Cancel

Open app

Search

Skinny Nate's BBQ

5.0 (1 review)

Skinny Nate's BBQ Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Skinny Nate's BBQ

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Skinny Nate's BBQ

Underdog BBQ

Underdog BBQ

3.5(188 reviews)
17.6 mi
•$$

Years ago we saw the show that centered around under dog bbq. Finally we made it here after our…read morelast visit to Erie when we found the location we went to was closed. Walking in I didn't get that bbq vibe right off the bat. Sure there were some sauces and ribs for sale but I was kind of left wondering if this was a bbq place. Our waiter / cook/ bartender had us seated in the wide open dining area and drinks moving in no time, we placed our food order shortly afterwards. The misses got the nachos, the chips were probably the best part of the dish, the queso was on the bland side and the chicken ... well some was tender and some really not so much. Kind of in impressed. The little yelper was down for her usual tenders, there was two large hand breaded tenders in the basket, and some fries. The tender breading wasn't a hit with her but that chicken was better than the nachos meat. After some peeling she ate it. The fries though, definitely could have used a little more time down, the weren't really crispy and had a hot sog to them. I got the smoked wings. Hellfire and rust belt. Of the two rubs the rust belt was the sweetest and overall best , but I'm a fan of spice and the hellfire was definitely the winner. The chicken wings had the same Kind of inconsistency . Some were perfectly cooked, others a bit dry. But their bleu cheese really was the standout for me. As a top wing reviewer in 2025 I've had a lot of wings and bleu cheese. This I would probably give a 7/10. Definitely saved the day with the wings. Underdog was a bit underwhelming but service really saved the day here. He was attentive, helpful And overall just great. The food however, definitely not what we had hoped for.

Best BBQ I've ever had!!!! Service was incredible and the atmosphere was welcoming and homey. The…read morebrand was clear and the pictures on the wall from the show really made it all feel like such a family and team effort. The history behind this place is inspiring and seeing it still owning its roots and going strong still feels great to support! Wish I was able to get a sweatshirt in my size but unfortunately when I went they no longer had mediums because they were getting a new screen printer. Anytime I'm in the area I WILL be back! The food is just too great to miss!!!!!!

Photos
Underdog BBQ - Brisket with mac and cheese

Brisket with mac and cheese

Underdog BBQ - Pulled pork nachos

Pulled pork nachos

Underdog BBQ

See all

Mortals Key Brewing Company - Smash Burger

Mortals Key Brewing Company

4.4(48 reviews)
27.0 mi
•$

A true and tasty delight! We make it a point to plan a day trip to this brewery - that's how good…read morethe beer is and how lovely the atmosphere is! Whether it's cold outside and you can cozy up inside of the incredible rustic yet architecturally rich environment and take in some bluegrass or roam outside among the sprawling areas, you're gonna be comfortable and enchanted. I've never tried a beer here that wasn't top notch. My hubby, who is an IPA enthusiast, was crazy over many of the IPAs, while I loved seeing a perfectly done Kolch on the menu, in addition to a great Pils and some darker favorites too. There is a modest yet deeply satisfying menu that includes a homemade pretzel shaped like the logo of the brewery along with pierogis and many burgers. If you sit outside it will be hard to resist the sandwiches which you can smell and watch cooking. The location is very convenient to Pymatuning State Park, especially the Jamestown facilities or Ohio/Andover facilities. It's a short and direct drive over to I-79 so this is a very accessible place if you're traveling from or between Erie and Pittsburgh. While I've not tried the adjoining winery yet it will be part of the itinerary next time, as it was equally inviting! I cannot wait to return. Highly recommend!

We actually ate at Gatehouse Winery which is part of the same business. We had a very nice…read moreexperience but my only complaint is that while we left the table to go dance to the band the staff cleaned off our table taking the rest of my husband's beer and the rest of the pizza we ordered. Not cool. We obviously were coming back as my husbands jacket and my purse were still there! My husband reported all this to the staff but they did nothing to compensate us for what we lost.

Photos
Mortals Key Brewing Company - Get a cool hat made by Bruce!

Get a cool hat made by Bruce!

Mortals Key Brewing Company - Beer pretzel, shaped like Mortal Key logo, served with incredible grain mustard and savory cheese sauce.

Beer pretzel, shaped like Mortal Key logo, served with incredible grain mustard and savory cheese sauce.

Mortals Key Brewing Company - Outdoor patio looking towards brewery and outdoor stage (one of many)!

See all

Outdoor patio looking towards brewery and outdoor stage (one of many)!

Skinny Nate's BBQ - bbq - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...