In town and was craving some NY style cheese pizza and it DID NOT disappoint! The kid behind the desk was nice and when I asked for two slice special, he made it fresh for me and it was awesome! Only two reasons (neither really bothered me) it doesn't get 5 is 1- kid was tossing the dough with no gloves or anything. Not sure how or if anyone does it that way these days, rather not see that:). If you're a gramophone, it may not be your thing. 2- It's kinda of a hole in the wall, not much seating (I think it had 2 small tables and 4 stools). Neither bothered me, pizza was awesome! read more

We got a medium Margarita pizza and it was the perfect amount for two hungry people, in my opinion. Lots of cheese, fresh basil and fresh tomato slices, with really good sauce. It was piping hot when we got it, no line and was ready in about 10 minutes. We were very happy with this pizza and I would definitely purchase again. I cannot imagine getting anything smaller than the medium unless it was 1 person happy with some leftovers, medium was the perfect size. Friendly service, casual ambiance. Overall, this was a random stop and would return! read more

Slices New York - Salad Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

This pizza place is very convenient if you are staying at Caribe Royale. It's very small location so take out is better. They have plenty of parking. We order veggie pizza however the taste was little off compared to other places. Behind the counter was very messy and not sure clean. They staff member was not very friendly. read more

Listen, sometimes you just need a no-nonsense pizza spot, and Slices New York gets the job done. Grabbed a pepperoni with pineapple (yeah, my wife is *that* person fight us lol) and a plain cheese slice. Both were exactly what you want from a NY-style joint: thin, foldable, with that perfect grease-to-sauce ratio. Pineapple was fresh, pepperoni had just enough crisp, and the cheese slice? Classic. No regrets. Didn't try the garlic knots (not my thing), but the vibe here is straight-up unpretentious counter service, zero frills, just solid pizza. Staff didn't hover, which I appreciated. Prices won't make you cry, especially for Orlando. Why not 5 stars? It's not gonna blow your mind, but it's damn reliable. Perfect for when you need a quick slice fix without overthinking it. read more

Slices New York - Salad Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

Alex provided outstanding service, because the pizzas we ordered were delicious, and he was pleasant, helpful, and culinarian. I suggest everyone goes to eat their food. read more

Just like NY pizza! They do not lie. While in Orlando have this pizza ! Small space but the food is amazing . read more

See all

I dont know where to start! This place was ran by kids and they were just hanging out. The main guy was helping costumers and making pizza without washing hands. I called him out and he goes sorry I'll put gloves and them helps a costumer with the gloves and makes more food.... Also not a dine in. DONT WASTE YOUR TIME!! read more

We walked across the street from the Caribe hotel to get a to go order for calzones. The order was prompt, correct and the pepperoni calzone and a meatball calzone were huge! They were very good and the my husband really liked the marinara sauces that were included too! read more

Slices New York - Calzones - Salad Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Strip mall restaurants scare me but this pizza dive was awesome! I wanted a small pizza but was talked into having a large. I am glad I got the large. I will eat some tomorrow as well! Excellent Pizza! read more

I have had better luck with frozen pizza out the box. Went there for my first time, ordered a small pizza, paid up front as required. I was never told that the oven wasn't up to temperature until 10 to 15 minutes later as I sat waiting. After some time got my pizza and drove home. The pizza was very soggy and stuck to the bottom of the box. Just ended up in the trash can! I feel that before they charged me for my order I should have been told the status of the oven, I would have gone elsewhere for lunch. I will never set foot in this place again!!!!! read more

Well that was a disappointment. Lackluster taste aside, it looks like they're having a shortage of toppings, because I ordered an XL Hawaiian that had maybe a dozen crumbs of pineapple and ham. And it's worth noting, of you order on your phone the default size is limited to XL only. I suppose it at least qualifies as "New York" style, but I'm rally only assuming based on other reviews. read more

Slices New York - What's in this photo? Certainly not toppings. - Salad Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Now this is exactly what I would call a hole in the wall as well as a perfect example of what you'd find in a good slice shop in the city as it's literally just a front door and a register inside along with a pizza kitchen doing things right! So one random rainy night it was all about some pie and what better place to grab some on the way home than this little spot as it was a quick in and out as we called ahead for our pizza and it was ready upon arriving! So we ordered a large pepperoni and onion pizza and let me say it didn't disappoint as it was very delicious from start to finish with a yummy sauce, crust, and toppings making for scrumptious at every bite! Overall there's not to much to go on here as it's just a chill spot to grab a pizza so with that said I'm sure I'll stop by here again at some point because it was just that yummy! read more

See all

This is a legit NY style pizza place. Currently Yelp rating is 3.8 but I think it should be much higher based on the DELICIOUS pizza I just devoured. Very limited seating so be aware. Not surprised it's so good as the cook told me he's from Queens NY. read more

Came here after a long day at Disney. We wanted something quick and yummy. I came across this pizza spot on Yelp and thought we could try it out. We pulled in and found the business quickly and ordered. We were told it be about a 20 minute wait which we were ok with. We ordered a small pepperoni pizza. The small was four slices and was just enough for the two of us. They had a small table inside that we were able to sit at and the cashier brought our food and napkins over to us which was really nice of him. We were pleasantly surprised by the pizza. It came out nice and crunchy yet chewy in the middle. I enjoyed our crispy the edges were and the cheese and pepperoni weren't too salty or too much. I'd love to come back and try the garlic knots next time! read more

Slices New York - Pepperoni Pizza - Salad Near Me - Orlando, Florida

We were out shopping and looking for a lunch spot and came across this pizza place. Said NY pizza so being from NY had to try it. The place is rather small with like one standup table , otherwise not really anywhere else to eat. Caught a special for 2 slices one topping and a drink for like 7 bucks. The server made us a pie as we needed two of the specials and had it out quick. Pizza wasn't bad. Crust could have been a bit more crispy but otherwise the rest of it was very good. And decent size as well. Worth a try for a decent slice at a good price. read more

Slices New York - Menu - Salad Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

Amazing service, I wasn't able to pay for the pizza so Sully let me cook up a few customers pizzas to make up for it. Great guy and great pizza. read more

The food was so good honestly, and the three boys working tonight were top tier on service at 10:20PM on 04/01/2026. They really made the whole restaurant look/feel like a family owned environment filled with joy and laughter. read more

The guy that answered the phone was unnecessarily rude. Made it seem like it was a problem for me to be ordering. I canceled my order and will not ordering ever again. Please work on customer service. read more

Food here is amazing with perfectly baked pie and a homemade sauce that is to die for. My buddy got a pizza roll filled with meat topped with garlic and Parmesan butter 10/10. The cook is nothing but good vibes, honest and respectable man. Would recommend ! read more

Slices New York - Delicious Medium cheese pizza - Salad Near Me - Orlando, Florida

I ordered a small pizza and a wedge salad. They gave me some random salad that I didn't order.... the pizza has a weird taste as well. Won't be coming back here. Was very upset about my salad. read more

Slices New York - Idk?? - Salad Near Me - Orlando, Florida

We put in a pick up order here like Dec of 23, and the pizza was pretty good. We're back and I'm ordering again. It's convenient because we are from out of town and like to get a few sodas at the CVS, grab some souvenirs at the shop next door, and then pick up pizza. Everything all in one place. read more

F**king joke this place! Ordered online via Grubhub app and receive a call that the restaurant notified Grubhub that I had picked up my order!! I'm visiting Disney World from Hawai'i and am staying at a hotel. I order pizza at like 2100 and pay $42ish which includes a $6.99 delivery fee through the Grubhub app. Why in the heck would the restaurant give my order to anyone! Maybe request an email confirmation from the person trying to pick up the order? Unless, the Grubhub delivery person picked it up and decided to consume the pizza pie themself?! Stay away!!!!!!!!! read more

Slices New York - Salad Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Amazing service! I ordered a half cheese half pepperoni pizza and at first they made the order wrong. I asked them to please fix it. They made a new one super quickly. They should add a little seasoning to the crust but the pizza was amazing and huge!!!!! We also ordered chicken wings which I believe they were Oven Roasted and absolutely delicious. First time coming and we'll definitely be back. read more

Bad customer service, I placed an order and cancel it immediately the worker has a bad attitude makes you feel unwanted

Ordered a pizza online. 2 hours later I don't have a pizza. So I called the number listed. Goes straight to voicemail. Don't buy anything from here, it's a scam. read more

The spot looks like hole in the wall. Very basic inside but right to the point. Service was good considering they made a fresh pie for my two slices. Taste was great, and good crunch on the crust. read more

See all

Ordered through UberEats and Slices forgot an entire pizza on my order and told me they didn't remember my order. They had so many orders they didn't know. Then they told me I could come pick up the missing pizza, but after I paid and tipped my driver 25%. The one pizza we did receive tasted horrible.. Also every app you try to order off of has a different menu for them. read more

Slices New York - Salad Near Me - Orlando, Florida

I ordered 2 pizzas and drove 30 minutes there. When I got there the guy goes. "Oh sorry I made a mistake" when I pulled up there were two workers sitting in from smoking. I won't be back. read more

I'm not sure what to make of this. After a long tiring trip, we were told this was the place that was still open. We ordered a few items on the menu especially awaiting of the pizza. The pizza has to be under the heat lamps because the sauce was no where to be found and the cheese was disintegrated. Then to my surprise was an added gratuity and service charge. What is that about? If you were closing soon you shouldn't have taken our order. read more

Slices New York - Dry cold soggy pizza - Salad Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Great place for some thin crust pizza. Just like home. Great team behind the counter, great customer service. Loved chatting with Hal. Would recommend heading over for a pie or a slice. Don't forget the cannolis! read more

Amazing Pizza, amazing garlic and herb crust and fresh ingredients. I asked for a custom pizza and they made it to my exact liking. Thank you!! read more

Here at Disney for a family vacation and we arrived in late last night and needed a quick and easy dinner. Ordered from Slices New York and we were so glad we did! Service was quick and the pizza was really tasty. NY style obviously and it had a nice chew to it without being thick or anything. The standout part of the meal were the garlic knots. Talk about amazing. They certainly didn't skimp on the garlic. Would easily come back here again. read more

The pizza was very mid, they charge $10.50 for two slices of pizza and then they secretly added a two dollar tip that I did not choose or select this place is a scam and the workers are scammers . read more

In Orlando and wanted pizza late at night. Found this place open until midnight when most places close by 11:00. It's just a small place, like you'd find in New York City. I ordered 2 pizzas, the vegetable pizza for me and another pepperoni with half sausage for my grandsons. This may be the best pizza I have ever had and the price for 2 18 inch pizzas was very affordable!!! Definitely the best pizza in Orlando and we'll be back every time we're in Orlando!!! read more

Has to be the best New York style pizza in the Orlando area I definitely recommend mostly a grab and go place but still nice !

This pizza place is 9min from where I was staying and because they do not Offer delivery I placed my order through Door Dash. The representative I spoke to by phone was very pleasant and apologized for not being able to provide delivery. But alas, the pizza also left a lot to be desired. Not sure I would recommend this spot for pizza, not even for a late night snack. read more

Slices New York - Cold, sloppy , 1/2 pepperoni 1/2 sausage and onion pizza - Salad Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Open at 12:55!!! I mean wow! We were starving!! Owner is super cool and kind and accommodating!! Do it!!!! read more

A hole in the wall kinda joint but hands down the best NY pizza in Orlando area. I'm from NY so I'm picky when it comes to pizza, the crust, crispiness and grease level were perfection (2 very important key factors for NY pizza). Great location and a must try! read more

Slices New York - Salad Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

This place is probably the worst pizza I've had in a long time... "don't ever disrespect New York with this pizza " Nems voice type s*** shoulda walked out when I saw the inside of the place. Pizza came out looking the same. Took two bites , in the trash. Should get a negative star for using new York's name. read more

Slices New York - Salad Near Me - Orlando, Florida

This was a door dash delivery that really detracted from the product Slices NY provided. Both the delivered pizza and meatball roll were disasters in a box. It looked like the entire order had been dropped on its side pushing everything into the corner. It's a shame, the food that was edible was pretty good and the marinara sauce was delicious. The pizza was missing the familiar NY pizza oil drip but the crust was good. I will order from the again but next time I'll pick it up myself. read more