Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Sandy's Custom Cakes

    5.0 (2 reviews)

    Sandy's Custom Cakes Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Sandy's Custom Cakes

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    28 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Erin M.
    54
    11
    9

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Bake Me A Cake Etc - The cake I got

    Bake Me A Cake Etc

    4.6(8 reviews)
    65.0 mi
    $$

    I picked this provider because the reviews suggested that she was good and her pictures also showed…read morethat she has talent in unique cake designs at a very fair price. BUT Communication: I was having trouble getting information out of her and had to ask several questions to get an answer. Response time took forever and the responses were very short UNTIL I started to speak about payment then everything was fine. style: Don't get my wrong the cake was pretty close (the two stars) We had a Taco Bell themed party and the inspiration cake was fake Taco Bell packs and "sauce" which I assumed would be made out of JELLY. NO, she put actual taco bell packets (did tell me she had to use real ones) and actual Taco Bell sauce on our cake that dried and looked disgusting. The very front of the cake was messed up. I was going to try and fix it myself when I got home but I was afraid I would make it worse. The whole thing just felt sloppy. Taste: This cake was not good. The layers of actual cake was thick and dry and the "filling" was so thin. The icing was thick that almost everyone picked most of it off and there was so much left over. And don't get me started on the taco sauce and the taste of that . Overall, I was very disappointed and will be going somewhere else next time.

    Very fast and great customer service!! The cake was amazing!! Very delicious and beautifully made…read more Definitely recommend

    Photos
    Bake Me A Cake Etc - The inspiration photo

    The inspiration photo

    Bake Me A Cake Etc - The beautiful rose like cupcakes/works of art Erinn created.

    The beautiful rose like cupcakes/works of art Erinn created.

    Bake Me A Cake Etc - Easter Strawberry Shortcake

    See all

    Easter Strawberry Shortcake

    Emily Wheeler Custom Cakes - Wedding cake

    Emily Wheeler Custom Cakes

    5.0(5 reviews)
    25.9 mi

    Emily is not only kind, but she is a true visionary when it comes to cakes and cookies! She is…read moreprofessional, Timely, and just all-around a great Businesswoman! We have ordered cookies from her for a housewarming gift, and didn't have a clue as to what to get. Well it was Emily to the rescue! She had the idea to do cookies in the shape of keys, and also a front door with a wreath on it!! Since I'm not very creative, she was able to just put it ALL together (even the colors!) for me just right off the bat!! They couldn't have been more adorable, and everyone loved their sugar cookies; I felt like the hero all night, and I didn't even do anything but buy them, haha! We'd also gotten a simple cake from Emily a couple years ago for my friend's first birthday party. It was only about 10 people, so my friend didn't want anything over-the-top; she just wanted a really small cake that would be cute for pics. My friend's dad had passed away right before this, and he was a fireman, so Emily created the perfect little cake, designed perfectly for her little guy. On top of that, it was chocolate and delicious!! We've also gotten her holiday cookies-- she sells out SUPER quickly, so make sure you place an order in time! We missed out one year because we waited until the last minute. They're the cutest things I've ever seen!! We will ALWAYS be patronizing Emily, and we feel lucky to have our "own dessert chef" from now on! (Haha, sounds silly, but Emily has made us feel like family! ) I'm going to come back to add pics / edit if I can.. I don't have them toward the front of my phone and it could take hours to find them, but I will eventually!! Thank you Emily Wheeler Custom Cakes- you've made our lives so much sweeter!!

    Emily created a sweet table for my wedding this past year, August of 2015, and she did such an…read moreamazing job! She did my best friend's wedding as well, both themes very different, but both turned out amazing! She was such a pleasure to work with. We kept in touch throughout my planning process and she easily made adjustments, and worked with our budget! My sweet table consisted of customized sugar cookies, cake pops, and lemon bars, as well as other assorted candies to tie in with my pastel color theme (light blue, pale pink, and peach). She supplied everything! Cake stands, candy jars, scoopers etc! It turned out wonderful! My guests still rave about the cake pops! I highly recommend her!

    Photos
    Emily Wheeler Custom Cakes - Wedding cake

    Wedding cake

    Emily Wheeler Custom Cakes
    Emily Wheeler Custom Cakes - Wedding cake

    See all

    Wedding cake

    Staggeringly Delicious

    Staggeringly Delicious

    5.0(1 review)
    19.6 miGermantown

    I'm a big fan of Glow Worm Play Cafe. For so many reasons. Perhaps one of the most unacknowledged…read moreperks of Glow Worm is that it's attached to Staggeringly Delicious. One of the biggest misconceptions I've encountered in conversation about Glow Worm is that people don't realize that while being incredibly convenient for Glow Worm customers, Staggeringly Delicious is an entirely separate establishment. You don't need to be at the play cafe to get some of what truly is staggeringly delicious. The chocolate chip cookies, arguably the best in the city, seem to be one of the best kept secrets in Louisville. They're made with brown butter, triple chocolate, and topped with just the right amount of sea salt. I'm a big fan of blueberry and lemon desserts, but everything everyone else does, well...they just seems to do better. Their frittatas are phenomenal. It seems like pretzel buns are becoming more and more popular, but having them made fresh is just superior. The breakfast panini and turkey panini are crunchy, gooey, savory, and hit the spot every single time. Every time I order, I'm satisfied. It's consistent. It's affordable. I don't feel guilty when I eat there. I don't feel guilty when I feed it to my family. Sadly, that's becoming hard to come by. If you're near the Highlands and you're jonesing for a simple lunch or a treat, put this place on your radar. Don't be dissuaded by the play cafe sign out front. The play cafe is absolutely second-to-none, but you don't need a kid or play date to enjoy Staggeringly Delicious.

    Photos
    Staggeringly Delicious
    Staggeringly Delicious
    Staggeringly Delicious

    See all

    Sugar Fashion Cakes

    Sugar Fashion Cakes

    5.0(3 reviews)
    62.5 mi

    Working with Sarah Roberts was super easy and she has a pretty simple process to get your orders…read morein. She does not have any limits to what she can create. For our wedding, we ordered 70 parfaits in 4 assorted flavors that were absolutely phenomenal. She even created some for us prior to the wedding for us to have a tasting of what to expect. We booked with her a year in advanced, and we found this to be ideal to plan ahead. All parfaits were ready at the time she said they were going to be. She does deliver for a fee, but we opted to have someone pick them up instead since it didn't make sense to us to have it delivered. Everyone's needs are different. What we ordered and the quality of the product matched. She was really nice to allow us to pay over time for our items instead of one installment as well. She works with you and understands that everyone has different needs. If I ever have a need to use her again, there is no question about it - I will definitely be reaching out.

    I contacted Sarah to make a 90th birthday cake for my mom. I was able to send her a link to the…read morerose gold party decorations that I ordered off of Amazon and she was able to make the cake match perfectly. She actually made two cakes...one was the number nine and the other was the number zero. We selected chocolate and white for the flavors. Let me tell you, it turned out amazing and my mom was so surprised she cried. Everyone said it was the most delicious cake they had ever tasted. You won't be disappointed if you order from Sarah! I'd give her a rating of 10 if I could.

    Photos
    Sugar Fashion Cakes - Custom chocolate cake and chocolate icing - per request from the birthday girl!

    See all

    Custom chocolate cake and chocolate icing - per request from the birthday girl!

    Sandy's Custom Cakes - customcakes - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...