This was my first time at Cassidy's. The interior was super clean and there was a decent selection…read moreof fresh fish, shrimp, scallops, and oysters. They also have sauces, marinades, and lemons for you to season your seafood of choice. I had major sticker shock as I'm only used to buying fish from the grocery store. The prices here for seafood are a premium. However, I trust that buying fish this way supports your local fisherman, is ethical, and is much fresher than what you'd ever get from the grocery store (most likely frozen before) My friends and I decided on tilefish as we all have never tried it. It did NOT disappoint. It had a nice "chew" to it, and it picked up the flavors of lemon, salt, pepper, and blackening seasoning so well. If it's a special occasion or you just want to buy fresh fish directly on the island, give Cassidy's a try!

Let me start by saying I have always LOVED Cassidy's--both the quality of the fish and the service…read more But today, I got real attitude from one of the guys, to the point that it upset me. I said I didn't love the way they cut my halibut (long thin strip). I was nice, not angry. He snapped at me and said: "What do you want me to do?" Now meanwhile I've bought Haibit from them 20 times. Mean guy who has clearly never heard "the customer is always right."

Ahearns was always our tried and true place to get fresh seafood for decades. Sadly, not anymore…read more it all started with the Manhattan clam chowder. The intense fishy smell as I heated it should have clued me in. One bite and it went into the garbage. The usually fresh, firm and delicious wild caught cleaned shrimp were mushy after cooking and a bit stinky as well. They were "edible" but we couldn't face the leftovers. The snow crab legs were frozen and when cooked, turned out to be thin and with very little meat...$150+ later, Ahearns is a thing of the past for us.

Ahearn's was always excellent in the past. I bought scallops there today. The price was written as…read more22.99 a pound. I was charged 29.99 a pound. Whatever... They didn't smell like the sea when I opened the container. I patted them dry to grill. They had a weird sheen on them. Upon putting them in a cast iron pan on the grill, they expelled a lot of water, did not caramelize and shrank a lot. Seems like they soak them in water to jack up the price. Looks like this fish market has down downhill. I was also over charged for the cod I bought today. Too bad. I didn't buy flounder. It was cod and the display price was 13.99

Fabulous, fresh seafood! Mussels were beautifully prepped as well as the clams…read more The stuffed clams and crab cakes were delicious! Such a pleasure to prepare and serve to guests at my dinner party!

Bought some New England clam chowder twice now both times hardly any clams mostly potatoes you…read morecould do better at the gateway Both times I mentioned this to the workers there and the owner was in earshot and he just ignored it I don't know where these people are getting five star reviews from Just goes to show you that this is a tourist area and people are happy with anything even bad Coffee

The seafood was amazing and the I loved the ambiance. Best seafood I had this summer.read more

Absolutely love this place. The fish is fresh people are well mannered just the only place I'll go…read morebuy fish. This is the one go here. Trust me.

1/2 stuffed lobsters are our favorites! Crab cakes are always fresh and delicious! Great serviceread more

If you are looking for a no nonsense off the beaten path old fashioned seafood place get here. We…read morehad a wonderful time at Seadogs which is the restaurant attached to Skipper's. Loved everything about this place even the outhouse. Food was delicious and service was excellent. Prices are good for quality and quantity. Can't wait to go back. Enjoy.

***** 5-stars. From my experience, the best American seafood restaurant in the state and quite…read morepossibly in the lower 48. If you find yourself at the shore and only have time for one restaurant, this is the ONE! Others may have incorporated the concept of trawler-to-table, where restaurant-owned vessels harvest the daily menu specials, but AOF has perfected it. They have an adjoining fish market where you can review the catch and board of fare, and see what appeals to you. I was very impressed with the freshness, variety, and quality (including many deep water cold Atlantic species including cod, ling, monkfish, plus mussels, oysters, etc.) Service was exemplary, execution was flawless, and taste was sublime. Setting is natural, old school, lots of local character and family friendly. Chowder and bisques 5 star Salads 5 star Bread 5 star Entrees 5 star Desserts 5 star Everything 5 star Recommend you come early for dinner or late for lunch because everyone knows the quality here and 2-3 hour wait during peak season is not uncommon (oh yeah, and should you have to, the wait is more than worth it) Mahalo for reading my review.

As with many NJ shore dining spots in summer, this one had an over one-hour wait. Instead we opted…read moreto order to go and dine in the back yard of the Point Pleasant Beach house rental. Among the samplings were the lobster bisque, lobster roll, fried calamari, bang-bang shrimp, fisherman's platter, and the corn dog made with lobster instead of a hot dog. A good time was had by all. Sorry no photos, or comments on service, or ambiance given it was take out. Can only say the food was good and travelled pretty well.

my family and I ate dinner we got at A1 seafood tonight. We got fresh flounder and crabcakes and…read morethey were absolutely delicious. One of the best meals I've had this year. the owners gave me suggestions on cooking and it came out soooo good.

I've been using them for my holiday seafood for years. Get my clams, lobster tails, crabs and…read moreshrimp platters from them for thanksgiving and Christmas and they never disappoint!!

Server Rihanna was very nice. Tuna nachos and hush puppies on point. The whole reason I came there…read morethough, the hot lobster roll, was a disappointment. Pathetic small portion. Complained to server about it and she confirmed she's heard the same from other customers about the drop off in portion size over last few years. Probably going across the street to Atlantic for rolls going forward. And that missing bite in pic was mostly bread which actually tasted good.

Cute little fish shanty by the water in Point Pleasant. The food was great and the service was…read morefriendly. This has a great low-key vibe with a real fishing type of decor. The area is great. We had a lobster roll, New England clam chowder, Manhattan clam chowder, swordfish bites, and brussels sprouts, with bacon and Parmesan, and two unsweetened iced teas. Everything was wonderful. We highly recommend the swordfish bites, they were literally fantastic. You can sit inside or outside, we opted for outside because they had shady little nooks where you could sit that had fans and it was so cool and comfortable. I could've sat there for hours. This is a BYOB. We had also visited the other point lobster house that is in the walkable town a few blocks away and that is a bar so it's not a BYOB. Just something to keep in mind the spot that's by the water you need to bring your own wine.

I was happy with the food! BUT 17.00$ for a tito and club soda is high way robbery! Meanwhile the…read moreowners own bums and berkley steak house in the same area! It's a shame when restaurant owners take advantage! I won't be back!

Great outdoor area with a bar and live entertainment. It's a dog friendly place. They have special…read moretreats for the dogs, too. Lots of sandwich choices on the menu. They also have a variety of pizzas and salads to choose from. It's the perfect spot to spend on a summer evening after a day at the beach. I tried the shrimp po boy with a side salad. Sandwich was good. The bread was soft. It had lettuce tomato and red onions. The shrimp was crispy. The sandwich was missing either tartar sauce or an aioli sauce. The sandwich was bland. I also ordered the Old Bay chips. They were crispy and full of flavor. The hostesses were friendly and we were seated right away. Our server was friendly and checked in often. Parking is available on the street. The food prices were reasonable. In order to give them a higher rating I'll will have to try other items on the menu.

We came to Tuckerton to celebrate our friends' birthday! Someone recommended Sunset Seafood. I have…read moresoft spot for any place that immediately brings you fresh bread with olive oil. So they had me at bread. The strawberry salad was a special that night and it was special. Dressing arugula is an art and they have technique. The crab legs were delish. Staff was on point. Will return.

Beautiful views of the bay but not all seats get that view simply because the dining room has seats…read morethat don't quite have that view. We showed up without resevations and somehow snagged one, but I'd suggest if you want that view, call in advance. The service was prompt, reasonably fast and accommodating of a well behaved four year old. While there were three adults dining, we all ordered fish or shell fish or pasta with fish and shell fish, there's some steak or chicken entrees too. Fresh oysters were just that, clean and fresh. The linguine with white clam sauce had lot of clams and al dente linguini but was surprisingly bland. Broiled dishes were nicely done. The fish of the fish and chips were flavorful without being greasy but the chips were disappointing. Given the view, service and food, overall fairly priced. Worth a visit if your looking for that package.