Beaver Bagel Company are great bagelers! I know, because I used to be bageler myself, also at a…read morebagel company whose name did not reflect their location, namely Pittsburgh Bagel Company in Meadville PA! My friend Nate and I made some mean bagels under the tutelage of Shirley! Anyways they have great bagels and great sandwich combinations!

I walked in there and I stood for 10 minutes and no one even looked at me. No one took my order and…read morefive other people were just looking at each other. Never again.

Firstly, I want to get something out of the way. I am a genuine New York City/New Jersey Bagel…read moresnob. My experience with Bagels hails back to the old H&H on the West Side of Manhattan on Broadway. They had a world-class shipping business which the owner squandered with drugs and tax evasion. What a pity. My second favorite place in New York is Best Bagels and Coffee in Hells kitchen. Fantastic. So here I find myself moving to the Pittsburgh area and wondering if these people know anything about Bagels. I visited a place called Pigeon Bagels. The lines were down the block on a Sunday morning for that place. The bagels were just ok. They were not super bagels like New York City. They were certainly not worth waiting a half an hour to get a dozen bagels that were just ok. So I had my son bring out five dozen bagels from New Jersey the other day. That'll hold me over. Doing my Bagel surveillance, I found out there was a place in Butler that claimed to have New Jersey bagels. This morning I checked it out with very little hope of believing the hype. I had an everything bagel with lox and cream cheese, onion, and tomato. My wife tried the blueberry bagel. To my utter surprise, the sandwich was really good! If you look at my other reviews, you'll see I can be brutal when it comes to reviewing Bagels. As someone who used to live in New Jersey and who used to frequent H&H bagels, having lived in Manhattan, this baby is the real deal. The real McCoy. The genuine article. You get my point. I'll be coming to Downtown Bagels often. The price for the individual bagels are on the high side by over a dollar, but the sandwich prices are very reasonable. I'm going to give this place two thumbs up.

I love this family's dedication to fresh tasty food. The menu is amazing, you can dine in or take…read moreout. It's all fresh so call early - sometimes they sell out

As someone from NYC, I don't hand out bagel compliments easily. Bagels are basically part of our…read morepersonality. So when I say Burgh's Bagels has the BEST bagels in Pittsburgh... trust me, that says a lot. I tried the Mother Clucker chicken sandwich and honestly? Best chicken sandwich I've had in Pittsburgh so far. Perfectly crispy, flavorful, and stacked just right. I also got the onion bagel with regular cream cheese and the jalapeño bagel with jalapeño cream cheese. And listen... I'm picky. I need more cream cheese than bagel They DELIVERED. Loaded perfectly, fresh, soft, and packed with flavor. What really made the experience stand out though was the people. The staff was super friendly and welcoming from the second we walked in, and the owner was incredibly easy to communicate with and genuinely appreciative of every customer. You can tell there's a lot of pride behind this place. This spot officially earned the NYC approval stamp from me.

Best bagels in Pittsburgh. Worth the excursion and drive! *…read moreYelp reviews require a min of 85 words.

incredible fresh soft quality bagels and excellent service, the kind actually deserving of a tip…read more can't understand why I'm not seeing multiple 5 star reviews on here

The only pro from my recent experience at this location was that the bagel sandwiches were…read moredelicious and the ingredients, including the bagel, all tasted fresh. The employees working behind the counter weren't friendly, there was a long line and wait for food, the dining area was small and there seemed to be an extreme shortage of chairs. There was one long table that should seat at least 8 and it had 3 chairs at it. Everything was worn down and could definitely use an upgrade.

I love this stop. The bagels are always super fresh and delicious. The service is also pretty…read morequick. I particularly love how the bagels aren't too big and they have a good cream cheese ratio. I got a marble bagel with fig and honey schmear which was delicious. I also got a tasty strawberry rugelach pastry. Parking can be tricky depending what time of day you go. There is a nice park down the street to sit and enjoy.

Pigeon Bagels, worth the hype? Worth the wait? Yep & yep…read more Did you know they've been nationally recognized by Food & Wine as well as Bon Appetit? Pretty amazing considering they've only had their brick and mortar since 2019. Who remembers getting their amazing bagels at the Bloomfield Saturday Market before the brick & mortar opened? ME! I lived down the street & looked forward to getting them. Who remembers them selling at the Squirrel Hill Farmers Market too? ME! I have spent enough time in NYC to really know bagels and Pigeon has been at the top of that game from the start. Proper bagels...boiled & hand-rolled! Faves: Everything bagel Plain bagel Veg bagel sandwich Jalapeno schmear Herb schmear *they have a different bagel flavor of the month Did you know everything they offer is certified kosher? Yep! Donut Day is the second Wednesday of the month. Coffee served is from Redhawk.

Took 30 minutes for 1 bagel sandwhich.... It was not just my…read moreorder, there were approx 15 people waiting just as long as me, all expressing their frustration to one another.

The sandwiches are carelessly made and the employees, mostly young kids, seem lost and without…read moreguidance from the franchisee or manager. Also, put meat on the sandwiches.

Always a positive experience at Jack's Diner for us. Comfort food and friendly service.read more

I have been all over these united states and have learned one axiom; do not judge a restaurant by…read moreits appearance. As has been the case in so many other experiences, sometimes the best food you have ever had comes from a diner attached to a gas station in the middle of nowhere. My wife and I were on our way to Star Lake for a concert and stopped in before for dinner. The interior screams home cooking but the menu was surprisingly complex and varied. I orderd the shrimp po'boy (an off menu special) and my wife the liver and onions. Both were phenomenal meals.

Love that this is a locally owned and operated shop! Pittsburgh's suburban neighborhoods are…read moredesperately begging for bagel shops. Out here in the North Hills, we've been stuck with chain options -- so when Three Brothers Bagels came to Shaler, it really helped fill a void. This place is a great destination for all kinds of bagels, bagel sandwiches, baked goods AND really, really good soup. My personal favorite so far has been the potato leek soup with bagel croutons. It was so good that I'd love to see it become a menu staple rather than just a special. As for the bagels themselves, the selection strikes a nice balance of savory and sweet, and the spreads and fillings follow suit. What I especially love is that the sandwiches go beyond just breakfast -- there are creative, lunch-style options that set them apart. And yes, their bagels are chewy and might give your jaw a workout after a whole sandwich, but honestly... isn't that just what a bagel is? Tip: Make sure you get there early or plan to order ahead this place is SO popular and regularly sells out. I'm also looking forward to seeing their food truck out and about. Highly recommend for anyone in the North Hills looking for quality bagels, sandwhiches, soups and some genuinely great baked goods!

Pretty solid bagel place, definitely one of the better ones in the Pittsburgh area!…read more They got a small shop, but they're definitely slinging a lot of product very quickly so get there earlier and prepare to wait a little bit too, but it's pretty worth it! The different types of bagels are good, Jalepeno cheddar could have a little more Jalepeno in it, but solid. The real highlight was the sausage egg and cheese, the sausage being freshly pressed and made in house really made it standout, definitely recommend! Overall, it's a real good spot for a bagel sandwich, plus they got coffee and some other treats that people were raving about, def will try next time!

I've only briefly been here in the summer to get ice cream, but I went this morning for breakfast…read moreand it was fantastic! The breakfast sandwich was HUGE and had thick cut bacon, fresh avocado, and was made to order. The donut was sweet and savory and the iced coffee was refreshing! I saw that they have coffee flights and a large array of lunch items as well. They even have an area with dog items (homemade donut treats, clothes, toys) and their patio is dog friendly! All in all, I will be a repeat customer and am so happy that I tried out this gem today!

Ordered a Herby Turkey Sandwich, a lemonade and 2 bagels with a side of turkey. Total price was…read more$28. Cashier would not show me the breakdown in costs before I paid. Avoid

Only about 3 seats open and the cashier wasn't the most personable, but the food came quick, it was…read moretasty, and can't really complain otherwise.