I figure since I referenced Plato's in my Hut No. 8 review, I should weigh in on Plato's for…read morecomparison. I've been going to Plato's stores across the country for over ten years, mostly for selling. It's how I get money to buy new stuff on my limited budget. I was very happy when they came to Anchorage.
First thing you'll notice when walking in is that this place is crammed with stuff. Every nook has clothing displayed in it. It's a bit overwhelming for my shopping style. I mean, I like to browse, but I'm not much of a committed digger. So, that's a bit of a downside for me and one of the reasons I prefer the Hut.
Also, as other reviewers note, their clothes are inexpensive, way more so than you'll find at local consignment places, which is great for basics, of which they have a ton (ranging from tees to leggings to jeans to shoes). Old Navy and Gap are common brands. There's some outside gear, too, especially exercise wear, which can be so expensive when new.
They have young trendy stuff, à la Wet Seal, American Eagle, etc. But as far as looking for unique but nicer clothes, like middle-road B.P. or Banana Republic, or higher-end designer type stuff, you're generally better off with consignment. Not always, but usually. Their jeans sometimes include some higher-ends brands: I've seen very affordable Seven for All Mankind there, though they were elf-sized. Once, I found a great Calvin Klein dress at a Plato's, but not in AK. The main point is you never know, so why not try?
With all they offer in inventory, I still almost never buy here because I find so little for all the browsing. I like selling there, but I agree that they can be inconsistent on buying (they've bought things from me that they once rejected, and their pricing is impossible to decipher). Try consigning first, and you'll make more. Then, take the rest to resale.
I'll keep Plato's on my rotation, especially until the Hut builds inventory, and it's worth checking out on your resale shopping journeys.
