The hangover burger hit the spot. 1/2 lb burger with bacon and egg. Fries are cooked in tallow…read moremaking it semi healthy. I would order this again. The Long Island ice tea was dangerous, tasted perfect. We were here with a group of nine and service was quick and thorough. Has the feel of a joint, but with lots of tv's with the games on display.

Excellent dining experience. Great bar & grill atmosphere, and the patio is sooo nice in the summer…read moretime. I can tell they clean very well, too. There's literally something for everyone here. I absolutely love the southwest salad and the burgers are so thick and juicy. The wait staff are very nice and attentive. I know one of them personally - Sydney is a very hard worker and does a fantastic job all around. Godfrey's really is a perfect representation of the charming community of Ottumwa. Always a treat to visit!

Wednesday 04 march 2026 Noonish…read moreYea hungry for salad So off to bench warmers for noon snack Pretty busy! That is kinda a good thing at least folks are out for a good meal All of the good stuff on the salad bar Wednesday is wing day I forgot to get any Couple of soups out and more on request They did make a personal standard crust crab ragoon small pizza for us.. Lol not the same crunch as the full size thin but I ate it anyway! Lol $15 total all you can eat out the door with tip. Yea I will try to update more on this place soon.

Food was hot and delicious. Homemade ranch. Service was amazing. Passion was a great sever!read more

Being the oldest bar in town, this place deserves a Legacy of Time award for being consistently…read moreawesome. If these walls could talk, they'd probably have some wild stories--and they'd all pair perfectly with a cold draft beer and great drinks Like stepping into a place where everybody either knows your name or pretends to because they're just that friendly. If you haven't been here yet, fix that. History, great food, and top-notch drinks--what more do you need?

First off I would give it 3.5 stars if I could. Very cool bar. Very historic. Menu is limited. I…read morewould stick with the smash burger. Didn't really dig the taco. Totino's pizza rolls is a nice twist. Place is more of a bar, with a bar vibe. We went for lunch so it was fine. Not sure what the night crowd would be like. Tons of TVs and pool tables and a shuffleboard game. Cool music playing too. Would come back for drinks for sure. Service was friendly.

You should go when the owner Steve P. is there. He's a funny, outgoing character! Food is good,…read moretypical bar food like burgers and Midwest style sandwiches. Bloody Mary is fun. Service is pleasant and fast. Place is kept clean. Can get crowded, loud and a bit drunk but is generally well controlled.

This place was unexpectedly AMAZING! My husband, son and I ate here for the first time ever for…read morelunch 3/24/24 and it was fantastic! For a bar and grill one never expects anything out of the ordinary. Just your regular service and bar food. However, we were immediately greeted with amazing energy and service! There was only one man to serve the bar and the sit down area to eat and he did beyond amazing. Even after we sat down and ordered drinks and then appetizers and food more people started coming in and he met them with the same amazing energy and service. He warned everyone he was alone behind the bar and to get orders and people still chose to stay and wait and I fully believe it was because of the man behind the bar and the amazing food! I would recommend this place to anyone looking for a bite to eat in a great atmosphere and energetic/ personable staff!

This is the bar restaurant inside of a bowling alley. On site parking available and dedicated…read moreseating with game machines and a full bar available. The food is great, large portions, the cheesecake is so good! The holiday cocktails are fantastic!! Service is always great but sometimes under staffed.

This bowling alley is so outdated, and the employees are rude, always on there phones, and not…read moremotivated. I took my family here for a night out and the whole experience was awful, the employees were complaining about how the owner is a B word, and that she doesn't know how to run a business in front of everybody! the other manager on duty was so high he couldn't keep his eyes open, his name was Brandon I think? the food is awful and took over 45 minutes to be made on a slow night it was only us and two other families, the bathrooms were nasty we saw roaches crawling around the bowling balls, it smelled like pee and there were drunk people causing issues with other bowlers. I don't recommend this place at all spend a little bit more money and go to a nicer bowling alley a bit further away, it's ran by a bunch of high young kids who don't care and a manager who thinks she's entitled because she owns a dump!

Located in downtown, parking can be a premium with a small limited lot and on street parking. Very…read moresmall bar area, small dining area, large patio / outdoor seating. The menu is small - sandwiches, burgers, apps, pizza. Bar menu is limited also. But the food was good. Our server was the right amount of attentive, but we were there on a Wednesday night with only a few tables. Worth a try!

Food was ok. Service was great. Cute little place. I would say the best thing is the cold beer and…read moreservice.

Out of towners spending the night in Centerville. We found the Pit and Pony on Yelp (thanks Yelp)…read more It is a very popular place paying homage to Centerville's past. There is good variety on the menu with very fair prices. They were busy so we chose to sit at the bar. At our request baseball was put on our nearby screens. It's a long narrow tavern that has been preserved very well. The clientele seemed like regulars and the waitstaff was excellent. This one's a five star place in its category. It's on an Attractive and fairly active town square with amble parking. Pictures were tough without disturbing other guests but it is definitely a pleasant environment.

Was in from out of town and looking for a place close to my hotel. Came across this place and gave…read moreit a shot. The atmosphere is nice. The staff was very friendly. Mollie in particular was very nice to talk to. I tried the Canary in the Cole Mine and it was DELICIOUS! Definitely recommend this place for dinner.

Fantastic pizza! A historic building with amazing wood work and a beautiful upstairs lounge.read more

Great bartender and friendly patrons! Fine respite on the way north to Mayo Clinic!…read moreBring cash!

One of my favorite sports bars with good service, food, location…read more I especially like the outside seating during the warm months.

Stopped by while traveling. Ordered a turkey melt with crisp bacon. What I got was one round very…read more small and thin piece of lunchmeat , one 3 inch piece of almost raw bacon and some sort of melted cheese on a marbled rye bread. It was pretty unbelievable that any "cook" would serve such an empty sandwich. It was more like two pieces of bread with the flavor of turkey but zero bacon flavor. Don't bother stopping, keep driving. No wonder at lunch, the place was not busy. Waitress kept trying to defend by saying that they have specific portions for sandwiches. Nope, not good enough. I'd rather eat at McDonalds.

Bartenders were super cool and fun the minute we walked in. Thought I'd have a chance to…read moreparticipate in karaoke but everything got shut down due to the owner throwing a fit. Seemed unprofessional, rude, and 100% will not be coming back. Unbelievable behavior from a grown woman. Screaming in everyone's face and a very nasty attitude. Visiting from out of town and will avoid this place at all costs next time. Really awful first impression and seems to be for locals only. Really still hoping that wasn't the owner behaving so belligerently. Yikes.

Great spot. Great staff. Karaoke is lit. You can find a decent game of pool or play some songs on…read morethe jukebox.