The shop is a converted house with separate rooms where each barber works. A comfortable, eclectic…read moresetting. These are skilled, experienced barbers that will give you a better than average cut. This crew takes the time to do it right. The clientele tends to be repeat customers; new customers become repeat customers. Appointments are required and in general, they are booked out a week, sometimes more. Covid protocols are excellent. This shop does not employ first time barbers, like others in town. It is impossible to get "butchered" here. I have tried many shops in York, Lancaster, Lebanon and Hershey. This shop is better than the rest and equal to only one of them. A solid four star cut that's one star short of absolute perfection. Recommended.

Way too much talking going on, and not enough cutting. I just sat there for 40 minutes, and there…read morewas a guy in the chair getting cut who pretty much looks the same as when I left because the kid cutting the hair could not cut and talk at the same time. There was another barber out front who did three clients to his one. I would've gotten stuck with the talker and I didn't have another hour to spend getting a 15 minute cut in between an hour of rambling, so I left without a haircut.

Great cuts. FRIENDLY service. Good with clients of all ages. Busy, but you never wait very long…read more Highly recommend.

The staff is second to none. More like family. My haircut is always perfect and I could not ask for…read moremore. Highly recommended.

Always my choice when I need a haircut. I've had my haircut by several different barbers here and…read morehave never been disappointed.

I got a great haircut. Scheduled online which was very easy. Great service and an easy to get to…read morelocation. I'll be back.

Just moved from Chicago looking for a barber. I went today and saw Gary from Gary and Joel's…read moreBarber. My appointment was at 2pm. I got in promptly and Gary got to work transforming my grizzly Adam's beard into excellent example of what a beard should look like. He was an interesting person to speak with and a great barber. The cost for the trim was super reasonable. I got the wife seal of approval.I will be going back often. No more Grizzly Adam's for me. I highly recommend Gary and Joel's Barber Shop .

Always friendly and professional. Shelly knows what she is doing, and she is pretty fast so don't…read moreworry about being behind several people. She will be to you in no time.

It's always nerve-wracking looking for a good local service provider in a small town--there isn't…read moremuch in the way of online reviews for the four barber shops in Mount Joy. I decided to avoid the one shop that did have a single, solitary, negative review on Google (Snyder's), but as I was driving back and forth down Main Street looking for the one other shop I thought I'd seen before, I kept passing Snyder's. In frustration, I turned left on a side street to make a U-turn, and lo and behold I saw *this* little gem of a shop, Shelly's, tucker away between a couple of houses. First thing I noticed upon entering was how clean and tidy the place was. It looked very comfortable and welcoming, with plenty of room (unlike some barber shops). The shop was empty as I entered - something the owner mentioned was not usual for a Friday afternoon - and so the gentleman beckoned me to the chair right away with the words, "Let's get you comfortable and then we can talk about what you'd like." The sense I got from this barber was of small-town warmth combined with truly professional skill. We briefly talked about what length would look good on me, and he said he'd go light to start out (he could always take more off) and do it on just a part of my head so I could see the effect. I appreciated that touch - with most barbers, you tell them your best guess and they go to town, and if you don't like it, too bad. We ultimately decided to go shorter, and after he'd done a once-over of my whole head, we decided to go even a good bit shorter in celebration of warm summer weather approaching, and the resulting cut was excellent - perfectly balanced, even, and flattering of my head's shape (insofar as much as that is possible - more like hiding my head's flaws as much as possible). I very much appreciated his attention to detail and willingness to spend extra time going over my cut again to bring it exactly to my preferences. I always appreciate it when a barber skillfully wields a straight razor, and a few quick (and painless - not always the case with some barbers!) swipes and he had the bit around my ears was crisped up. But that wasn't all - I felt a bit of hot lather on the back of my neck and a few more quick swipes of the razor to get my neckline clean. I thought that was a very nice touch, and the warm lather certainly felt nice. Through it all, he (and I'm sorry, he told me his name twice but I can't remember it at the moment) kept a light but knowing touch. As well, he let me simply enjoy the experience - we talked a little about my job and his family, but he didn't push me for conversation like some barbers can. I appreciated that, as sometimes I just want to relax in the chair. And for all that PLUS a beard trim, he charged less than just a plain (mediocre) cut at Great Clips! Will definitely be back. 4.8/5 stars.

Chad is so easy to talk to! He remembers things we talked about the last time I was there…read more I always get a great haircut even when Chad was on vacation, I got a great hair cut!

Jonah is the best barber! Great service and a clean cut. Highly recommend this shop! Check it out!read more

Received a couple haircuts from Travis and they were okay, but the last one my sides still had…read morevisible lines where he failed to blend. I was very disappointed in my haircut and prices were raised the same day! Moved on to another local barbershop in Mount Joy and have been pleased ever since. Would not recommend.

Called the same day and he (Travis, I believe) got me in. Nice fella, chatty but not obtrusive…read more Gave a quick clean cut and left looking top notch. Really knew his way around the barber chair. It's a new school barber shop without the hipster feel. Very tidy, no attitude, good prices. I'll be back for sure.