Touristy
Trendy
Romantic
Classy

You might also consider

More like St. John's Fish Exchange

Recommended Reviews - St. John's Fish Exchange

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Oysters
Jaz P.

(From June) The restaurant feels like family-style. The service was good and we got a good seat at the back where the ceiling-to-floor windows are so it was nice to look onto the water. The oysters were super good and fresh (obviously) and I liked the pickled onion they gave as well. The crab was alright. It was baked so it's harder to get the meat clean off and it was quite dry. I prefer it being boiled as you also get the juice from the meat. It was heavily seasoned (personally just like my crab plain). It was well worth it though with the side dish and the amount of crab you get. The chowder was good. I really liked it but it was quite small, even as a main course meal. The downside, I got an upset stomach and threw up later that night. (thankfully not food poisoning but still a bit turned off) I'm not sure if it was a bad oyster or the chowder but I shared the crab with my mom and no one had my chowder.

Crab Cake appetizer
Michael B.

I stopped here based on a local 's recommendation. I am So glad I listened. The Fish Exchange is the real deal! Great food, wonderful service and a great place to eat with great views. My waitress was friendly, knowledgeable of the menu, and always around when needed but not too much to be annoying "Perfect"!!!! The food is excellent. Prepared just right, presented with class, And seasoned to perfection. If you want GOOD seafood this is the place. It's on the pricey side but good seafood should be. I have ZERO complaints. Nothing but good things to say about this place!!! I'm so happy I stopped. Going back again tomorrow before I go back home!!

NL Seafood Cioppino
Scott K.

So this is our second time to the SJFX . This time was better than the last time. We were here this time in our last night of our trip and the restaurant did not disappoint. We were there on Saturday night and reservation is highly recommended. The wait for a table was about 45 min if you,were walking in that night. We were seated in the area that had a great view of the harbour our severe that night was Nick. He was amazing ( especially being a transplant from the west coast ). He was attentive had great suggestions. The food was great the oysters were delicious and the fish was fresh and very delicious. One of had the grilled Halibut, one had the Fishing Admirals feast ( which included Salmon, halibut, Cod shrimp and scallops), I had the NL Seafood Cioppino which was fantastic. Thank you to the staff for making this night best way to end out trip

Seafood scampi
Jacqueline B.

Great view of the harbour, friendly staff. Fantastic food. Fresh flavirful and plenty for leftovers

I think it is the lobster bisque
Janice Y.

This is a delayed review for my trip back in July. I had an amazing meal at St. John's Fish Exchange. When I was there it was busy and we had to add our names to the waitlist to be called back later but it was well worth the wait. From start to finish, all the dishes we had were great. The fish and chips are perfectly made and the lobster and shrimp pappardelle is absolutely yum. The cheesecake dessert we had was also a great way to finish our meal. Our server was also very personable and made sure we had a good time. Highly recommend for a seafood dinner at St John's.

Bacon wrapped halibut (made gluten free) with clam chowder and a "staycation" Ie pineapple margarita.
Marie S.

Just an absolutely outstanding restaurant. I highly recommend if you're in the area. Great food, drinks and service.

Shrimp and Lobster Papardelle- 4.5/5
Racquel S.

We went here to celebrate my birthday. Food- 4.5/5 I've had the shrimp and lobster papardelle, it was super good. Ambiance- 5/5 Service -4/5

fish exchange
Ewhan H.

The establishment is nice and clean, however, it is very busy. We ordered the Seafood duo and Tuna steak. The food was good, but the price tag heavy for what it was. Please note that the portion sizes were severely lacking. An issue we did have was the service. As the place was very busy, our server was not able to attend our table that often. Unfortunately I would not recommend this place to my friends from my personal experience.

Shrimp and crab pasta.

The food was amazing. The service was just as good. Great location and definitely will eat here again next time I visit.

Interior
Scott L.

Wonderfully friendly bar service gets 4 Stars!!! Allison is the best! Highly recommend the SJFE spin on an Old Fashioned and their wine list is excellent. Cod Cheek app hit the spot: perfectly battered and fried fish. The main, lobster Mac-n-cheese was a huge disappointment. Ordered because it looked great in front of another bar patron, mine looked like it was made in another restaurant?!? My dish took a LONG time to arrive. I suspect it sat under the heat lamp as the cheese dried up and pasta hardened well beyond the creamy, delectable dish I'd ordered

See all

Reviews are generally positive. People highlight the fresh seafood dishes, friendly attentive staff, and attractive harbour views. Cocktails are also well-liked.

Read the full review summary in the app

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Gets booked early on and bar service is a bit hit or miss. Food however is great and worth waiting for.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Great people, great food and great atmosphere. Special thanks to Brent for making the night special during our vacation in St. John's!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Brian E.
48
44
31

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

9 years ago

The food was really good, but expensive. The servers were all very friendly, but service was a bit slow at times.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of C B.
0
3
2

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Paige D.
657
19
18

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of les l.
1
104
50

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 3 of 3

St. John's Fish Exchange Reviews in Other Languages

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Portage

Portage

4.5(21 reviews)
0.8 km

Portage was amazing. I loved the craft nature of their dishes, often using locally sourced (even…read morewild crafted) ingredients. The service is great and attentive here, happy to answer all questions and make off menu beverages. The ambiance is a bit tight and loud unfortunately but the dining experience is still remarkable because of the creative food and excellent employees.

Located near the upper end of Water St just before it turns into offices, Portage's PoMo space is…read morein contrast to much of St John's historical downtown, but it's a refreshing vibe that still feels inviting and relaxed. The menu is on the larger side for a place of Portage's caliber and reputation, with several snack-sized starters and veggie-based dishes, and a leaner variety of proteins and desserts on offer. You know you're likely in for an excellent meal when it's hard to choose what to get, but after some deliberation, my wife and I landed on a handful - smoked olives, the cleverly-named Tongue and Cheek, Brussels sprouts, broccoli, cauliflower souvlaki, and fingerling potatoes. Note that you can conveniently get half-sized portions of most dishes, although we, somewhat greedily, did not. Unsurprisingly, the smoked olives arrived right out of the gate. The plump green olives came as advertised and while you wouldn't know it from looking at them, tasted more like smoke than olive - and I was all for it! I'm slowly converting to olives, although it's generally only at nicer restaurants and not the olives that come out of obscenely large buckets/cans that get slopped on mediocre pizzas and salads. The cauliflower souvlaki started off our string of excellent veggie dishes. I wasn't sure what the portioning or presentation would be like for these, but they were all a generous size for two people to share, and while they were plated with consideration, it wasn't so much "haute cuisine" as it was "piles of delicious food with complementary garnishes". I was a bit surprised that the cauliflower was served at room temperature, but the charred cruciferous veg still packed a lot of flavour into each tender-crisp bite. Paired up with pickled dates, yogurt, and fresh dill and mint, the dish hit a lot of notes - savoury, lightly sweet, and tart and bright vegetal freshness. On deck were the fingering potatoes. Loaded up with sauteed onions, scrunchion-esque bits of pork belly, and a blessedly-conservative amount of Dijon, this was a dish that harkens to a lot of continental European dishes. The execution of the relatively simple ingredients is where it stood out though, with firm-but-tender potatoes that had hints of sweetness and umami from their toppings, and the crisp bits of pork belly brought some textural contrast to this comfort food classic. The dishes were coming hard and fast at this point with the broccoli, Brussels sprouts and (cod) Tongue and Cheek showing up in quick succession. Brussels sprouts have become a family sight on contemporary restaurant menus in the past 15-ish years, and the crispy, charred veg got the Boomer parent treatment, although melted Cheez Whiz was replaced by a much more natural Mornay sauce. I'm not jaded enough yet by their ubiquity to bemoan the delicious execution of these sprouts, and the cheesy goodness of the Mornay mellowed out the sharper edges of this infamous vegetable. A surprise hit was the broccoli - with velvety smooth and lightly salty ricotta, fresh micro greens and a not-insubstantial punch of heat from chili crisp, our third cruciferous vegetable of the night took top honours of the three, IMO. The Tongue and Cheek is an amusingly tongue-in-cheek play on words, using two cuts of cod that have become local delicacies. Each was fried in a light and airy batter that was only slightly heavier than a proper tempura, with a perfectly generous amount of salt. The tongues were a bit more toothsome, but still tender, while the cheeks almost melted in your mouth. They're one of the more pricey starters, but absolutely worth it. After this sizeable feast, dessert was not on the table, figuratively or literally. Service was spot-on and friendly, without the almost clinical coldness that can come with the precision that some fine dining places have. Portage is understandably representing St John's on Canada's Top 100 list with its deliberate, but unpretentious menu that will leave you wanting more and loosening your belt at the same time.

Photos
Portage - Dining room

Dining room

Portage - Broccoli with ricotta and chili crisp

Broccoli with ricotta and chili crisp

Portage

See all

Rabble - Cod tongues (and cheek meet)

Rabble

4.7(9 reviews)
0.5 km

Top notch service here!…read more Charissa made me feel at home at the bar. I got fresh tasty oysters, the code tongues, and fries. The oysters were small but so refreshing. The cod tongues are a unique item in just had to try and they tasted really good. The fries came out hot but I would say they lacked the crunch I really enjoy.. I still found myself eating them all though. The fry sauces were great, I think all made in house. What I really loved was the homemade peri peri sauce with the oysters... I put it on my cod and fries.. game changer!!! The place is beautifully designed, small and quant, and a good place to hang out. The rotating drink special was a frozen Paloma which was nicely garnished and had a natural wheat straw. The chef gave me a nice little gift at the end of my meal which I appreciated greatly.

There weren't many places open late downtown for dinner, we went to two places prior to get food…read morebut the kitchen was pretty much closed. Luckily we made our way to Rabble, and they seated us at the bar immediately upon arrival. We were very happy to find that they were open late. I thought the decor and aesthetic was nice, cozy, and clean. I loved the dishware and houndstooth napkins. First, I got their blended Passionfruit Guava (?) mocktail. I'm pretty sure those were the flavors. It was citrus-y, sweet, and refreshing. We ended up ordering the Half Chicken, Brown Butter Turnip Papperdelle, and the Seasonal Parisian Gnocchi for 2. Everything was absolutely wonderful. The Half Chicken was flavorful and the juicy. And the skin was the best part! It had a beautiful crisp. The Brown Butter Turnip Papperdelle was nice, I was very impressed with how they made it "noodle" like. The texture was good, and I loved how it was under a mountain of parmigiano hehe. Lastly, the Seasonal Parisian Gnocchi was a hit. The gnocchi had the perfect texture, it was chewy and soaked up the sauce very well. And the sauce! It was creamy, savory, and just fantastic. I've actually been raving about this gnocchi to everyone, and it has stayed on my mind ever since we ate it. I think that was the best gnocchi I've ever tasted. The only reason why I gave it four stars was the wait time. We came a good 30ish minutes before the kitchen closed and I'm pretty sure we put in our orders with enough time. However we waited a lot longer than we anticipated. Nevertheless, we had a wonderful time. We actually visited St John's for our anniversary and celebrated it here for dinner, and this was a dinner and day we'll never forget. We'd love to come back for another anniversary, and I hope that the gnocchi will still be there haha. Thank you!

Photos
Rabble - Local oysters and the peri peri sauce

Local oysters and the peri peri sauce

Rabble - Half Chicken

Half Chicken

Rabble - Frozen Paloma

See all

Frozen Paloma

St. John's Fish Exchange - seafood - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...