Awesome realtor. He was our realtor on our first home here in Apple Valley and he was honest with…read moreus and was with us every step of the way. From the time we started looking until we signed the papers. When we called and said we wanted to look at a certain house at a certain time he made it work so we could see them on our schedule. It only took a couple of months and we were in a home we love. You won't go wrong with him.

From the owner: Scott Craigo, ABR of the Sam Miller Real Estate Team offers unparalleled service to ALL clients in…read morethe Knox County Ohio real estate market. Your complete satisfaction with our service and representation is our number one priority. Scott serves the entire Knox County Ohio real estate market including the communities of Apple Valley, Bladensburg, Butler, Cardington, Centerburg, Danville, Fredericktown, Gambier, Howard, Martinsburg, Mount Liberty, Mount Vernon, Utica and Walhonding. Whether you are considering buying a home, selling a home or both, we know this area inside and out.

It's refreshing to work with a realtor who truly has her clients' best interests at heart. She's…read moreknowledgeable, professional, and always takes the time to listen and present the facts about each property and the current market conditions. There's no pressure--just the tools and information a buyer needs to make an informed decision. She understands that buying a home in today's fluctuating market can be stressful, so she's completely transparent and honest when offering her opinions or advice. I've bought several properties through Sibley and will continue to do so to grow my investment portfolio. I've also recommended her to family and friends because I trust she'll always have their backs, and it's great to see their positive experiences reflected in their own reviews. She's someone you can count on!

From the owner: I specialize in helping Sellers, Buyers and Client Relocation in the Knox County and surrounding…read morearea. As a 15 year local veteran, I know the area and the market well. Your complete satisfaction with my service and representation is my number one priority.

Drew Smith was outstanding from start to finish. He helped sell my home and guided me through…read morebuying a new construction home at Apple Valley Lake. Drew's knowledge of the local market and the Apple Valley Lake community was invaluable. He priced my home perfectly, marketed it aggressively, and got it sold quickly. On the buying side, he helped navigate the new construction process communicating with the builder, explaining timelines, reviewing details, and making sure nothing was overlooked.

I would like to express my deep disappointment with Drew Smith and share my negative experience…read moreworking with them. We sought their recommendation for a real estate professional and decided to work with someone they suggested. Unfortunately, our experience turned out to be highly unsatisfactory. After submitting an offer on a house, we were informed that we were being considered as a backup offer. However, due to our preference for a different district, we made the decision to work with another agent after our contract with the agent and agency had expired. We openly communicated this decision when they checked in with us. In response, Drew reacted in an unprofessional manner. They wrongly accused us of breaking the law, despite the fact that our contract had already expired. To our surprise, they then proceeded to send us a termination notice, which was completely unnecessary under the circumstances. In an email explaining our position, we provided clear and concise reasoning, only to be met with dismissive behavior from Drew Smith. They claimed our email was too long and declared their refusal to read it. Furthermore, it is important to note that Drew continued to contact us persistently, even though we had clearly chosen to work with a different agent. This disregard for our decision and repeated attempts to engage with us demonstrated a lack of respect for professional boundaries. Considering the unprofessionalism and complete disregard for our choices displayed by Drew, we have decided to file a complaint against them with The Ohio Division of Real Estate & Professional Licensing. We strongly caution others to seek alternative real estate agents who prioritize their clients' needs and adhere to professional standards. A few things Mr.Smith does not disclose in his colorful way of responding to this review is that he had no reason or recourse to interact with us after we started working with the other agent. We did not agree to be a backup offer, that would require a written contract, which we never signed. The end of the conversation as he so quoted was after threatening to go after our current agent for the commission by looking at the auditor website for what house we would buy, stating several times that what we were doing was illegal, when he had no idea of when we signed a contact with another agent. Which of course was after ours expired with his colleague. Or that not even his colleague asked him to contact us, as per a voice mail stating that she has nothing to do with his actions. We had to tell him to terminate contact with us and that we were done with his agency, especially after the way he represented it.

We highly recommend Isabelle (Izzy) Trepkoski with Styer Real Estate Professionals! Izzy was our…read moreRealtor in the purchase of our Clintonville-Beechwold home, genuinely helping us navigate and understand a complex, changing real estate market and successfully finding us a home that met our specific needs in a highly desirable neighborhood. Izzy's expert negotiating skills went well above and beyond to get us to closing to everyones satisfaction all around. Izzy additionally provided experienced, professional guidance with our downsizing process, as well as connecting us with several professional contractors to consult with for desired updates (both an extra helpful bonus for certain!). In short, Isabelle Trepkoski's expert professional representation and guidance from start to finish with this process were invaluable and set us up for a successful transition to our new home!

She helped us out in 2024 when we were trying to move to Columbus and went out of her way. Despite…read moreusually not doing apartments, she helped us look using the realtor database and sent us not just those based on criteria we wanted but also people she trusted. She essentially charged us nothing for a lot of help we ultimately didn't use as we didn't migrate to Columbus. The very least she deserves is 5 stars.