The food is good BUT watch your back when dealing with the manager!!!! online…read more He has ripped me off a few times now. Once charged me twice for a meal and said it was my credit card's doing and the card said they put it through twice. And again tonight, I ordered TWO meals the same (I have the receipt) via UberEats and got two different meals. I phoned and the manager said I was wrong, the order he sent was correct. I HAVE THE RECEIPT! I was charged for the two exact meals! What happened to the customer is always right? ESPECIALLY when they are!

The only good food to eat was the soup. The batter on fish…read moren chips is too thick it's undercooked. One could still get the gritty raw batter. The fries on poutine seems to be pre-frozen and crumble when just held. The gravy is very thin and not hot enough to melt the cheese. Good service and nice setting overall.

Great food everyone enjoyed what they had. Fish & chips,…read morepeanut butter burger (sounds funny but tasted great), egg plant zucchini lasagna. Dillion was a hoot & everyone was Canada NICE! Little place inside with a nice patio right on the water.

Surly Mermaid in Sidney is so nice! Love the patio. It overlooks the pier and boardwalk which is…read moregreat for people watching and getting some fresh breeze from the ocean. The atmosphere is fun and welcoming, the staff were friendly, and the food was good. We had the poh boy, salmon burger and it comes with fries. The food in my opinion is a tad on the greasy side... but regardless now we know what it's like. We'll definitely be coming back the next time we're in Sidney. Highly recommend checking it out!

What a great late lunch! Here's the deal. My wife and I rode our e-bikes from Victoria to Sidney…read moreand knew we wanted to have lunch before heading back. It did not disappoint. The place is small but has great views both inside dining and outside dining. Right on the water. Downtown Sidney. Work class view. We were treated and swerved by two young, friendly, and helpful ladies. The crab cakes and chowder was perfect. The Cobb salad was ok: good taste but a relatively small serving with not a lot loaded on. For $24 one should get a fairly hefty salad. But heck, it was still good taste. The salad serving size is the only thing keeping it from being a 5. This is a great spot. Go!

Love the ambiance and view of water. Fabulous crab cakes!…read moreSeafood chowder is also delcious!

Great service, drinks and the food was all yummy! Order the burger and side caeser salad. Ignore…read morethe negative reviews!

This was one of the worst restaurants I've ever been to. After a beautiful day at Burchart Gardens,…read morewe decided to end the day having dinner at a restaurant on the water. I ordered 2 fish tacos for $5 a piece and they were literally 2 bites each and were absolutely awful! The fish was mushy and almost nonexistent. I also ordered a California roll that came 10 minutes after we had finished our meal. I ended up canceling it because I didn't want to eat alone. My boyfriend ordered a shrimp salad for $28. It was a small mediocre salad with about 2 tablespoons of what looked and tasted like canned shrimp. I don't know how this establishment stays in business!

An incredible seafood paradise. Seafood sourced directly from locals by passionate, knowledgeable…read moreOwner Operators - and as specialists they are able to access some unique offerings. The smoked salmon is fantastic (and highly addictive, you have been warned) - I like the Mad Dog Mix smoked salmon. Do not hesitate!!!

This place sells the most amazing smoked salmon crack on the planet. You can get it plain or…read moresweetened with garlic. Small fish market conveniently off the highway. We buy several pounds at a time, freeze them, and savor them. Goes great with a little cream cheese or just plain. Always a hit as an appetizer at a dinner party. Maybe you shouldn't try them, just say no now and avoid the addition.

This is a great place to buy raw or cooked crab spot prawns and oysters for your boatread more

How can you beat fresh seafood on the Marina dock? Get your own LOL! Check it out, and enjoy!!read more

I wanted sockeye salmon this year for the freezer. I like the idea of not having to wash cut and…read morewrap my own fish. I can guarantee you I clean them better then they would (only because I spend more time on them) and to cut them I prefer larger pieces for baking so that isn't a big deal. But it takes time to clean up the mess (not that bad) So I thought I'll get them from 1fish2fish. But when I seen they want 18.00 a pound I said no way. I can buy sockeye for 10.00 per lb. So they are saying they want 8.00 a lb for cutting and wrapping? Not from me they are getting this price. You know if you would have not got so greedy with your prices you would have alot more business. Or maybe you are and the people that are paying this price have too much money in there wallets :) Sorry to say until your prices come down I will not be a customer. I gave you are 2 star only because you product is good :) So if you don't mind the prices then go for it!

We moved up to Ferndale Washington in 2022. It's been hard for us to find decent Lobster sold…read moreanywhere locally. Our Yelp search led us to 1 Fish 2 Fish and now we order our Lobsters with them ever since. We eat Lobster 3 to 4 times a year for celebrations and have never been disappointed with the quality. Worth the 45 min drive one way across the border. Would recommend them in a heart beat to anyone looking for quality fresh seafood. Several cuts above anything that you'd at a regular market. The word is "fresh".

Stopped by for spot prawns and some crab... not only was he helpful, but overall customer service…read morewas outstanding! Ended up with some amazing halibut cheeks on the house! Totally worth the stop, we can't wait to devour all this!

Took a drive and saw the sign! Had to stop in and see if I could get myself a seafood treat. Lucky…read moreme, the owner and fisherman responsible for catching the items in the tank was manning the shop. Thank you Matt! We chatted a bit about the seafood and interesting chocolate bars. Thank you for your service. A former military serviceman. This is a locally run business with locally caught seafood. I am a bit squeamish about cooking and cleaning my own crabs. Happened to be one left that had been cooked and cleaned. In the freezer were speciality meats too. A large parking lot immediately out front. One way in! If you pass it, just go around the round a bout. For sure worth a stop and see to get some of the freshest seafood around. Run by a husband and wife team. I love supporting small businesses. Good vibes inside too. Little cute knock knacks of your looking for a special gift and some crab or shrimp. Treat yourself! SYOY.

Fantastic seafood stop! They've got an amazing rule - If you see it in our cases not frozen, it…read morenever has been frozen. Freshness is their biggest asset! Man those shrimp were fantastic. Don't expect to come to black rock for a wine and dine experience, this is pretty much a spot to pick up fresh boiled seafood, and take it to a picnic spot, or back home, but it's some of the sweetest, freshest tasting shrimp around. Looking forward to our next visit!

Popular seafood pickup spot in Anacortes…read more Parking is easy as there's enough space for 6 cars. Pretty transactional. Don't expect bubbly customer service like Shrimp Shack. We come here for Dungeness crab. Shrimp are small but good. We usually drive to Deception Pass State Park, find a table, and eat our seafood there. We bring our usual party utensils, seafood tools, gloves, and rice. Make sure you check the Jet Carrier Training Schedule. It can get really loud if you don't time it right.

I do not eat tomato soup and was told to try it WOW! It's more like a rich sauce. I also had the…read morekind of Blue sandwich and it was great. My husband had a different sandwich and both were AMAZING. We started with the warm mixed Mediterranean Olives, soooo tasty and NOT salty. The service was excellent and the restaurant was very chill. Loved this, we will be back. I wish I would have taken photos!

Worth a visit for sure…read more A talented couple bring their Ontario foodie experience to the island and create an awesome Bistro.