We stopped by here for lunch after taking the ferry. The lady at the counter was very professional. When we said it was our first time here, she gave us a generous sample plate of literally everything they had that day. The oxtail, chicken curry and jerk chicken were really good. Veggies and mac were solid, but didn't love the rice. I got the large oxtail plate ($25) which normally comes with rice and 2 more sides, but they let me pick any 3 sides so I got cabbage, green beans, and mac n cheese. The plate was served in a large takeout container and it was stuffed to the brim with everything. They don't skimp on the oxtail. It was tender, juicy, and had a good flavor. My partner ordered the chicken and waffles ($14) which unfortunately he didn't like as much. He said the chicken was tough and the waffle was just ok. But he liked the mac n cheese. But just FYI, the block is seedy, and there was a seedy character hanging out inside that the employee kicked out. read more

Service very friendly. Staff helpful. Ordered for pick up because Holland bay was listed temporarily closed . If I compare a large helping from SI fish for price and servings, theres no comparison. Holland bay is gracious with their oxtail and sauce and will give more of that than rice and peas or cabbage depending on your preference. Si fish portion is half what you could get at Holland bay. It also has the consistency of being a day old and lost its juices along the way unlike Holland bay . Mac and cheese was good and cabbage great. Rice and peas had the same feeling of sitting around for a bit. This could be my bad ordering at the end of a day. For 25$ you can get the freshest juiciest oxtail at Holland bay but if that's not an option I need to order from SI fish bright and early and in person to truly test the food. I wouldnt intentionally order oxtail from here again but I haven't tried their other dishes so I will be back to try other things. This is my first impression of the spot since they moved from montgomery ave and took off. Kool-aid is bangin. TbC read more

Si Fish & More - Oxtail - Soul Food Near Me - Staten Island, New York

I was in the mood for curry chicken do. I came here. I was hungry and excited to eat. I ordered the rice with peas and the curry chicken. It came to $12 and change for the smallest styrofoam container which are illegal in NYC . I got home and had a big bite with old rice. The rice was hard as if it was days old and the peas, the beans were all dried out and I had to remove them from my mouth. The chicken was ok but I got a piece of the chicken leg and it was just the bone with the cartilage at the top. Gross that she could even put that in my small container. The food i got was old. I will not be returning there. I will go to Golden crust in Brooklyn next time. read more

I decided on take out from Si Fish & More for dinner tonight and I'm glad I did. The restaurant is small but bright and clean. The lady at the counter was friendly and professional. The food was hot and delicious. I ordered the fried catfish and shrimp with fries. My husband had the fried catfish and sauteed shrimp with rice and peas. I will be back to try other dishes. read more

See all

Great atmosphere,staff is very friendly the food amazing, will be back as usual ,great ambience

Tasty Caribbean food at an affordable price. The interiors is inviting, and you can see everything youre ordering.

The food is delicious and the service is great and the ambiance is great too I do recommend this restaurant because they have a good menu selection,you won't be disappointed read more

My BIL loves on the Island and was so excited to bring us to this spot, and I totally understand why. First impression of the place is bright, airy, and clean. Service was extremely giving and friendly. Malik was so gracious to give us a sample of everything to help us first timers decide what to get. I will tell you that was hard, because everything was DELICIOUS.. from the oxtail, meatloaf, mac and cheese, yams, cabbage... my goodness. We decided on the fish and shrimp combo plate with mac and cheese and yams. The whiting and shrimp were perfectly seasoned.. the mac and cheese and yams were top of the line good. While you wait, you can get a drink from their fully stocked bar. I live in Jersey, but will definitely return! read more

I've ordered here a few times now with friends and all I can say is that this place doesn't miss and is one of the few gems on Staten Island. I usually get it delivered, at this point I have tried everything on menu and have complaints about nothing, well the only small issue for me is that the jerk chicken pieces are massive!! Lol The portions can probably be divided into two meals and they're flavorful, the sides are great too. I've never been to the actual location but when I do I can edit review based on experience. But for now keep being great! 4.5 stars read more

Great fish fry place. Mix menu a lot of different choices on the menu. My favorite is the fish.

I came here this past summer and loved the food actually adored it. Cool spot located not too far from the Staten Island ferry. They really did there thing with the food and service...the owner I believe or manager gave me a small sampler platter to try all the favorites. We fell in love with everything. One of the workers helped me so much she went above and beyond to make me feel comfortable. Because of the good deeds when I graduated from my parenting journey class, I highly referred the restaurant & the facilitator picked them to cater the event. I highly suggest all of these so yummy Stewed Chicken Curry Chicken 3 Pieces Fish and Chips Jerk Chicken Oxtails Green beans Salad Mac n Cheese The kool aid was kool aidin' Thank you for the experience can't wait to pop back in again read more

I abs love this place. I usually get macaroni pie, oxtail and rice and peas. I've tried the fried fish which wasn't bad at all. This place make sure you order ahead and give yourself some time to pick up the food it does take awhile. I haven't ate inside, always ordered it to go. However the new location has enough seating space so I'll be back and eat while there for sure. Prices are reasonable and staff was always friendly with me. read more

Staten Island sad to say is lacking a lot of Caribbean options. Some might say it's a desert. Those that take on the challenge must deliver in a way that's consistent to what you've had prior. What's wrong is how would you know you've had better? Such is this place. My sister who is a resident of this fine borough suggested this restaurant. I ordered a fish meal, and "Rasta" pasta. The Alfredo/ pasta sauce was thick. Clumped up nice on the way home. ‍ the chicken added was picked/ pulled possibly from chicken thighs or legs. And it was kinda salty. The fish meal was with macaroni and cheese. Again, just ordinary, the fish wasn't crunchy at all. It was chewy though and not in a good way. Overall I'm those on the island of Staten has become use to this place. I'll do my carribbean cuisine in Brooklyn or the Bronx. read more

The young lady who answers the phone is a customer service gem. Restaurants need more people like her. The food arrived, hot, fresh & delicious. I will order from them time and time again. read more

My second time ordering SI fish this month, the first time the food was amazing. Fresh fried fish with collard greens and Mac and cheese. Today Nov 26, 2024 I ordered 3 piece fish with cabbage, Mac and cheese, side of of yams and banana pudding. Returned home to eat and the fish was not fresh you could tell that it had been microwaved, the Mac and cheese was the corners and burnt pieces. That was it for me, can't eat from places that sometimes have good food. Not a meat eater only fish and veggies. read more

Prices are much higher than what's shown (2018 menu and 2021 menu with no changes). A $48 order came out to $70 and they said "there's nothing they can do about that." Meanwhile it's printed on the menu to "leave a good review on Yelp for a 10% discount." How are you going to direct people to Yelp while also claiming you have no control over what your customers see? They can literally add an updated menu at any time but I guess that would be bad for business. And maybe turn down the radio when taking orders over the phone instead of trying to scream over it? Guess they have no control over that as well. read more

Everytime I get food from here they never disappoint. The food is so freaking good. And I always eat all my food, no crumbs left. The customer service is pretty good. I know they are always busy because everytime I call I get put on hold and they never come back to the phone. Now the ambiance is really nice, very clean and neat. You can sit at the countertop/bar and have a drink while waiting for your food or you can sit eat and drink. I highly recommend this place to everyone in the world read more

The food is nasty especially the Mac and cheese , prices are ridiculous , and they only take Cash, which is a inconvenience to all people

Been thinking about this spot since my first visit and couldn't resist ordering again. The fried fish, fried shrimp, and bbq wings were all superb. The bbq wings were fried (maybe even double fried) but were crunchy and juicy. Also loved the bbq sauce. Mac and cheese is a must-try side! I wish I could order double Mac because it's just that good. For the price and quality, this place is unbeatable. Already looking forward to my next order. read more

See all

UPDATE , I was in the area so I passed by to pick up the bbq chicken with candid yams and Mac & cheese. It was so delicious and I haven't had this in forever but today was just the day ! Everything taste amazing and I will definitely be back for more ! read more

Si Fish & More - BBQ Chicken with mac and cheese and yams - Soul Food Near Me - Staten Island, New York

luna from boost mobile; id just like to say not only is the food good but this res is very inviting and welcoming; u feel like family for just walking in. great ambience great food. LOVE EM! read more

LISTEN TO MY FOOD POISONING STORY: The food was okay, oxtails were flavorful, but very skimpy on the portion. Mac and cheese was fine but it needed a little something extra. As far as the rice it was bland and needed flavor. The main reason I will never eat from this place again.... it gave me FOOD POISONING. The meal I got from SI fish was the only thing I ate that day and the following morning I've vomited for hours. I even filled a garbage bag with my vomit. read more

Moved to New location, always striving forward. I love, love love the Oxtails, White rice, Yams, Mac and Cheese. The Barbecue Shrimp is amazing. The Kool-aid's will make you Diabetic (As they Should). The staff is AWESOME, PLEASE REMEMBER TO TIP!.... read more

I ordered 2 fish sandwiches, whiting on white bread and whole wheat bread. I have no allergies to fish I eat whiting all the time. Unfortunately the fish was bland and rubbery. I spit out more than I ate. Next thing I know my face and my hands were itching, so I took a Benadryl to be on the safe side.i will never order any else from this business again. They should be ashame to charge people for this garbage. I had to sit here and pray, that I wouldn't have to go to the ER. read more

Quick and great meals close to my home Love have Caribbean food close to me Oxtail and jerk chicken on fire Like the cabbage and collard too read more

this food was very good awesome here chicken mac and cheese off the charts come here for authentic caribbean food Best on the Island !!! read more

Update: I went to the location on 04/272022. The place was immaculate! Clean, shiny and fresh. Hand sanitizer on every table. The manger had the place functioning on a dime. The food is always fresh and delicious. One of the best places on Staten Island. You won't be disappointed. read more

The only place on the island I can find that makes banana pudding. It's magically delicious! I could eat it for breakfast, lunch and dinner and if this place were closer to my house I probably would . I've been here about four times and I have yet to order a meal. I walk in , I bypass the food, order two banana puddings and I walk out. Who are you to judge me?!! read more

Si Fish & More - Banana Pudding.. Its magically delicious - Soul Food Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Had ox tail sweet potato mac and cheese green beans. The tastiest food. Delicious!! Customer service is good experience. read more

Everything is delicious and fresh and consistent I would recommend the fried chicken, jerk chicken, shrimp Rasta pasta , yams and macaroni salad read more

BEST SPOT ON THE ISLAND 5/5 quality and service always get the oxtails with max and cheese :)! read more

My favorite spot.. I am from Brooklyn! Its hard to get good food. They are great.: small spot with home made soul food.. read more

Si Fish & More - Sides!!! On point! - Soul Food Near Me - Staten Island, New York

They lack in giving good portions of food. I come here a lot. It is expensive being that I spent a lot of money on one plate I would expect to get a good portion of side to meat ratio. It seems like this is always a problem with them. They are very cheap when it comes to giving the meat. There food is alright I have to be very hungry and my last resort to get it. Like I said very expensive to not be giving good portions of meat and being cheap. Let's be honest who wants to eat more rice then meat. I order a small container of macaroni an ox tails and they gave me FOUR ox tails. Not worth it only if you are straving! read more

Si Fish & More - Lack giving correct portions of meat to sides! - Soul Food Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Found myself feigning for fish & chips. This place popped up on my radar. Placed an order for pick up. When I got there COVID measures were adhered. Felt good about that. Food was delicious & fresh. Gotta appreciate that. Second trip was collards & sweet potato. Yummy! Found my fish spot! read more

There food is amazing. It is small spot and not a dine in type of location. This is the main reason I've gain weight. I eat there all the time. The food is so good. I love how the food is season. It is rich with flavor. They have these cool-aid drinks and try really remind me of my childhood. They come in all colors and are so good. Everything in that place taste so good. read more

See all

There's always a line to get Island food from this hole in the wall and there's a very good reason for it. The food here is outstanding! I no longer live in Staten Island but whenever I am back I always stop here to get a large oxtail meal for myself and a fish meal for my mom. It's the highlight of our visit. Reminds us of our island roots, but it's much better than Nanny ever made. Check it out! read more

I love this spot. The fish is in the money!! However, their customer service needs work.

This is the best spot in Staten Island. The oxtail dinner with Macaroni and cheese plus string beans is the best! My family also enjoyed the curry chicken dinner. read more

One of the best restaurant in the area. We ordered 2pc jerk chicken with collard greens and macaroni salad and we were literally sucking our fingers. I'm definitely coming back again.Jerk Chicken read more

Absolutely love this restaurant! They always prepare my order to perfection and it always tastes amazing. My favorite is the salmon with their mac and cheese. Jerk chicken and bbq wings are also really good! My go to spot on the island for some good soul food! read more