Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Shelly's Pizza

    3.5 (2 reviews)
    ModeratePizza

    Shelly's Pizza Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Shelly's Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    16 years ago

    The pizza was pretty good, but the owner is too cheap to run the air conditioner. It's worth the trip to Ft. Branch or Princeton to eat.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of J M.
    0
    3
    0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 106 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Joe's Pizza - Half Greek half a deluxe style pizza with no sauce. Very delicious!!!!

    Joe's Pizza

    4.4(24 reviews)
    38.0 mi
    $$

    I'm from Columbus, Ohio where we know a thing or two about a thing or two. Winning traditions and…read morePizza. So I found myself in Onley, Illinois on a Tuesday night. Hungry. Tired. And did I mention hungry. Based upon some recommendations I came in and wanted to see if the spot was what I wanted and it delivered. Well I did not have the pizza deliver but well you know. In a single room I walked in and found the spot crowded but still had a space for me. I sat down and was greeted promptly. Ordered some toasted ravioli and then followed up with a thin crust Joes Deluxe. Ravioli arrived and a whiff told me things my sight could not discern. Aromatic equated to delightful. At first sight this must have been made in house. A bite. Come on man. Packing a serious punch. Dipped in the accompanying sauce meatier à la plentiful. I devoured the order. Then the pizza arrived. Let me pause here. The toppings underneath the cheese. Is it possible they were sautéed? For me??? The sausage just spicy enough to keep it interesting. The pepperonis bathed in a sweetness of saucy perfection . Is that hints of basil, simmered perfection? Maybe a family tradition and the only way they could figure out to make it. Like it was a real functioning kitchen. The prep line was not just any prep line. Like Leonardo didn't have just an ordinary paint studio. This was not a Ford pizza factory. They are making some serious Maserati's up in this piece. The ambience. Circa Pizza Hut 1972 or so. I loved every second of it. Thank You for being true to the art, true to the best pizza in town, to the heart of what makes a pizzeria a place where the town gathers even on a Tuesday night.

    Talk about some of the best pizza and pasta around. This place is amazing. The sauce is a little…read moresweet which makes it different then most. Do a joboli or any of their pizzas. Their bosco sticks with the red sauce and cheese mix is great.

    Photos
    Joe's Pizza - Toasted meat ravioli with marinara

    Toasted meat ravioli with marinara

    Joe's Pizza - Joe's deluxe, thin crust

    Joe's deluxe, thin crust

    Joe's Pizza - Joe's deluxe, thin crust

    See all

    Joe's deluxe, thin crust

    Sandy's Pizza - Pizza !

    Sandy's Pizza

    2.8(46 reviews)
    6.5 mi
    $$

    The service was great. Melissa was a real good and attentive waitress. I tried the jumbo wings,…read morethey are smoked and seasoned with 15 choice of sauce or dry rub. They were really tasty but not served hot. I also had a side salad. It was served in to go container. It would've been nicer if it would've been in a bowl instead of a clamshell container since I was dining in. The cheesy breadsticks were really good. Two sauces for a nice touch. They have Pepsi products. The dining room has a great field to a lot of nostalgic old store, signs and old grocery store signs and gas station signs. The wood walls are a nice touch to make it feel really homie and the dining room was really warm on a cold night.

    This is your stereotypical local food place that gets by on its former reputation. I literally just…read morestood at the counter while 3 young kids were too concerned with packing things up to even acknowledge a customer. I know for sure two of them 100% knew I was there but didn't care. I finally had to ask can I get some help and If anyone was actually working tonight. I'm sure I was called some names but that was ridiculous. One went to get someone finally did she apologize no of course not. If it weren't for Toyota orders I can't imagine this place would ever make it. Now at one time probably around 10 years ago maybe not that long ago it was a great place. We never order from there just thought id give it a shot being so close but the service was just unreal. I'm sure they'll have a million excuses but that was blatant disregard. I recommend Bobes or Roscoes in Princeton. Follow-up, the owner claims they were training high school kids, last time I checked training involved instruction and mentorship. This wasn't a training issue this was a management issue it lack there of. Then recommended I buy a pizza place in princeton that closed and see how I do. If I were to own and run a business I wouldn't be making excuses for my incompetence and blaming high school kids for a customers bad experience in my establishment. As previously mentioned you would be in the same boat if it weren't for Toyota.

    Photos
    Sandy's Pizza - Decor

    Decor

    Sandy's Pizza - The JUMBO smoked wings were great. But not real hot.

    The JUMBO smoked wings were great. But not real hot.

    Sandy's Pizza

    See all

    Shelly's Pizza - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...