Great prices and fair appraisals- the best I have seen in the northwest. I came here after getting…read morelow offers on bullion from two other shops and was glad I did. They have a larger selection of gold and silver items on display than other shops and the staff were very friendly as well! I will make this my number one coin and bullion shop going forward for sure. Thank you!

Very disappointed - significantly underpaid for silver I…read morebrought in a large silver collection that included: * 82 silver dimes * 247 silver quarters * 10 silver half dollars * 16 Morgan & Peace silver dollars * 40% Kennedy half dollars * War Nickels * 1 oz silver round They offered me only $3,814. When I asked the employee if this was his best offer, he replied, "This is my best offer." I later calculated the melt value of the silver they kept at approximately $5,100. That means they paid me roughly 75% of melt. Because of this experience, I will not be bringing in my much larger collection that I will soon inherit from my uncle. Very disappointed with Northgate Rare Coin Shop.

Frank and the crew at American Rare Coin & Gold are always honest and offer a great price!! Will…read moredefinitely come back!!!

From the owner: Guaranteed Highest Prices Paid - CASH! American Rare Coin & Gold specializes in large, rare coin…read morecollections- your place or ours. We are known to be exceptionally accurate and knowledgeable, as well as providing our clients with free appraisals. We are the only buyer that has a precious metal analyzer and we pay the highest prices guaranteed! Our services include: free appraisals, gold buying, jewelry buying, silver buying, and coin buying. Call or stop in today. We will pay you in cash, no checks! We will beat any competitor by at least 10%.

An excellent location for gold, silver and rare coins! The owner, Brenden, and his amazing staff…read more(Sarah) and their store mascot (Bam Bam the Bulldog) are incredible. They're personable, friendly and welcoming. Brenden will take the time to tell you about the coins and quote very reasonable prices. The Coin Market collection is consistently better than other nearby local coin shops. Sarah is awesome and very knowledgeable on coins and proof sets. We love coming here and conversing + seeing the amazing BamBam (a very friendly bulldog who greets you shortly after your arrival). Been to a lot of coin shops and this one is by far my #1. Location is near a couple of nice restaurants too. Keep it up!

Smooth transaction. Would use again. The Coin Market paid the highest price for gold.read more

Decent selection of gold and silver bullion for purchase at reasonable price. Would buy from again.read more

They are very nice and straight to the point love this store have done business with him for years…read morethey dont pay good for silver or gold but they sell at best price in town for sure great guy easy to deal with

Definitely worth stopping by , Kim was nice and helped me find a few new coins to add to the…read morecollection. Thank you !!

Took several items to this shop. We had a lot of different coins and other things. We weren't sure…read moreof the value of any of it. We did find we had several silver coins worth some money, and the owner, Kimberly Stober, was very knowledgeable and helpful. We would highly recommend this shop.

This is a honest to god local family owned jeweler that you can genuinely trust for everything and…read moreanything! Whether it's the owner Mike, or his son Mick, and Michael or micks Wife who's name I can't currently recall who helps there from time to time. Everyone there is honest, fair, caring, and best of all helpful! I genuinely could never think about going anywhere else because these people treat me like family and have become great friends with myself and everyone around me. I consistently recommend this shop to everyone I meet because of how kind and honest they are. It's nothing like a pawn shop and you could just tell the people here are filled with integrity. Love you guys thank you for all the awesome silver and gold products you guys have been amazing to me and my family. This review is the least I could do for all the great deals, repair service, and advice you have given me over the short time you have been in that nice little shop. God bless you all and much love! ~D

Buyer Beware. I purchased foreign currency banknotes which turned out to be counterfeit xerox…read morecopies. Filed a complaint with a Kitsap County Sheriff and a lawsuit in court in Illinois where the package was delivered. I obtained the judgment against Silverdale Jewely and Coin on 5/14/2026 for $666.96 (2026SC1006) however the judgment was ignored and not paid. When I inquired about the payment of the judgment my phone was blocked. Next stop, filing a motion for discovery of assets and subpoena the management under oath. If they ignore it will file a writ of bodily attachment which will require them to present to court in person. Failure to do so will result in an arrest warrant issued under the Illinois statutes. This all you need to know what the Silverdale is and how it does business.

About a month ago, I went into Bayside, coin and jewelry to sell a gold necklace and some silver…read morecoins. He said that silver wasn't selling now due to some thing with the refinery, so I set them down on the counter while he assessed the gold necklace he offered me amount that I trusted him with giving me a true value. I found out later that it was way under them. Anyway I didn't do my due diligence so anyway it's my fault too but I'm not the one who stole when he paid me he laid out the money and I wanted him to recount it and when he did the $20 bill fell out in the middle I believe he was trying to pass $20 is $100 bill when I was leaving I noticed the coins were at on the counter and I assumed I put them in my bag when I got home they were not there there's only one other place it could be in that was their store I called them and they had a big resistance to my claim they finally agreed to show me the video when I came in it was blurry and black-and-white and her finger was extracting some of the view and also her fingers was on the air where I could probably see what happened I mentioned that and she just went on ignoring me I left very unsatisfied so I called and asked if I can bring someone with me to look at the video together as I've seen that video before and it was very sharp and in color and I knew I saw something on was on the area where I could probably see whether the quee I called back and said I wanted to bring someone with me to watch the video I believe they took a vantage of me because I'm a senior and they probably didn't think I would be aware of what was happening they didn't want me to bring any buddy else they were very rude and they have absolutely no customer service ability I looked on the stock market yesterday and the value of the silver coins were $87 each so they were value as close to $1000 and there's really nothing I could do about it. I talked to a few people about this and they said well they've changed management. But this is a family business my best guess is that they switch managers managements between the family, which makes it looks like it was under new management and you can trust them I think when it gets too hot, they put managements name in another relatives, leaving the impression that it would be a better.

I had a fair amount of coins, silver dollars, jewelry I had inherited from both my parents. It was…read morefinally time to organize and depose of these items. I really wasn't looking forward to the task. At first, I took some collections of medallions my mother had collected over decades. I was given a direct, informative description of every item. It was delivered in a polite, but concise manner, pleasingly direct. They told me what it was worth and what they would pay. I accepted their offer, which I thought was very fair. I was impressed. Over the next 4 months, I took more and more items to them.... more, jewelry, silver dollars, etc. In the end, I think we did somewhere around $10k worth of business together. I was very impressed, pleased with them. Quality organization!.

Fabulous service. Very experienced buyer. I was happy with the price they gave me and plan to take…read moremore silver for an estimate.

Nice people that work here with great customer service I was offered a amount for jewelry but a…read moreman that frequently goes there to sell asked to look at my jewelry. He told me that I would be able to get way more at a pawn shop so I left without selling. I went to many other places and they were not even close to what I was offered here!!!